Become a part of the TranceAddict community!Frequently Asked Questions - Please read this if you haven'tSearch the forums
TranceAddict Forums > DJing / Production / Promotion > Production Studio > Learning to compose with notation programs instead of staff paper.
  Last Thread   Next Thread
Share
Author
Thread    Post A Reply
Anxieties
tranceaddict



Registered: Jan 2011
Location: Brew York, USA
Learning to compose with notation programs instead of staff paper.

Are there any serious disadvantages to beginning a composition on the computer?

Purists seem to be against composing on the computer, and recommend beginning with instrument and paper. You input what you've composed into the program, you are not to begin there. But why? I can't know if this some kind of collective quirk rooted in respect for tradition, or if it's a substantial concern that new composers should heed.

I find the computer to be so much more convenient than staff paper. Composing the traditional way seems quaint to me. I also find it absurd to think I have to learn to compose on staff paper before I use a notation program. Why can't I learn on the program first? Then, if I ever need to use staff paper, I'll easily be able to do so.

The only reason this is even an issue is because of my uncertainty. I have the impression that, for some vague reason, if you compose on staff paper, your composition will be stronger. The argument I've read for this is that staff paper forces you to consider your ideas with more care, while the luxury of the computer with its undo/redo button will make you sloppy and spoil you in a creative sense. I've seen a similar argument made by poets against typing poetry. The second argument was that certain unused ideas on paper can one day grow to be something, while everything bad gets deleted on the computer. The second argument I disagree with wholeheartedly, because I save all my musical projects even if I don't like them -- one day I might be able to incorporate them elsewhere.

What's the verdict on this? I'm learning music theory and I'm going to use a notation program almost exclusively. I will be doing all the exercises on the computer. I already make music, but I do so by ear and I've been frustrated by my inability to create more ambitious works. I just want to be able to notate my ideas, so I'm going to be ear training and attempting to compose "legitimately." If I ever need to use paper in the future (let's say I'm traveling and don't have a laptop, or can't use a laptop), I think I'll do fine.

Old Post Jan-02-2011 05:27  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Anxieties Click here to Send Anxieties a Private Message Add Anxieties to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Mr.Mystery
Static Guru



Registered: Dec 2001
Location: Vantaa

For me it's all about the end result. Use whatever you feel like. People will always tell you you're doing something wrong, but as long as you are getting stuff done the way you want it to be what does it matter what they think?


___________________
Latest releases:
Endless Cycles [Capital Heaven]
The Charlatan [Morphosis]

Old Post Jan-02-2011 05:30  Finland
Click Here to See the Profile for Mr.Mystery Click here to Send Mr.Mystery a Private Message Add Mr.Mystery to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
floyd741
addict



Registered: Dec 2008
Location: Chicago

You could just not compose anything at all, and instead throw things at your keyboard (while recording, of course) for about half an hour (more if you're feeling inspired that day), then see if you got anything good. That is, after all, HOW THE PROS DO IT.


___________________
"I pay no attention whatever to anybody's praise or blame. I simply follow my own feelings." -Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Soundcloud

Old Post Jan-02-2011 05:33  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for floyd741 Click here to Send floyd741 a Private Message Add floyd741 to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
cryophonik
Boom shanka



Registered: Jan 2008
Location: Elk Grove, CA USA

When I first started getting into production years ago, my natural tendency (having a background in music performance and theory) was to want to compose everything using the staff/notation editor, but I quickly realized that the notation editors in most DAWs were pretty inept at the time, and haven't improved much from what I've seen. So, I begrudgingly learned to adapt to the piano roll view. That said, the dedicated notation editors are much better, from what I've heard/seen.

More importantly, I think you'll be hard-pressed to find any EDM producers who use notation software. That's not to say that you can't or shouldn't use notation software, it's just that it's much more common to use a DAW's piano roll view, track view, and/or step sequencer. Those are by-and-large the tools that EDM was started and evolved with, going back to the days of hardware sequencers, so you'll notice right away that almost all producers and tutorials use them pretty much exclusively and if you try to follow a tutorial or have a discussion regarding notation, it will definitely be in your advantage to be familiar with the piano roll view.


___________________
cryophonik.com | facebook | soundcloud

Sonar Platinum | Ableton Live 9 | Logic Pro X | Access Virus TI2 Keyboard | Kurzweil PC3X | Nord Lead 4R | NI Maschine

Old Post Jan-02-2011 05:43  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for cryophonik Click here to Send cryophonik a Private Message Visit cryophonik's homepage! Add cryophonik to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Fledz
Banned



Registered: Sep 2006
Location: London UK

quote:
Originally posted by Mr.Mystery
For me it's all about the end result. Use whatever you feel like. People will always tell you you're doing something wrong, but as long as you are getting stuff done the way you want it to be what does it matter what they think?

I'm the same. In most cases, the important thing is the end result. How you got there, in most cases doesn't really bother me.


___________________
Like Progressive and Deep House? Grab my latest mix below
http://www.tranceaddict.com/forums/...s=#.UAv1rbRo3h4

Old Post Jan-02-2011 05:49  Croatia
Click Here to See the Profile for Fledz Click here to Send Fledz a Private Message Add Fledz to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Kysora
Supreme tranceaddict



Registered: Aug 2009
Location: Hampshire, IL

I don't buy that it makes your compositions better at all. It just depends on how much effort you put into it and as long as whatever your medium is doesn't hold you back then your writing will be as good as it can be.

Old Post Jan-02-2011 06:56  United States
Click Here to See the Profile for Kysora Click here to Send Kysora a Private Message Add Kysora to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
J.L.
Never gonna give you up.



Registered: Aug 2002
Location: Toronto, Canada

"Pros" tend to be trained, educated and experienced to compose using staff paper. But I'm sure if you gave Mozart a computer instead of paper to score music, he'd do a great job at it as well.

Old Post Jan-03-2011 06:23 
Click Here to See the Profile for J.L. Click here to Send J.L. a Private Message Add J.L. to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Looney4Clooney
Supreme tranceaddict



Registered: Apr 2010
Location:

Using a computer is just faster , less messy and really unless you like the art of calligraphy, makes notation paper completely obsolete unless I suppose you are notating something short hand that you are trying to transcribe or maybe just an idea in your head. Some old people still do it that way but it is like how your grandma sends written letters instead of typing a letter. In 5 years, except for learning , nobody will be using staff paper.

The reason you start learning by using paper is that there are very strict arbitrary rules regarding how music should look and notation programs don't always do things right. In fact there is no notation program yet that actually does everything for you in terms of formatting and there is quite a bit of proofing , adjusting aesthetic things so it looks right but had you not first learned with normal paper, you would not realize these things. So think of it like spellcheckers. Fucking handy but have you noticed how your spelling has gone to shit because you know you can roughly type the word and your computer fixes it for you ?

That is why. So you basically do some sort of exercise and you have your notation book with all the rules , trust me it is a big book with so many rules that are completely arbitrary and traditional with no practical reason but musicians expect it and you will really change a performance if your music does not look write. Players read 8 measures at a time and if something is a miss, like your note stems are not pointed the right way or your beams look a little wonky , it interferes with their ability to sight read. They train themselves to notice patterns and anything you do that is not what you would expect after years and years of reading well formatted music will decrease the performance. I mean if it is easy music, no big deal but a really fast piece where you have a few takes and there are alot of notes, well the way it looks really makes a huge difference.It is rather impressive how well some musicians can sight read. Like glance at a sheet of paper and how it memorized. I used to be rather good but I don't really keep up at it and i'm a little slower. I still do 1 hour of sight reading a day just to warm up my brain but it isn't to sound perfect like you have been playing the piece for ages but rather a brain crunching exercise where I basically convert an orchestral score to a piano reduction in my head and try to play it at a tempo slightly faster than I can handle. It never sounds great but it really does make your brain work.

A typical orchestral score uses many different clefs so lets say a treble clef, the C is on the first line below the bottom. And an alto , middle C is right in the middle, and tenor clef, middle C is on the 4rth line, and then to make things even more complicated, some instruments might use a treble clef but the instrument does not play at concert pitch. For example, horns sound a perfect 5th lower, Clarinates usually sound a major second or minor 3rd depending on the type. Now if that wasn't confusing enough, there are times when an instrument that does not use concert pitch then uses a different clef so you have transpositions you have to do for each note in your head. And that is only 1 of 10s or 20s lines.

Now imagine looking at all this information and being able to play it i mean not well but basically make your way thru it doing all these calculations in your head. I suppose it is still sight reading but ya, I do that because you start seing an entire orchestral score and you read it like a book. You can look at 10 lines and know how it sounds. This sort of practice will make you a ninja.

In fact I was hired by a well known orchestrator and he seemed busy and not really interested in talking and by this point I felt like I just had to be a little more aggressive so I just put it out there and told him I will sight read anything you put up there and he loved the cheekiness of it. I'm just glad he din;t reach for some obscure atonal piece with 30 staff lines. Anyways, after 3 pages of his own work , he said ok your hired. Then started grabbing other scores and trying to find my breaking point. And then he said for me to orchestra a brahms sonata for orchestra for tomorrow. That took 21 hours. He then laughed at how tired I was and said get used to it. He then talked about what he is working on and what he needs help with and I was given an assignment. Nothing too important and then he asked me to get him a latte. lol so there you go. Even the people that actually are paid still sometimes have to get the lattes.

But yes, all these little things matter as a pro would notice a score that didn't look right and there is just no room for babying people around. There is room for learning but there is this base level at which you have to be at.


___________________
"This is why Superman works alone." GC
old stuff from days gone by (2001-2004)
Mad For Brad's gay little contest

Last edited by Looney4Clooney on Jan-03-2011 at 10:23

Old Post Jan-03-2011 09:49 
Click Here to See the Profile for Looney4Clooney Click here to Send Looney4Clooney a Private Message Add Looney4Clooney to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message

TranceAddict Forums > DJing / Production / Promotion > Production Studio > Learning to compose with notation programs instead of staff paper.
Post New Thread    Post A Reply

 
Last Thread   Next Thread
Click here to listen to the sample!Pause playbackTune from the 1997/1998 Era [2007] [2]

Click here to listen to the sample!Pause playbackCRW - "I Feel Love" (RAF By Picotto Mix) [2003]

Show Printable Version | Subscribe to this Thread
Forum Jump:

All times are GMT. The time now is 12:08.

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
[IMG] code is ON
 
Search this Thread:

 
Contact Us - return to tranceaddict

Powered by: Trance Music & vBulletin Forums
Copyright ©2000-2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Privacy Statement / DMCA
Support TA!