Im up for it, but whats the deal with separate judges for mix, production and composition.

___________________


http://soundcloud.com/subtara

each judge would have their niche as not everyone is great at everything.

quote:

Originally posted by Mad for Brad each judge would have their niche as not everyone is great at everything.

Alright, i would have to take production then, how does it differ from mix ?

___________________


http://soundcloud.com/subtara

umm , if that doesn't seem apparent , perhaps you are not the right person for the task.

quote:

Originally posted by Mad for Brad umm , if that doesn't seem apparent , perhaps you are not the right person for the task.

When you say mix im thinking how well the track is mixed, which is about the same how well a track is produced in my book.

___________________


http://soundcloud.com/subtara

The mixing is if the track is cohesive and drives smoothly from the different parts of it , a real good track must have a good mixing.

Check this, this track has several parts some more chilling some more banging but all is well put together



here i will post you my real first production which has an awful mixing so you can compare.

I always considered that "form", mixing to me is the same as production, unless "mix" and "mixdown" are two different things.

EDM is confusing.

I'll take the case!

___________________

Now with extra singles!
my old stuff, not quite up to snuff - but I still dig it - UPDATED 9/23/2012

[IMO]Production could hold your choice of sounds, maybe the elements you all in all have in your track, how have you picked your drums, how well are your sounds designed etc.

The mix is how all that is put together, how clean / muddy your mix sounds, how good is your eq'ing, compression and such.[/IMO]

I separate them because they are separate issues and a song with great production can be poor composition with a mediocre mix.

composition : melodies, harmony and form
production : effects, sound design,
Mixing : judging the quality of the final mix. Not is the bass good but is the bass easy to hear and at the right levels.

The way I will have it is each contestant will have to explain their track as I will have certain elements mainly a melody and some chords that although doesn't have to be used verbatime the person must explain how the elements were used.

the judges will give feedback as it will allow everyone the opportunity to learn not only from the actual tracks and their description but also from the judging.

The goal is that everyone will learn something and of course the winner will get at least 250$ from me no strings attached and you still own the rights to your track. The aren't really any artist guidelines other than the melodic and motivic content that you can use in any way.

People have been talking about a contest but unless there is money in it, nobody is going to apply themselves and I don't mind paying.

quote:

Originally posted by Mad for Brad I separate them because they are separate issues and a song with great production can be poor composition with a mediocre mix. composition : melodies, harmony and form production : effects, sound design, Mixing : judging the quality of the final mix. Not is the bass good but is the bass easy to hear and at the right levels. The way I will have it is each contestant will have to explain their track as I will have certain elements mainly a melody and some chords that although doesn't have to be used verbatime the person must explain how the elements were used. the judges will give feedback as it will allow everyone the opportunity to learn not only from the actual tracks and their description but also from the judging. The goal is that everyone will learn something and of course the winner will get at least 250$ from me no strings attached and you still own the rights to your track. The aren't really any artist guidelines other than the melodic and motivic content that you can use in any way. People have been talking about a contest but unless there is money in it, nobody is going to apply themselves and I don't mind paying.

Too late to enter the competition ?

___________________


http://soundcloud.com/subtara