TA Track Of The Year 2002: Final 1

TranceAddict Forums (www.tranceaddict.com/forums)
- Track of the Year - 2002
-- TA Track Of The Year 2002: Final 1
Pages (2): [1] 2 »

Posted by JayD on Mar-17-2003 00:46:

TA Track Of The Year 2002: Final 1

You may vote 2 out of the 4 seen below.

01. Paul Oakenfold - Southern Sun
02. James Holden - Nothing
03. Gouryella - Ligaya
04. Solar Stone - Seven Cities 2002 (Armin van Buuren, Michael Woods, Solar Stone, Yunus Mixes)

JaY

Posted by whiskers on Mar-17-2003 01:08:

southern sun & nothing (nothing's gonna take #1, IMHO, although i haven't seen the other thread yet)

Posted by victor on Mar-17-2003 01:41:

2 + 4!!!!

Posted by LiquidX on Mar-17-2003 03:32:

1 & 4 !

Posted by noikeee on Mar-17-2003 09:46:

nothing and ligaya

Posted by CygnusX on Mar-17-2003 10:29:

Easy
Southern Sun & Ligaya
1 & 3

Posted by m0sh on Mar-17-2003 10:52:

01. Paul Oakenfold - Southern Sun
02. James Holden - Nothing

for sure

Posted by Lytchix on Mar-17-2003 12:52:

1 & 3

Posted by stijn on Mar-17-2003 15:46:

Please... don't let me choose between those beauties

Allright then... 1&2 (Hmz, also want to vote for ligaya... )

Posted by b|p|3m on Mar-17-2003 17:18:

Ligaya and Southern Sun.

Posted by daydreamer on Mar-17-2003 19:31:

southern sun all the way

Posted by robootz on Mar-17-2003 19:38:

Southern Sun & Nothing

Posted by Rising on Mar-17-2003 20:52:

1 and 2

Posted by Madjer on Mar-17-2003 23:50:

Hey JayD,

I couldn't believe that 'Plastic Boy - Silverbath' didn't do it to the SEMI's !
And after having done the math, I was even more confused, because 'Silverbath' clearly got the 2nd most of the votes !!!

Then came the illumination: Now I understood why my favourite song didn't make it! You're just counting which combo was most liked, which unfortunatelly isn't a fair vote at all ((

PLEASE, would it be possible to have the 2 SONGS which got the MOST VOTES WHEN YOU COUNT EACH SINGLE VOTE ?!!!
( and not the COMBO (of 2 songs) which got most votes )

---------------- Calcs for FAIR voting ---------------------
[madjer@rivaldo d2k]$ perl TA_voting.pl 65 33 56 10 63 29
Votes for track 1: 154 = (+65+33+56) (01. Paul Oakenfold - Southern Sun)
Votes for track 2: 138 = (+65+10+63)
Votes for track 3: 72 = (+33+10+29)
Votes for track 4: 148 = (+56+63+29) (04. Plastic Boy - Silverbath)
( Silverbath HAS GOT 10 VOTES MORE THAN 'J.Holden - Nothing' !!!! )

[madjer@rivaldo d2k]$ perl TA_voting.pl 39 37 60 35 38 36
Votes for track 1: 136 = (+39+37+60) (01. Gouryella - Ligaya)
Votes for track 2: 112 = (+39+35+38)
Votes for track 3: 108 = (+37+35+36)
Votes for track 4: 134 = (+60+38+36) (04. Solar Stone - Seven Cities 2002 )
( NO DOUBT HERE ! )
---------------------------------------------------------

btw, I will also do the fair calculations on the other 1/4 Finals to see if this happened more than once ...

I hope I'm not alone with this

Madjer

Posted by shao on Mar-18-2003 03:11:

The guy who posted before me has a point, even if his main motive is to get silverbath back in.

As for my vote... it was tough, but i went for southern sun & ligaya.

Posted by Thierry on Mar-18-2003 05:32:

NOT FAIR AT ALL TO CHOOSE BETWEEN LIGAYA AND SEVEN CITIES!!! I have to go with Seven Cities and Southern Sun.

Posted by Shito on Mar-18-2003 07:58:

3 & 4 for me.

Posted by Trancemaster2k on Mar-18-2003 08:01:

1 & 3 for me (formi formidable )

Posted by JJ-T1 on Mar-18-2003 12:39:

1 & 3 for me.

Posted by Djeebie on Mar-18-2003 15:20:

Paul Oakenfold - Southern Sun
James Holden - Nothing

Very easy to vote...

Posted by _Marco_ on Mar-18-2003 18:54:

3&4

Posted by JayD on Mar-18-2003 19:15:

quote:
Originally posted by Madjer
Hey JayD,

I couldn't believe that 'Plastic Boy - Silverbath' didn't do it to the SEMI's !
And after having done the math, I was even more confused, because 'Silverbath' clearly got the 2nd most of the votes !!!

Then came the illumination: Now I understood why my favourite song didn't make it! You're just counting which combo was most liked, which unfortunatelly isn't a fair vote at all ((

PLEASE, would it be possible to have the 2 SONGS which got the MOST VOTES WHEN YOU COUNT EACH SINGLE VOTE ?!!!
( and not the COMBO (of 2 songs) which got most votes )

---------------- Calcs for FAIR voting ---------------------
[madjer@rivaldo d2k]$ perl TA_voting.pl 65 33 56 10 63 29
Votes for track 1: 154 = (+65+33+56) (01. Paul Oakenfold - Southern Sun)
Votes for track 2: 138 = (+65+10+63)
Votes for track 3: 72 = (+33+10+29)
Votes for track 4: 148 = (+56+63+29) (04. Plastic Boy - Silverbath)
( Silverbath HAS GOT 10 VOTES MORE THAN 'J.Holden - Nothing' !!!! )

[madjer@rivaldo d2k]$ perl TA_voting.pl 39 37 60 35 38 36
Votes for track 1: 136 = (+39+37+60) (01. Gouryella - Ligaya)
Votes for track 2: 112 = (+39+35+38)
Votes for track 3: 108 = (+37+35+36)
Votes for track 4: 134 = (+60+38+36) (04. Solar Stone - Seven Cities 2002 )
( NO DOUBT HERE ! )
---------------------------------------------------------

btw, I will also do the fair calculations on the other 1/4 Finals to see if this happened more than once ...

I hope I'm not alone with this

Madjer

Votes went by the percentage of people which voted and by which tracks were voted and by the percentage of times it was voted. Therefor leaving Nothing w/ more of a percentage making it to the finals. I did not "only count" the track which was most voted (2 in 1) it was all done on a fair scale. What I can do is throw in another thread for Silverbath and Energy 52 since they were pretty much tied with the percentage of others and then with those I will see which is making it to the last four votes.

JaY

Posted by puckhead on Mar-18-2003 22:28:

1 and 2

Posted by Madjer on Mar-19-2003 00:44:

quote:
Originally posted by JayD
Votes went by the percentage of people which voted and by which tracks were voted and by the percentage of times it was voted. Therefor leaving Nothing w/ more of a percentage making it to the finals. I did not "only count" the track which was most voted (2 in 1) it was all done on a fair scale. What I can do is throw in another thread for Silverbath and Energy 52 since they were pretty much tied with the percentage of others and then with those I will see which is making it to the last four votes.

JaY

Could you please show me this in a math. formula (maybe we can find a bug
In this case only numbers show us the truth :P

I extended my script to also show the percentages (which don't give ANY extra information at all because they contain the same numbers only multiplied by a constant factor (100/512 in our case))

Track4 is 2. with 28.91%

( I fear that your calculation, either didn't take into account all the numbers, or even weighted them too much by quadratic operations for instance (like if you took 65 * 25.39% ...)
both of which would falsen the vote! )

Madjer (who was very good in math

---------------------------------------------------
[madjer@rivaldo d2k]$ perl TA_voting.pl 65 33 56 10 63 29
1 and 2 : 65 25.39%
1 and 3 : 33 12.89%
1 and 4 : 56 21.88%
2 and 3 : 10 3.91%
2 and 4 : 63 24.61%
3 and 4 : 29 11.33%
Total votes: 256 * 2 = 512
Total votes T1: 154 = ( + 65 + 33 + 56) 30.08% = ( + 25.39% + 12.89% + 21.88%) / 2
Total votes T2: 138 = ( + 65 + 10 + 63) 26.95% = ( + 25.39% + 3.91% + 24.61%) / 2
Total votes T3: 72 = ( + 33 + 10 + 29) 14.06% = ( + 12.89% + 3.91% + 11.33%) / 2
Total votes T4: 148 = ( + 56 + 63 + 29) 28.91% = ( + 21.88% + 24.61% + 11.33%) / 2

Posted by Flipper01 on Mar-19-2003 10:45:

DAMN, I missed the semi-finals

I'm glad to see that Nothing and Southern Sun are still in the running

Pages (2): [1] 2 »