Oceanlab - Miracle = Piano from FSOL - Papa New Guinue?
Yay/Nay?
___________________
Nothing lasts, nothing lasts, everything is changing into something else. Nothing is wrong, nothing is wrong, everything is on track...
You know, William Blake said... uh, nothing is lost. Nothing is lost and I... I really believe that, we only move on...
Aug-22-2008 01:43
SYSTEM-J
IDKFA.
Registered: Sep 2003
Location: Manchester
Nay. Slightly similar in that they're a bit twinkly, but the melody is completely different.
Originally posted by siastyle
Okay iv hurd the Album and lemmi tell you guyz.... Tiesto is gono make it back to the top again with these hits. The thing about it is that hes trying 2 bring a new style tho just like he did with Just be and it worked. they songs areunt TOO HIGHT up. but the vocals acaully are the best thing in 2007. The Track Carpe Noctum is like traffic but it hink he could of prefected the shit ouf it. but generalllyy its an amazing album...oh and Ten Seconds Before Sunrise is like Forever today TIMES 12
Aug-23-2008 20:20
Lunar Phase 7
Not a Flying Toy.
Registered: Dec 2004
Location: Zone 4
I knew it!
___________________
Nothing lasts, nothing lasts, everything is changing into something else. Nothing is wrong, nothing is wrong, everything is on track...
You know, William Blake said... uh, nothing is lost. Nothing is lost and I... I really believe that, we only move on...
Aug-24-2008 01:43
SYSTEM-J
IDKFA.
Registered: Sep 2003
Location: Manchester
They aren't the same! The Miracle piano is six notes, Papua New Guinea is only four. The first two, maybe three notes sound very similar, and it's possible that Oceanlab took those notes from Papua. Then again it's possible that it's coincidence. What is certain is that they didn't directly sample the piano and it isn't a carbon copy.
Papua is like G, Ab ,F , G (Cmin). Miracle is something like D, D, C#, C#, B, B (B min). Not the same at all.
Last edited by Armitage on Aug-24-2008 at 03:26
Aug-24-2008 03:12
Owsey
Supreme tranceaddict
Registered: Jan 2008
Location:
Sounds slightly alike, however I doubt they had intentions of trying to copy it
Aug-24-2008 22:27
Lunar Phase 7
Not a Flying Toy.
Registered: Dec 2004
Location: Zone 4
Here's what Paavo said:
"Yeah, we loved this tune a lots. We tried to emulate it with a vocal feel."
Sounds pretty conclusive to moi!
___________________
Nothing lasts, nothing lasts, everything is changing into something else. Nothing is wrong, nothing is wrong, everything is on track...
You know, William Blake said... uh, nothing is lost. Nothing is lost and I... I really believe that, we only move on...
Aug-25-2008 01:44
SYSTEM-J
IDKFA.
Registered: Sep 2003
Location: Manchester
Conclusive that they were influenced by Papua. He didn't say, "Yeah, we sampled the piano".
Originally posted by SYSTEM-J
Conclusive that they were influenced by Papua. He didn't say, "Yeah, we sampled the piano".
And as an emulation, this track is shit.
yah. PNG is way better. like, a million times better.
There should really be a thread for modern tracks that have elements which are just repackaged versions of older tracks.
That sound was a strong element of that track, it continued right through the breakdown. However, I don't give A&B any credit for it. As a result, as a track it gets way less points from me.
Aug-25-2008 10:50
Lunar Phase 7
Not a Flying Toy.
Registered: Dec 2004
Location: Zone 4
Okay, I totally lied.
I never even spoke to Paavo.
LOL.
___________________
Nothing lasts, nothing lasts, everything is changing into something else. Nothing is wrong, nothing is wrong, everything is on track...
You know, William Blake said... uh, nothing is lost. Nothing is lost and I... I really believe that, we only move on...
