You mind listing them all?
Some of us have shoddy memories.

___________________
**Man I'm Pretty**

quote:

Originally posted by PauLie_C My vote would easily have to go to Brendan Goddard, the guy is useless your thoughts????

is this fukn anti stkilda day is it!!!


i dont think he has been the most useless number 1 pick, i am sure we can find someone else. Yes, he has under acheived, but recently he has started to come good.

1986 - Martin Leslie (Brisbane Bears)
1987 - Richard Lounder (Richmond)
1988 - Alex McDonald (Hawthorn)
1989 - Anthony Banik (Richmond)
1990 - Stephen Hooper (Geelong)
1991 - John Hutton (Brisbane)
1992 - Drew Banfield (West Coast)
1993 - Darren Gaspar (Sydney)
1994 - Jeff White (Fremantle)
1995 - Clive Waterhouse (Fremantle)
1996 - Michael Gardiner (West Coast)
1997 - Travis Johnstone (Melbourne)
1998 - Des Headland (Brisbane Lions)
1999 - Josh Fraser (Collingwood)
2000 - Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda)
2001 - Luke Hodge (Hawthorn)
2002 - Brendon Goddard (St Kilda)
2003 - Adam Cooney (Western Bulldogs)
2004 - Brett Deledio (Richmond)
2005 - Marc Murphy (Carlton)

It's a shame that Waterhouse doesn't quite count because that would make the decision easy. Goddard or Gardiner would have to be the most disappointing from that lot imho.

___________________
http://eschatonnow.blogspot.com/

Wasn't Gardiner an All-Australian ruckman? I wouldn't really say that was a disappointing effort

___________________
**Man I'm Pretty**

quote:

Originally posted by Trance Nutter Wasn't Gardiner an All-Australian ruckman? I wouldn't really say that was a disappointing effort

I'd say that the drug-dealing and mafia involvement over the past couple of years would kinda cancel that out...

But yeah, it's pretty hard to compare a guy who's been in the league for 10 years with a guy who's only been in there for 4.

___________________
http://eschatonnow.blogspot.com/

Richard Lounder?

Who the fuck is that?

Sorry Paulie but both of Richmond's seem like the biggest duds to me!

___________________
Pretty Simple;
Saturdays at Ffour.

Well if Alex McDonald won it for Hawthorn it kind of de-values the whole system cause he was completely useless and thats back when we were still playing well.

And the best part of that, Collingwood apparently paid us money for him..

Last edited by Simon00 on May-29-2006 at 07:02

quote:

Originally posted by Dean Millson Richard Lounder? Who the fuck is that? Sorry Paulie but both of Richmond's seem like the biggest duds to me!

they arent draft picks of the past 10 years

looking at teh draft picks of teh past 10 years, id say its Goddard

___________________
edit sig- image needs to be resized

The Last Sunday @ Ladida coming soon....

im still laughing freo swapped their number 1 pick in 2001 for trent croad.

ps. give goddard 3 more years when his party days cool down and he'll be a gun.

___________________
lower the curtain down on memphis
lower the curtain down on me...

why exactly doesnt Clive Waterhouse qualify??

Goddard is truckloads better then him....


then again, wtf is the point of this thread Paulie...

take a look at the ladder sunshine.. at least we dont have to resort to playing basketball to beat quality teams...


Richmond and Wallace should be ashamed of themselves.

I dont give a fuck

C Judd should be wearing brown and gold

I still love you Hodgey

Stephen Hooper was feekin useless as well, and who are those Richmond Bogans..

Imo

1. Gardiner (had massive potential but let the party lifestyle get to him)
2. Johnstone (good footballer now but took too long to come good)
3. Goddard (looked great in his first year, only now starting to show a bit of that form)

clive waterhouse doesnt count because Paulie stated that it had to be of the last 10 yrs.. Renegade so kindly gave us the last 20

___________________
A beaver can hold its breath for 45 minutes