Is the greatest movie of all time, discuss.

quote:

Originally posted by escee Is the greatest movie of all time, discuss.

hrmmm.. id say Scarface would be a contender for the greatest movie of all time

personally i thought scarface was a bit weak.

especially comparing to the absolute masterpiece that godfather 2 is.

I'm watching Godfather II now.

___________________
HOT NEW DANCE MUSIC SITE:

www.joshandfriends.com.au

Win FREE entry to Gas and our events for members!

Godfather I and II are a couple of my favourite movies.. Im also watching it now

___________________
"There are no forces in the universe that are bad in themselves.
It is always up to man whether he will make good or bad use of them."
- Dr. Albert Hofmann

Godfather is legendry, all 3 parts were awesome and couldn't have had a better ending to finish it off.

The Sorpranos is a great contendor for all of them, it being a series makes it even better IMO.

___________________

THERE IS NO PART 3!
(in the same vein as when a father says i have no son...)

and i agree psygnosis, sopranos is good, but not as good as the godfather movies.

i got the series on dvds, the pine barrens episode in series 3 classic. favourite episode from all the series

series 1 is the best though.

godfather 2 is perhaps the only movie I can think of which actually surpassed its original. my opinion

___________________
self improvement is masturbation

Anyone who says it doesn't deserve to be amongst the greatest films of all time is kidding themselves.

From IMDB:
User Rating: 8.9/10 (54,727 votes) top 250: #3

Only beaten by Shawshank Redemption and Godfather Part I

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by waXology hrmmm.. id say Scarface would be a contender for the greatest movie of all time

werddd

i couldn't be bothered watching it.... *awaits lashings...or knee capping actually...*

___________________
new set online, Summer Journeys

quote:

Originally posted by webmeister Anyone who says it doesn't deserve to be amongst the greatest films of all time is kidding themselves. From IMDB: User Rating: 8.9/10 (54,727 votes) top 250: #3 Only beaten by Shawshank Redemption and Godfather Part I

werd webscheister!!!

i find those imdb rankings reflect my tastes (and i guess the vast majority of movie-lover's as well) perfectly.

i've seen all of those films ranked in the top 20 (cept seven samurai) and although i may swap em around, they do deserve there placings at the top - cept the LOTR films. personally, they wouldn't be in my top 100.

and phil mate, next time i see you, remind me to kill you. dont forget. NEVER disrespect Coppola. NEVER.