Heya's, suffered an unfortunate mishap over the weekend with a drunken guest knocking over one of my mackie MR8 monitors.

It resulted in a crack/split in the driver cone from the centre right out to the surround, including a small hole in the edge of the centre cap near where it joins the cone.

I just wired it up and ran some audio through it, it isn't too bad, the impact doesn't seem to have affected the internals and it's hard to detect any difference just playing mp3's through it, but if i load up cubase and put a deep sine wave through them panning left and right to compare the difference there is some obvious fluff/noise coming from the damaged monitor.

Playing high end source through them the damaged one actually sounds a bit dull or slightly flatter than the undamaged one, but i can't see how the high-end could have been affected by the damage i can see, so i'm thinking that is possibly my hearing or the room dynamics or perhaps the filter section was never perfectly matched to begin with.. any thoughts on this?

Anyway just wondering what to do, i got a local quote for a driver replacement of AUD$174.. or $130 just for the driver if i can install it. I'm not sure how much it costs to have it re-coned but is that a good option or is a new driver much preferable?

Cheers

___________________
i7 | Cubase | Virus TI KB | Motu 828mk3 | K&H O300 | Dell U2410 x2 | Maschine | Soundcloud

The drunken guest is paying for it, right? Get it done right - i.e., by professionals, and with a warranty for the parts/service.

___________________
cryophonik.com | facebook | soundcloud

Sonar Platinum | Ableton Live 9 | Logic Pro X | Access Virus TI2 Keyboard | Kurzweil PC3X | Nord Lead 4R | NI Maschine

Replace the whole driver imho. I'm always concerned that reconing slightly alters the driver's original performance.

___________________
-~-

my speakers (Adam A7's) have a 5yr warranty on them, i've blown 3 drivers/woofers and had all replaced for free look into your brand more if you haven't already

quote:

Originally posted by Zombie0729 my speakers (Adam A7's) have a 5yr warranty on them, i've blown 3 drivers/woofers and had all replaced for free look into your brand more if you haven't already

Which is fucking wicked of Adam as nearly every brand will not do driver replacement unless it's for their top of the range models.

Sometimes if a driver just goes (without someone damaging it) if you speak to their return department they will be nice and either repair it or send you a new driver (as it's kind of a warranty issue) but I don't know a single brand that will replace a driver when damage is clearly present.

Mackie though are pretty good with spares, especially having drivers in stock - shouldn't cost you that much (about $80) and replacing them are easy - done it a few times so let me know if you need help.

quote:

Originally posted by DJ RANN Which is fucking wicked of Adam as nearly every brand will not do driver replacement unless it's for their top of the range models. Sometimes if a driver just goes (without someone damaging it) if you speak to their return department they will be nice and either repair it or send you a new driver (as it's kind of a warranty issue) but I don't know a single brand that will replace a driver when damage is clearly present. Mackie though are pretty good with spares, especially having drivers in stock - shouldn't cost you that much (about $80) and replacing them are easy - done it a few times so let me know if you need help.

yah, Adam's warranty is awesome, i've had them send down parts (i replaced the front panel volume/power control) for me to replace and i have sent things up to LA for them to do. They have downsized so it took a bit of time to get a hold of someone but i sent the speaker up on a Friday and got it back 10 days later.

quote:

Originally posted by Zombie0729 my speakers (Adam A7's) have a 5yr warranty on them, i've blown 3 drivers/woofers and had all replaced for free look into your brand more if you haven't already

i have mixed feelings about this. while its really good with such serious warranty-offer, its not good to hear that u blown them three times. im looking for monitors and one of the things i need is the option to play loud from time to time.

quote:

Originally posted by 19503 i have mixed feelings about this. while its really good with such serious warranty-offer, its not good to hear that u blown them three times. im looking for monitors and one of the things i need is the option to play loud from time to time.

I haven't personally blown them but my studio partner has. In our old studio we were in a building with 10 bands and 3 other studios so when there is bleed he would crank it to compensate. They go plenty loud for me although i'm usually at moderate levles

How do speakers break ? Is it just a life expectancy thing ? I've had my genelecs for 11 years now and wonder if they have degraded somewhat.

quote:

Originally posted by Mad for Brad How do speakers break ?

They can break or wear for a number of reasons. Overdriving them is obviously a killer as it can push their coils beyond their limits and rip or dislodge cones. Other factors like prolonged exposure to pure square waves and clip-distortions can also cause damage.

___________________
-~-

what about phat beats. Sometimes my beats are really phat, wonder if the cones can accommodate such girth.

.. ok so not hearing a lot of support for re-coning.. I sort of feel the same, would prefer a new driver. but my girlfriend is offering to pay because it was her drunken friend that knocked it over and she doesn't want to ask her for it, so i want to do it as cheaply as possible without sacrificing the quality of the repair.

I will take the advice of contacting mackie about it directly before accepting the repair quote i think, might be worth a shot.

I wouldn't mind doing the labour myself to save the ~$50 or so, not sure how to actually get it apart and replace the driver though the front of it is all flush, no screws. Anyone know if the driver can be removed by taking off the back panel (where there are some screws) or does the cabinet have to be re-glued or something?

___________________
i7 | Cubase | Virus TI KB | Motu 828mk3 | K&H O300 | Dell U2410 x2 | Maschine | Soundcloud