Which productions are better?

Gabriel & Dresden or Above and beyond?

___________________
"The 'soul' of the machines has always been a part of our music. Trance always belongs to repetition, and everybody is looking for trance in life... in sex, in the emotional, in pleasure, in anything... so, the machines produce an absolutely perfect trance."
--Ralf Hütter, 1991, quoted in Kraftwerk: Man Machine and Music

ehhh ive always liked G n D better, more interesting productions, i think

___________________
Get Killed.
Get Noticed.
Keine Schoenheit Ohne Gefahr

A&B do some nice stuff but i find most of it a bit cheesy, G&D productions I like more. Unfortantly they both have a habbit of churning out remixes for pop music.

quote:

Originally posted by raydn A&B do some nice stuff but i find most of it a bit cheesy, G&D productions I like more. Unfortantly they both have a habbit of churning out remixes for some pop tune.

i rather like the remixes of pop tunes. jewel remix was nuts.

___________________
Get Killed.
Get Noticed.
Keine Schoenheit Ohne Gefahr

quote:

Originally posted by raydn A&B do some nice stuff but i find most of it a bit cheesy, G&D productions I like more. Unfortantly they both have a habbit of churning out remixes for pop music.

Thats so true

___________________
"The 'soul' of the machines has always been a part of our music. Trance always belongs to repetition, and everybody is looking for trance in life... in sex, in the emotional, in pleasure, in anything... so, the machines produce an absolutely perfect trance."
--Ralf Hütter, 1991, quoted in Kraftwerk: Man Machine and Music

G&D

quote:

Originally posted by Zenchowdah i rather like the remixes of pop tunes. jewel remix was nuts.

I agree wholeheartedly. The dub of "Intuition" was absolutely stunning, and the mixes of "Serve The Ego" are simply classic. I think G&D barely edges out A&B, but why pit them against each other when you can have them together with G&D's remix of "No One On Earth"? another classic tune.

___________________

http://www.myspace.com/retrobytemusic

G & D are my favs. A & B are freakin sweet though

It depends on what mood I am in, but I would give Gabriel & Dresden the nod in an objective-as-possible mindstate.

g&d have nothing to do with the musical style of a&b
its like comparing airplanes and bananas

___________________
trance is dead, tiesto killed it

quote:

Originally posted by Toufas g&d have nothing to do with the musical style of a&b its like comparing airplanes and bananas

You can compare how well and consistantly each one does what theyre trying to accomplish...

what a dumb question (sorry about this flame!!!), nothing is better, its all about personal preferences

in music there is no "better than", trance isnt better than hardrock, blink 182 isnt worse than armin van buuren... Music is about personal taste, and personal taste cant be discussed. Yes, i like trance more than hard rock, but that doesnt make me a better or smarter person than a hard rocker...

Sorry about generalising this topic, just ignore me, i am drunk