Why are people on here saying this is trance? its not is it?

armin remix is trance and i believe the original is house?

___________________
Doo Doo Breaks

top40 trance

___________________

soulful/latin/deep house + jazz

quote:

Originally posted by mndeg top40 trance

original IMO wasnt too trancey.

How about we as Ishkur?

perhaps its Gabba

rofl

Why couldn't that be trance??

The original version of Rapture was at PvD Politics of Dancing, and I belive it's a trance album..

Rapture (original) is chilled and a bit ambitient.. but still trance IMO

___________________
Yesterday is history, today is a gift, tomorrow is mystery

Soulside Remix is chilled

god that's a good song

quote:

Originally posted by chjo Why couldn't that be trance?? The original version of Rapture was at PvD Politics of Dancing, and I belive it's a trance album.. Rapture (original) is chilled and a bit ambitient.. but still trance IMO

The original wasn't on POD, it was PvD's rework. The original is sorta commercial housey. It's not very good. Only the Riva/AvB remixes are trance, I'd say.

Original is considered basic club/top 40. the original is not trance.

The 'J Creamer & Stephane K' mix is my favourite version of this song. It is considered under the general header of 'progressive' isnt it?

quote:

Originally posted by Neuro'99 The 'J Creamer & Stephane K' mix is my favourite version of this song. It is considered under the general header of 'progressive' isnt it?

While the differences between prog house and prog trance are not easily discerned and many tracks drift along the fuzzy border between the two, Creamer's mix qualifies as progressive house. So yeah, you could call it "progressive".

quote:

Originally posted by starglider While the differences between prog house and prog trance are not easily discerned and many tracks drift along the fuzzy border between the two, Creamer's mix qualifies as progressive house. So yeah, you could call it "progressive".

yeah, I was actually tempted to define it as progressive trance but I figured it wud be easier to sit on the fence in case I was "wrong"

either way, to me this is definately in the genre of "good music that I enjoy listening to", as opposed to "music I dont like"