Well I'm sure they all work fine. I have a different one than that you mentioned but they all do the same thing. They are definitely helpful in making melodies, especially if you're using Cubase.

The buttons and sliders make it easier to control synths. you can assign the knobs/sliders to parameters in the VSTi so that you can control them from your controller.

___________________
1 out of every 4 people in this country are mentally disturbed. Look at your 3 closest friends. If they seem okay, then you're the one.

I have the radium 49 key, it works great and its a good controller, nice faders and good knobs. reason i got this one instead of the other 2 was because the guy at guitar center recomended it to me
i would either go with the edirol or the radium, ignore the remote (in my opinion).

yes it will be easier to create melodies, but still dont expect them to pop into your fingers/head

Have fun

___________________

robelectric
http://www.robeyee.com
http://www.soundcloud.com/robeyee
http://www.twitter.com/robeyee

Get the Edirol or radium.
Remote is too small.I have a radium61 got it for like $200 @ GC. I like the feeling of it.

___________________
Phunktronix Mixes

alright so the radium 49 would be totally fine for what i need?

___________________
this is it.

I have a radium 49, and I absolutly love it. Great quality product.

___________________

try learning some music theory to get good melodies.. I have a MIDI controller (25 key) but mainly use it to record automation with it's knobs..

every now and then I "jam" on it to see how a patch sounds or something.. but the melodies I use in my songs are sequenced.. not played out and then sequenced..

___________________
Youtube || Soundcloud || Synth Patch Banks

have the radium49 too, i love it. sliders okey, knobs okey, no complicated shit

I like being able to put my controller in my lap while I produce which is why I got the 25 key one...

___________________
Youtube || Soundcloud || Synth Patch Banks