Anyone here dig Jung? - TranceAddict Forums

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Canada - Toronto & Southern Ont.
-- Anyone here dig Jung?

Posted by Elendil on Feb-01-2011 05:10:

Anyone here dig Jung?

So I found myself (not surprisingly) struck by how relevant and utterly timeless this man's brilliant works really are as I made my way through "Modern Man In Search Of A Soul" and I found myself thinking: I wonder what my fellow TA's think about him?

Carl Jung was stunningly brilliant, and I don't think I've ever encountered a great thinker that I so personally valued. Over the past years - 5 or 6 now - he's been like a guide to me, helping me to navigate many treacherous scenarios that I've found myself in, allowing me to better understand the contents of my own mind and ultimately helping to shape the path of my adulthood. His works have made a profoundly positive impact on the direction that my life has taken, and if he were alive today, I'd wish nothing more than to shake his hand and thank him for his contribution to the tapestry of our collective experience.

Also brilliant: Edinger, "Ego and Archetype". Seriously. Check it out.

Anyways, just thought I'd through it out there.

Posted by Abercrombie on Feb-01-2011 13:53:

Last year I asked my Valentine to be my subconsious projection of the anima archetype.

I then spent valentine alone.

Posted by Elendil on Feb-02-2011 04:14:

quote:
Originally posted by Abercrombie
Last year I asked my Valentine to be my subconsious projection of the anima archetype.

I then spent valentine alone.

ALone? Or were you accompanied by your shadow... which just happened to make itself known at that key moment?

Posted by mnemonic. on Feb-02-2011 04:36:

I really need to pick up ego and archetype and finish it. the first few chapters blew my mind, but then I was busy with school and never got around to the rest.

Posted by Abercrombie on Feb-02-2011 04:42:

quote:
Originally posted by Elendil
ALone? Or were you accompanied by your shadow... which just happened to make itself known at that key moment?

lol... i guess we're the only psych geeks who got that...oh well, it's been a long time since university so a lot escapes me.

Posted by GGM on Feb-02-2011 17:32:

He among other philosophers are brilliant and extremely underutilized. It's a shame they don't make that mandatory material/classes in highschool or even simplify it for the elementary school level.

Posted by pozz on Feb-02-2011 23:29:

Why Jung over Freud?

Posted by Elendil on Feb-03-2011 04:57:

quote:
Originally posted by pozz
Why Jung over Freud?

I perceive Jung's perspective as a circle, encompassing the vastness and depth of the human mind and human mythology, whilst I perceive Freud's perspectives to be laser like, finite and ultimately piercing through darkness... yet leaving the darkness around it unexplored and subsequently a source of problematic confounding variables.

Jung's standpoints simply address my own subjective life experiences more accurately, hence I find him to be of more relevance to myself.

Regardless, I think a truly valuable approach is to examine both. Jung often remarked about the extremely important contributions Freud has made to the as still infantile state of psychological science - and it would be foolish to discount one for the other in entirety.

If you haven't read anything about Jung's theories and general investigations, I highly recommend!

Posted by pozz on Feb-03-2011 23:18:

Freud and Lacan are my interests. never ventured into reading Jung, but I'll check him out when i have the time. if i remember i'll revive this thread or pm you.