Become a part of the TranceAddict community!Frequently Asked Questions - Please read this if you haven'tSearch the forums
TranceAddict Forums > Main Forums > Chill Out Room > Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005)
Pages (2): [1] 2 »   Last Thread   Next Thread
Share
Author
Thread    Post A Reply
tribu
Guest



Registered: Not Yet
Location:
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005)

(please excuse my typos and grammar mistakes. Ive got to get my nephew to bed)
To begin with, I'd like to say
THIS REVIEW WILL CONTAIN SPOILERS AND LIKELY ALOT OF THEM.,
That said, if you don't know the stroy of Willy Wonka by now, you likely won't be seeing the new version either.

MAJOR FILM EVENTS

Opening Credits - I really like the factory intro to the movie.

Introduction to Charlie and his Family - To begin with, the depiction of Charlie's house was nothing short of amazing. The walls inside looked like the Gene Wilder version and the bed where the two sets of grandparents slept could have been from the original film as well. A stunning disply of Dahl's literal povery. The casting here was a bit weak. The two main characters, Grandpa Joe and Charlie, displayed little chemistry together, but each filled out the role they were to play sufficiently. Burton took quite a bit of artistic license, filling in backstory for some of the characters, some of which was rather pointless. Grandpa Joe used to work for Willy Wonka? Who knew?

The Golden Ticket Search - Rather than rely on the post, a small army of Oompa Loompas (though vaguely filmed, so as not to reveal their apperance) was unleashed upon the world, putting up banners to announce the contest.
--Agustus Gloop - The fat little kid from Germany was an ok casting call considering he isn't part of the film for very long. His parents were golden choices for casting; the (silent) father was a particularly brilliant choice. Augustus was a bit less coherent then Wilder's version, and thusly talked less, ate more.
--Violet Beauregarde. A decent casting choice made brilliant through the casting of her mother; these two were made to look amazingly similar. Violet is a karate champion in this one, as well as a champion gum chewer.
--Veruca Salt - Perfect casting for Veruca, down to the crooked teeth. She played the spoiled brat role well, had a great pouting look, and her british-tinged 'Daddy!' was immaculate. The father, on the other hand, looked the part, but played it horribly. It's not a huge role, but the character needs to be played like a top business owner; he didn't have the confidence or charisma for the role.
--Mike Teavee - The introduction to Mike Teavee is nothing short of brilliant as well. Hes converted from a TV monster to an FPS monster who doesn't even like chocolate. He was bratty, demanding, and a know it all; wonderfully done. His mother, who only makes an apperance was forgettable, his dad was the same, only because of his role. He was the perfect spineless father who has already given in to his demanding son.
--The Counterfiet Russian Ticket - Comparatively little time was spent on this plot element. This was a good suspense builder from the book (I think?) and Wilder version that received about 30 seconds of attention. In that time, we learned the ticket was found, to the fact that it was counterfeit.
--Charlie Bucket - As soon as Charlie learns the ticket is fake, he opens his bar of chocolate and finds the ticket. People offer him money for the ticket, but no Slugworth is to be seen. Charlie runs home to tell his family and Grandpa Joe gets out of bed to dance. The character acting as Grandpa Joe did not convincingly pull this part off; he looked stiff and out of character.

The Factory Gates - Gone was the fairy palace factory of the Mel Stuart version. Tim Burton's factory was immense, industrial, and very impressive visually. The five winners waited at the gate until 10AM. But Willy Wonka did not emerge from his factory. Instead, Depp's voice eminated from loudspeakers, instructing the winners to enter and approach the front door. The gates closed, and the front doors opened, revealing the dancing puppet show a 'Will Wonka!' theme which apparently showed in ever TV commercial. This bit is a little funny, and Wonka appears nexxt to the winners, rather than on a throne beyond the puppets. Wonka looked ok, but Depp wasn't eccentric at all with the character; he played it somewhgat mellow and depressed; shades of Gilbert Grape maybe? He could have done MUCH more with the character, as he was barely convincing.

Enter the factory - No contract. No coat grabbing hooks. No ever increasingly small hallway leading to a tiny door (not exactly anyways). Wonka is revealed to have some family problems, solely with his father. This is a minor part anyways.

The Chocolate Lake Room - Pretty good visually. The chocolate lake was a bit nicer looking than Stuart's version, and the fields, flowers, etc looked real; at least until the camera got close. The Oompa Loompas make their first apperance, and a small aside takes place to explain why the Oompa Loompas are working for Wonka. This part is ok but seemed rather unecessary.

Augustus Falls in the Lake - Thankfully, this little ****** goes first; he was the worst of the child actors. This part is similar to the original film, only the Oompa Loompas sing while he is stuck in the pipe (Aside: The machinery of the pipe was a nice touch). The song was the first terrible Oompa Loompa number. Though a modern touch was added to the song, I think it took away from the overall effect. Agustus shoots up the pipe, and his mother is remarkable calm. She was a shit actress anyways.

The Boat Ride into the Depths of the Factory - I expected this to be the best part of the movie. Instead, it was a major let down. Though visually pretty stunning, it was over to quick and felt slowed down, despite the rushing pace. A few bits from the book made it in here (not included in Stuart's version) but were jammed in the middle, further slowing the pace of the scene. Theres also a small vignette about Wonka, his father, and his first piece of candy which sets up some later plot elements.

The Inventing Room - Yet another chance for Wonka to be eccentric, but he was dull and overly complacent. Very little machinery was shown, and even less was explained. Everlasting Gobstoppers made their apperance, but without Slugworth's apperance, this was little more than a small nod to the original. The machinery was impressive, unfortunately little else was including,

Violet turns into a Blueberry - The machinery which churned out the gum was awesome. Violet's acting on the other hand was shameful. There was little to no wonder as she chewed the magical gum, little wihimpering or shrieking as she changed into a blueberry (not badd effect work here!) Her mother was a bit more anxious than Mrs. Gloomp, but not incredibly impressive. The Oompa Loompas make it two for two with a terrible disco-era song.

Veruca wants a Trained Squirrel - This scene is why many critics say this movie is truer to the book than Stuart' version (Stuart used geese who laid Golden eggs in place of squirrels). Unfortunately, this part is somewhat bad. Veruca was easily the best of the five child act(resse)ors plays the part pretty convincingly, but let's face it, shes a one dimensional character. The squirrels attack her, which is another well done piece, but her 'I want it Now' song is totally bypassed in favor of another terrible Oompa Loompa song. When I heard it start, I made a break for the bathroom and missed her dad being tossed down the garbage shute as well.

The Great Glass Elevator - Amazingly done by Burton and the designers. Great scene leading to the TV room. This is one of the better scenes (visually) in the movie until

Mike Teavee, Television, and teleportation - The room where this is done is immaculatly white and well done. This whole scene is actually quite well done, though Mike ramapages through the room and controls the machinery himself. The Oompa Loompas are still batting 1.000 with yet another final bad song as they switch Mike through the TV channels in a convention that has been around for some time.

Charlie is the Only One Left - We immediately leave the factory since there was no contract or Slugworth scene. One scene I always felt was missing form the original is included here: The other children leaving the factory in their new states. The break into Charlie's house and Wonka offers the factory to Charlie, but he must leave his family behind. Charlie refuses in the most unbelievable part of the movie ever. Wonka leaves, and Charlie stays in the house, having turned down the greatest gift a poor child could ask for.

Wonka shows up Later - Things (economically) get a little better for Charlie's family. Meanwhile, Wonka is making terrible candy; he has no family, and he has no heir, since Charlie has refused his offer. Charlie is shining shoes and Wonka goes to his stand. Charlie explains why family is so important and offers to accompany Wonka to see his father.

Wonka's Father - Is a dentist, which was explained earlier, but not mentioned by me until now. They take Willy into his dads office and the dad inspects his teeth (which are immaculate, though Wonka doesn't floss). It turns out that Wonka's dad has been quite the follower of his son, collecting newspaper stories and pictures which are everywhere. The scenery surrounding Wonka's father's home/office is odd, but a credit to Tim Burton.

Conclusion - Charlie gets the factory. The house is literally moved into the field of candy (where Agustus met his demise) where candy snow falls all year round. The End.


Overall this is not a bad interpretation of the book, but Id rank it below Wilder and Stuart's original effort. The film felt rushed in many parts, like Burton did know what to do, and slow in others. Some of the actors/actresses didn't show up, beyond to collect their paycheck, some great elemts (listed below) are missing, and theres some odd additions to the story which Dahl didn't include. These additions helped explain Wonka's character a bit, but seemed more included to push a message. The script was poorly adapted from it's two potential sources. Depp was a poor choice for Wonka, or was stifled creatively. The Oompa Loompas were homogenous, and their (re-written) songs were shoddy.
On the plus side, some of the characters did excellently with their roles. Most of the children started off great, and only plummeted when their characters hit the factory. Alot of the scenery was impeccable. The addition of forgotten scenes from Stuart's version were a nice touch.

Ranking : 6/10


Parts not Included from the Stuart Version and Book
-No Slugworth (minus a small montage at the beginning)
- The Fizzy Lifting Drinks Sequence (including the famous: 'A Shnozzberry tastes like a shnozzberry!')
- The sequence with the candy machine where the remaining contestants are sprayed with whipped cream and other goodies, then magically cleaned is gone.
-Veruca's 'I want it now' song

Last edited by on Jul-16-2005 at 03:06

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:16 
Add  to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Zenchowdah
I'm beyond it.



Registered: Jul 2003
Location: va

for the love of god man, just post an out of ten score.


___________________
Get Killed.
Get Noticed.
Keine Schoenheit Ohne Gefahr

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:19  Pitcairn Island
Click Here to See the Profile for Zenchowdah Click here to Send Zenchowdah a Private Message Add Zenchowdah to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
tribu
Guest



Registered: Not Yet
Location:

I've done so, thanks. I didnt finish typing before I hit submit.

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:27 
Add  to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Zenchowdah
I'm beyond it.



Registered: Jul 2003
Location: va

quote:
Originally posted by tribu
I've done so, thanks. I didnt finish typing before I hit submit.


six, im disappointed


___________________
Get Killed.
Get Noticed.
Keine Schoenheit Ohne Gefahr

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:28  Pitcairn Island
Click Here to See the Profile for Zenchowdah Click here to Send Zenchowdah a Private Message Add Zenchowdah to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
tribu
Guest



Registered: Not Yet
Location:

quote:
Originally posted by Zenchowdah
six, im disappointed


All in all, Depp was horrid, Burton took out some key parts, and added in some crap. I was disappointed too. Its worth seeing visually, and some of the actors were good, but like I said, most of them just seemed to want their paycheck and the notoriety of acting in this film.

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:34 
Add  to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Zenchowdah
I'm beyond it.



Registered: Jul 2003
Location: va

quote:
Originally posted by tribu
All in all, Depp was horrid, Burton took out some key parts, and added in some crap. I was disappointed too. Its worth seeing visually, and some of the actors were good, but like I said, most of them just seemed to want their paycheck and the notoriety of acting in this film.


so...
basically

$$


i was really hoping tim burton could remove the tarnish from his name on this one


___________________
Get Killed.
Get Noticed.
Keine Schoenheit Ohne Gefahr

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:36  Pitcairn Island
Click Here to See the Profile for Zenchowdah Click here to Send Zenchowdah a Private Message Add Zenchowdah to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Omega_Blue
Someone Changed My Custom



Registered: Dec 2003
Location: Gone
Re: Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005)

quote:
Originally posted by tribu
Parts not Included from the Stuart Version and Book
- The Fizzy Lifting Drinks Sequence (including the famous: 'A Shnozzberry tastes like a shnozzberry!')


no shnozzberries? wtf

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:43  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Omega_Blue Click here to Send Omega_Blue a Private Message Add Omega_Blue to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
tribu
Guest



Registered: Not Yet
Location:

quote:
Originally posted by Zenchowdah
so...
basically

$$


i was really hoping tim burton could remove the tarnish from his name on this one


Hmm, kind of. It's hard to say this was for money because, based on the movie, there aren't going to be Oompa Loompa action figures, or Willy Wonka talking dolls anytime soon. There won't be a soundtrack release (only 4 real songs in the whole movie) though a score release might be possible. It just seems like the movie was bad. The characters weren't like the book's characters or the original movie's in many ways, which really hurt things and the pacing was way off for the entire movie. Fast parts were slowed down and slow parts were sped through to keep the film short enough for children. Like I said before it's release, I'd have loved for this film to be a bit more adult oriented and darker, but that was barely achieved, if at all.

quote:
Originally posted by Omega_Blue
no shnozzberries? wtf


One of the most quoted lines from the original film interpretation and the whole surrounding scene was lifted in favor of giving Wonka some bleeding heart backstory and a cliched reunion with his dad that wasn't even part of the original story?

Terrible.

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:44 
Add  to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Danny Ocean
Throwin' Shapes



Registered: Dec 2003
Location: Absinthe Party at the Fly Honey Warehouse

that sucks, i thought this was going to be darker...i mean, burton and depp = dark no? guess not...

Old Post Jul-16-2005 02:46  Italy
Click Here to See the Profile for Danny Ocean Click here to Send Danny Ocean a Private Message Add Danny Ocean to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
igottaknow
PerfectTeeth R4 Dinosaurs



Registered: Feb 2001
Location: The Future

this review sums up my feelings:

"Tim Burton is Ed Wood,

This is a bad movie. It's bright,loud and it lies there like a beached whale. The original was no masterpiece, but it had a cheesey charm. It had Gene Wilder, mystery and wonder. Tim Burton wrings these from the re-make like a wet towel being twisted. Dep's performance is quirky to say the least. Basically, he is reduced to a series of facial tics. His pale makeup, darkglasses and white teeth remind one creepily of Michael Jackson giving children a tour of Neverland. Charlie of the title is a non-entity,as are the other brats who are reduced to one demensional caricatures. The Umpa Loompas are all the same person. This is clever, but it's an obvious digital effect that gets old fast. The laughs are few, as line after line fall flatter than a squashed squirrel. Speaking of squirrels,they dump a little girl down a garbage chute. Ha ha. The songs of the original have been replaced with terrible music by the ubiquitous Danny Elfman.Useless flashbacks have been added,but don't add to the movie, unless you find the sight of a boy in elaborate dental headgear hilarious.They just slow things down .The subplot of the original concerning the theft of the "everlasting gobstopper" has been jettisoned. There's no plot. The lesson that family is more important than wealth is trite and unearned. Tim Burton once made a great movie called "Ed Wood" about a hack director. With re-makes like this, Burton is in danger of becoming the Ed Wood of a new generation."

Old Post Jul-16-2005 03:08 
Click Here to See the Profile for igottaknow Click here to Send igottaknow a Private Message Add igottaknow to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
tribu
Guest



Registered: Not Yet
Location:

quote:
Originally posted by igottaknow
this review sums up my feelings:

"Tim Burton is Ed Wood,

This is a bad movie. It's bright,loud and it lies there like a beached whale. The original was no masterpiece, but it had a cheesey charm. It had Gene Wilder, mystery and wonder. Tim Burton wrings these from the re-make like a wet towel being twisted. Dep's performance is quirky to say the least. Basically, he is reduced to a series of facial tics. His pale makeup, darkglasses and white teeth remind one creepily of Michael Jackson giving children a tour of Neverland. Charlie of the title is a non-entity,as are the other brats who are reduced to one demensional caricatures. The Umpa Loompas are all the same person. This is clever, but it's an obvious digital effect that gets old fast. The laughs are few, as line after line fall flatter than a squashed squirrel. Speaking of squirrels,they dump a little girl down a garbage chute. Ha ha. The songs of the original have been replaced with terrible music by the ubiquitous Danny Elfman.Useless flashbacks have been added,but don't add to the movie, unless you find the sight of a boy in elaborate dental headgear hilarious.They just slow things down .The subplot of the original concerning the theft of the "everlasting gobstopper" has been jettisoned. There's no plot. The lesson that family is more important than wealth is trite and unearned. Tim Burton once made a great movie called "Ed Wood" about a hack director. With re-makes like this, Burton is in danger of becoming the Ed Wood of a new generation."


A very good review which speaks my opinion as well. You've got to wonder how much say Burton and Depp (don't forget the 6 executive producers, which included Roald Dahl's neice (daughter?)) had in crafting the characters. This reviewer fails to note that squirrels were part of Dahl's book (replaced by geese in Stuart's version, probably due to the differences in digital technology), but overall sums it up pretty well.

I also made the Michael Jackson connection, but didn't note it

Old Post Jul-16-2005 03:13 
Add  to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
DjConfessions
Senior tranceaddict



Registered: Jun 2005
Location: Jamesfranco, France

either you were taking notes in the theater with night vision goggles or you should just admit you downloaded it


___________________
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/gabriel_and_dresden
quote:
...known from a videotape the two made when they met in March... in Dresdens home, Dresden amputated Gabriels penis and Dresden and Gabriel ate the penis together...Gabriel had insisted that Dresden bite his penis off; this did not work.. Dresden used a knife. When that knife turned out to be too blunt, Dresden used a sharper knife to slice the penis off. Gabriel apparently tried to eat his share of his own penis..but could not because it was too..."chewy". Dresden then sautéed the penis in a pan with salt, pepper, and garlic.

Old Post Jul-16-2005 03:40  Canada
Click Here to See the Profile for DjConfessions Click here to Send DjConfessions a Private Message Visit DjConfessions's homepage! Add DjConfessions to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message

TranceAddict Forums > Main Forums > Chill Out Room > Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005)
Post New Thread    Post A Reply

Pages (2): [1] 2 »  
Last Thread   Next Thread
Click here to listen to the sample!Pause playbackJessy - Tooth Trouble: Is this the correct artist/name? [2008] [0]

Click here to listen to the sample!Pause playbackChew Fu Phat - "Without You" [2002]

Show Printable Version | Subscribe to this Thread
Forum Jump:

All times are GMT. The time now is 11:00.

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
[IMG] code is ON
 
Search this Thread:

 
Contact Us - return to tranceaddict

Powered by: Trance Music & vBulletin Forums
Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Privacy Statement / DMCA
Support TA!