I think it would work if ppl realised that all flaming should be kept in such a forum, also a chillout type 'posts dont count' would stop spam in it, and give us a place to take out frustrations without disrupting the main forum, like Az, I would also help mod one if needed, I'd be happy to help with it, provided theres a warning on it that its not to be kept too personally

quote:

Originally posted by ferrycorstenfan provided theres a warning on it that its not to be kept too personally

thats where good moderating comes in, anything too personal, posts are edited pink!
also, petty arguements can be removed from a thread, and carried on in this forum

That sounds fun.

tbh, i think it should rather be dealt with in ta, as it could, and probably will encourage arguments just to spam.

damn az, anything 2 become a mod

___________________

w: www.luketerry.com

quote:

Originally posted by Project T damn az, anything 2 become a mod

as if, i'm not fly ffs

like this will stop flaming everywhere else....



i disagree with even the spam threads, ur still encouraging pointless behaviour regardless of it being organised, jsut flaming u cant control ffs.

"u offended me, lets go post in the flame forum and argue"

___________________
Fave Tune at the Moment: Mesmerizer - Taking Control

>>> Download my mix here <<< (Electro, Techno & Psy-Trance)

quote:

Originally posted by Dumonde Trancer like this will stop flaming everywhere else.... i disagree with even the spam threads, ur still encouraging pointless behaviour regardless of it being organised, jsut flaming u cant control ffs. "u offended me, lets go post in the flame forum and argue"

missing the point ste, posts are moved the forum, and new threads are started.
Not just flaming tho, general stuff that pisses people off

it would still provoke unruly behaviour. even tho it's in the "right place" so to speak. there is no benefit from this. it may, in theory, reduce flames but i highly doubt it. ppl have reactions to one another's post. they don't go looking for flames to respond to.

it also creates more work for the mod(s) that will be watching over it. it's not needed. doesn't add anything to the site imo.

quote:

Originally posted by Linx_da_cat it would still provoke unruly behaviour. even tho it's in the "right place" so to speak. there is no benefit from this. it may, in theory, reduce flames but i highly doubt it. ppl have reactions to one another's post. they don't go looking for flames to respond to. it also creates more work for the mod(s) that will be watching over it. it's not needed. doesn't add anything to the site imo.

hehe, you just want less work
I can see your points there, and they are good points, but as I've pointed out, a flaming/piss take/vent forum has benefited other forums
plus I tend to be online a fair bit, and could oversee a lot of stuff

quote:

Originally posted by Az hehe, you just want less work I can see your points there, and they are good points, but as I've pointed out, a flaming/piss take/vent forum has benefited other forums plus I tend to be online a fair bit, and could oversee a lot of stuff

Same here, but I can see the argument both ways

It's a a stupid idea. People will get bored spamming that forum after a few days.

A good piece of flaming shouldn't harm the forum. As long as you have a decent reason to flame, go ahead.

Making such a forum is setting a wrong example.