|
I'd go for vinyl for different reasons.
The pitch on a CD isn't as accurate as on a TT. There tends to be a gap between let's say 5.1 and 5.2, which makes beatmatching quite a bitch. You constantly have to use the jog wheel or the pitch bend to keep the records in sync. It's a lot easier to correct errors on TTs. You have a better feeling for what you're doing and it's also a lot easier to find a certain part of a song. Also, in my experience, when you speed up a tune on vinyl or on cd, they tend to sound different(in my opinion a speeded up vinyl produces a nicer sound than a cd). And don't forget those nice rumbling bass sounds that are produced by vinyls. Cds simply can't compete with that. And on a personal note I really don't like the counting down thingy on cds, it makes me incredibly nervous. I love the fact that you can just see where the vinyl's gonna end. That's a lot more reassuring since you aren't fighting against the clock.
This is my opinion and is obiously very subjective. I hope noone is offended by it. There a lot of things that are in favor of cds(e.g. availibility of classic tracks, which are incredibly hard to come by on vinyl). I simply don't like cds because you can't touch them while playing. You don't feel the music. Please take into account that I don't have a lot of experience in mixing with cds.
|