TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Producers Promotion
-- Best Melody Made So Far In 2013 ! Check It Out !

Best Melody Made So Far In 2013 ! Check It Out !

https://soundcloud.com/idj-m/djkidm-circus-original-mix

Moved to Producers Promotion.

Best melody according to you, maybe. Little noobie producers these days don't understand the concept of artistic objectivity. FAIL

quote:

Originally posted by Evolve140 Best melody according to you, maybe. Little noobie producers these days don't understand the concept of artistic objectivity. FAIL

Dude ur just a downer. Try thinking positive for once. All I've ever seen u post is whining and bitching. Didn't your mom teach you that if you have nothing nice to say. Don't say anything at all. And ya dude sick melody. What program do you use?

quote:

Originally posted by Lryso Dude ur just a downer. Try thinking positive for once. All I've ever seen u post is whining and bitching. Didn't your mom teach you that if you have nothing nice to say. Don't say anything at all. And ya dude sick melody. What program do you use?

FL Studio and thanks bro

quote:

Originally posted by Lryso Dude ur just a downer. Try thinking positive for once. All I've ever seen u post is whining and bitching. Didn't your mom teach you that if you have nothing nice to say. Don't say anything at all. And ya dude sick melody. What program do you use?

I completly agree with evolve here, this melody is completly generic. Sounds like something half the people here could pump out in a day or so. I could see SHM or axwell play this out I guess, but I think this sound will pass soon.

Constructive critisism shouldn't be taken personally.

This is a cool melody. Yes its generic but theres nothing wrong with that, its catchy.

I'd be very happy if someone compared my music SHM. I'd certainly take that as a compliment.

Nice track mate.

https://soundcloud.com/jtwbeats

quote:

Originally posted by sako487 I completly agree with evolve here, this melody is completly generic. Sounds like something half the people here could pump out in a day or so. I could see SHM or axwell play this out I guess, but I think this sound will pass soon. Constructive critisism shouldn't be taken personally.

true dat dude. it shudnt be taken personally. It does seem to be generic to what has been popular. But I think that's more related to the style of music that he is making. It is good to broaden ur horizons to more diverse styles

yea thanks guys , im just doing what i love .

quote:

Originally posted by DJKiDM yea thanks guys , im just doing what i love .

hell ya dude aren't we all haha keep it up

We kinda already have an avicci, who i dislike anyway, as for the melody, well its a matter of opinion kiddo, its kinda clean, but i'm just so tired of this shit, honestly... And i'm presuming you want some kinda gain out of this since you're posting this to a forum, so i'll say this, Be original...

I hate avicii. His set at ultra weekend 2 was very original but at the same time he took it too far and blended too genres that shud have never have happened.

i dont really like avicii , but i like making this style of music . but all i said was this was my best melody this summer .

Well isn't this a controversial track! Haha

I will say that the melody follows a pattern that several other tracks have charted with in recent times. It may be so that it is similar to others, but they each made their respective authors plenty of money, so I wouldn't hate on it for that reason only. Look at Prydz for instance, he produced 'Call On Me' for a couple of studio compressors. He set up a record label off the back of it.

So down to the actual review & critique:
I don't think much of the melody but the instruments used to achieve it fit with the genre - you certainly can't fault that. However, the section I prefer is the arpeg that begins at roughly 0:33 and nicely complements the chord triplet motif. If you developed this a little further, maybe it would stand out from the tracks that others are complaining about. I can't say I enjoy the strings, they are a little too dry, but then I don't really like many samples of strings so maybe just ignore this. You could add more strings in to thicken them and it might also improve them, to my ear at least.

I would also say that you could increase the lengths of your reverb tails especially on your fill samples. The best example of this is at 1:04, when there are no high frequency harmonics to overpower it's tail and it becomes more obvious. I think your kick may be cutting slightly too much out of your mix. The bottom end sounds a little overpowering, on these headphones at least. (I have also been guilty of this, just listen to my old mix of Man with the Red Face that I never bothered retweaking )

At 2:16 there is a rising lead that I was half expecting to turn into a second melody which would have given some much-needed variation. Maybe an idea you could develop. Arrangement sounds good and, although this is not a genre I personally enjoy, I did appreciate listening to your track.

Remember people, we are supposed to be a community of producers providing objective and constructive feedback to each other, with the aim of improving one another's music.

quote:

Originally posted by Mr Kre8 Well isn't this a controversial track! Haha I will say that the melody follows a pattern that several other tracks have charted with in recent times. It may be so that it is similar to others, but they each made their respective authors plenty of money, so I wouldn't hate on it for that reason only. Look at Prydz for instance, he produced 'Call On Me' for a couple of studio compressors. He set up a record label off the back of it. So down to the actual review & critique: I don't think much of the melody but the instruments used to achieve it fit with the genre - you certainly can't fault that. However, the section I prefer is the arpeg that begins at roughly 0:33 and nicely complements the chord triplet motif. If you developed this a little further, maybe it would stand out from the tracks that others are complaining about. I can't say I enjoy the strings, they are a little too dry, but then I don't really like many samples of strings so maybe just ignore this. You could add more strings in to thicken them and it might also improve them, to my ear at least. I would also say that you could increase the lengths of your reverb tails especially on your fill samples. The best example of this is at 1:04, when there are no high frequency harmonics to overpower it's tail and it becomes more obvious. I think your kick may be cutting slightly too much out of your mix. The bottom end sounds a little overpowering, on these headphones at least. (I have also been guilty of this, just listen to my old mix of Man with the Red Face that I never bothered retweaking ) At 2:16 there is a rising lead that I was half expecting to turn into a second melody which would have given some much-needed variation. Maybe an idea you could develop. Arrangement sounds good and, although this is not a genre I personally enjoy, I did appreciate listening to your track. Remember people, we are supposed to be a community of producers providing objective and constructive feedback to each other, with the aim of improving one another's music.

Thanks ! I apreciate this type of feedback , ill try out some of this .

nice work !! love the arp ...keep it up !!

quite possibly the worst piece of music I will ever vomit to

SENSATION WHITE PRESALE PASSWORD

Sensation: Ocean of White comes to AmericanAirlines Arena Friday, October 11 and Saturday, October 12!

Sensation is having an EXCLUSIVE presale starting Thursday, June 13th from 10AM - 10PM. Use the presale password OCEAN to get your tickets before anyone else! Click here to buy your tickets > Friday: http://bit.ly/11fBZ6q. Saturday: http://bit.ly/172VQ0w

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright © 2000-2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.