PvD-Autumn VS. Chicane-Autumn Tactics (Thrillseekers Mix): Which one do you prefer??

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Music Discussion
-- PvD-Autumn VS. Chicane-Autumn Tactics (Thrillseekers Mix): Which one do you prefer??

Posted by VisionsofPVD on Jan-16-2003 21:44:

PvD-Autumn VS. Chicane-Autumn Tactics (Thrillseekers Mix): Which one do you prefer??

As many of you may know, PvD was inspired to produce his track Autumn by Chicane's Autumn Tactics. Just curious about which one everyone prefers...I personally like Pvd-Autumn because its a little more driving and intense, where as Autumn Tactics is more soothing and mellow...

One interesting note: Over the past year, van Dyk has been playing Autumn Tactics rather than his own Autumn... perhaps because Chicane re-released it on Xtravaganza? Who knows, but one thing is for sure..Paul doesn't play Autumn very often...

Thankfully, it will be on his new production album!

Posted by DJ-Ande on Jan-16-2003 21:45:

there'z a poll forum for this type of battle, but my vote goes with chicane

Posted by arturob on Jan-16-2003 21:48:

both..

Posted by vmc on Jan-16-2003 22:12:

I prefer PVD - Autumn

Posted by tranceman78 on Jan-16-2003 23:44:

Autumn Tactics all the way.

Posted by Rakoon on Jan-16-2003 23:49:

I prefer Autumn more because it "completes" the melody of Autumn Tactics so to speak.

Posted by Floorfiller on Jan-16-2003 23:49:

chicane...no question about it...

Posted by Clyde77 on Jan-16-2003 23:59:

Autumn Tactics!!!!!!! but im not saying autumn is bad.

Posted by Kimmi on Jan-17-2003 00:17:

Autumn Tactics. Not just because it sounds better IMO, but because I don't agree with PvD going and being a "copy cat", for a lack of better words

Posted by Arbiter on Jan-17-2003 00:30:

Autumn Tactics... though I like the EoS mix over the Thrillseekers'

Posted by arturob on Jan-17-2003 00:32:

Posted by tc-fan on Jan-17-2003 04:27:

quote:
Originally posted by tranceman78
Autumn Tactics all the way.

helll yeah...the saltwater rmx is nice but original is the best

Posted by udham on Jan-17-2003 05:11:

Autumn gets my vote!

Posted by Miss Vandit on Jan-17-2003 06:00:

No question - Autumn all the way!!!

Pure genius!!!

Posted by TuanAnh213 on Jan-17-2003 06:14:

the thrillseekers remix of autumn tactics absolutely 0wns...so much emotion

Posted by Jeb on Jan-17-2003 06:39:

Pvd - autumn
i like the complexity of the beat

Posted by VisionsofPVD on Jan-17-2003 18:51:

Theres quite a difference between the two tracks, except for the one portion of the melody Paul decided to use in his track. I love the surreal vocals (sort of echoes) PvD used in his track, and if you've heard it live, its amazing!!!

Posted by breslin on Jan-17-2003 19:37:

PvD-Autumn, i love that track especially live when its pitched up a bit.

Posted by KoreanDJ on Jan-17-2003 21:06:

AUTUMN...

FEEL THE ENERGY!

Stevek

Posted by mavo on Jan-18-2003 04:27:

quote:
Originally posted by Kimmi
Autumn Tactics. Not just because it sounds better IMO, but because I don't agree with PvD going and being a "copy cat", for a lack of better words

quote:
Originally posted by Starfox
He didn`t copycat on Autumn, though it is more like a remake. So please, before you come here and "blah blah," read a little of past history

many greetings,

f0x

Wow why am i not surprise with foxy's reply...

AUTUM TACTICS no f***ing competetion if PVD wins this poll i shave my head bald

not bald soon,
ma-vo

Posted by undertensecond on Jan-18-2003 04:31:

pvd - autumn is a slight ahead of the other..

Posted by zolwik on Jan-18-2003 12:02:

PvD Autumn has better composition of melody then Chicane's
Just set on 3:50 minute --> That's it

Posted by DJ_Skaya on Jan-18-2003 13:56:

Re: PvD-Autumn VS. Chicane-Autumn Tactics (Thrillseekers Mix): Which one do you prefer??

quote:
Originally posted by VisionsofPVD
As many of you may know, PvD was inspired to produce his track Autumn by Chicane's Autumn Tactics. Just curious about which one everyone prefers...I personally like Pvd-Autumn because its a little more driving and intense, where as Autumn Tactics is more soothing and mellow...

One interesting note: Over the past year, van Dyk has been playing Autumn Tactics rather than his own Autumn... perhaps because Chicane re-released it on Xtravaganza? Who knows, but one thing is for sure..Paul doesn't play Autumn very often...

Thankfully, it will be on his new production album!

I ALWAYS WONDERED WHY THOSE TWO TRACKS SOUNDED THE SAME! Autumn's one of my favorite PvD (I guess I should say PvD and Chicane) Tunes, and I don't know why he doesn't play it. I guess its just not energetic and driving enough to throw in his sets. On the other hand, if he's really playing autumn tactics, that makes even less sense cuz thats an even less likely candidate for PvD play then Autumn!

Anyways, I win the moron of the week award

Posted by DJ_Skaya on Jan-18-2003 13:59:

Oh, in case my first post on the thread wasn't self explanatory enough, Autumn all the way

Posted by apostrophe on Jan-18-2003 14:07:

Chicane's autumn tactics is so peaceful... i think I prefer that, because well, right now, i am in that peaceful mood! pvd - autumn is quite the track though!