|
Re: Re: Re: How to define?
| quote: | Originally posted by Belgian Bonzai
No. A remix is much more invasive to the original than a mix.
a Mix generally resembles the original Mix, uses the same sounds, same melody, bifferent build-ups perhaps. A Remix has a different sound (e.g. ligaya original mix vs. Green Court Remix) and the melody can be the same or slightly different or completely different alltogether.
'Mix' is usually preceded of 'Original', 'Club', 'Extended', 'Radio', 'Vocal', 'Instrumental',... whereas a remix is usually preceded by an artist name.
If 'Mix' is preceded by an artist name, it is generally the same artist that produced the original. But 'artist that did original' Remix exists too (e.g. Airwave (Rank 1 vs. Dutch Force Remix)), but that is because it is a remix, i.e. features new sounds and/or new melodies.
So don't ever write 'Cosmic Gate - Fire Wire (DJ Scot Project Mix)' as it's clearly a completely reworked version of the Original Mix and therefore clearly is a Remix.
Grtz! |
... but there are times when labels release someone's remix as "_____ Mix". I've said this before, but oh well. Mix, Remix, Version, Remake and whatever else a remixer feels like calling his mix can all be used interchangeably. What you said is a fairly good rule of thumb but does not apply in all instances and it shouldn't be assumed that it does.
Random examples:
Control Freaks - Subspace Interference (Blu Peter & Sal Mix)
Ecano - Run (Z2 Mix)
RR Workshop - Mess With Da Bull (Pappa & Gilbey Mix)
The three above should be labelled "Remix" according to your rule but they are clearly not. All of these are just labels! There are no rules. 
edit With regards to the original post:
As pointed out, a dub typically removes all or some of the vocals from a vocal-based track. It should be noted however that one can release a "dub" version of a track that never had vocals in the first place! A dub can simply be a darker, slower, more minimal or otherwise altered mix.
Random examples:
Accadia - Into The Dawn (Accadia Ambient Dub)
Cygnus X - Superstring (Rank 1's Deep Dub)
HH - ICE 794 (Thanks To Berlin Dub Mix)
Bedrock - Heaven Scent (Evolution Dub Mix)
Mirco De Govia - Epic Monolith (Sonorous' Epic Dub)
Three Drives - Sunset On Ibiza (DJ Ton TB Dub Mix)
etc.
Last edited by starglider on Dec-29-2002 at 17:15
|