I was wondering which one sounds "sadder" : Above and Beyond - No one on Earth (San Francisco remix) OR Ferry Corsten - Sublime (Thrillseekers)

sublime for me. no one on earth has a danceable feel to it.

___________________
Doo Doo Breaks

but the vocals perhaps add to it?

no one on earth, for sure

___________________
ID 1ID 2ID 3

"No One On Earth" is sadder than "Sublime."

___________________
What do I usually get at McDonald's? Pissed off that I'm not at Fuddruckers.

quote:

Originally posted by Snagglepulse "No One On Earth" is sadder than "Sublime."

It is, but not in the way the thread starter intended.

___________________
Latest releases:
Endless Cycles [Capital Heaven]
The Charlatan [Morphosis]

i think im gunna cry

___________________
+[MeRc_4_HiRe]=[WiLLoW]+

I don't really find Sublime sad... Well, maybe a bit.
It's more mindblowing than sad.

I don't think trance by itself can be "sad". It all depends on the lyrics. No One On Earth isn't sad at all, the lyrics are rather hopeful.

Yes trance alone can be uplifting, but sad?, naw.

___________________
www.gerrycueto.com
gerrycueto.com promo vol7

san francisco remix? what now!?

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by gerrycueto I don't think trance by itself can be "sad". It all depends on the lyrics. No One On Earth isn't sad at all, the lyrics are rather hopeful. Yes trance alone can be uplifting, but sad?, naw.

but melodies themselves can be sad; you being a producer should know that. there are certain keys/chords that are actually classified as 'sad'.

personally i find a sad or melanchollic melody by itself can be more emotionally powerful without the pollution of human language. just my opinion though.

as for these songs, i'm not a huge fan of either but i suppose that i would say "no one on earth" is sadder.

Sublime.