"So my question is, is Trance really THAT superior? Why can’t I appreciate 2 different types of music at the same time? I love it when music takes me away but I don’t understand how a whole genre of music can lose its ability to do that for me."

I had a friend who toured with Phish for 3 years, and she feels the exact same way. I also feel this way about some of the old stuff that used to appeal to me. A few months ago me the Mrs. went to a U2 concert here in KC, and while it was a good show, we didn't leave with that certain "euphoric" feeling (no, I don't mean drug-induced). But a couple of weeks ago we went to an afterhours party for $10 bucks and witnessed a killer house set from Astroglyde (NY residents at Groovejet). A few months back, we saw an incredible set from Sasha and Digweed. So far, no other music genre has come close to electronica, especially live shows.

However, I still like to listen to other music. I feel a lot more balanced when I do, for some reason. I'll balance out the dance beats with some John Coltraine or Miles Davis on occasion. Or I'll throw in my old college tunes of Everclear, 311, Samples, etc. And then there's those nostalgic occasions of high school music that I must throw in, like the Cure, Smiths, Pixies, Depeche Mode, Love and Rockets, Christ I need to stop! I am really feeling old now!

*throws PVD CD in computer and scrambles for the headphones.....*

___________________
Whence September dusk grows crisper still,
with leaves all crimson conquered,
I yearn to shout,
and dance about,
and stick pickles in my honker...

quote:

Originally posted by butterfly So my question is, is Trance really THAT superior? Why can’t I appreciate 2 different types of music at the same time? I love it when music takes me away but I don’t understand how a whole genre of music can lose its ability to do that for me. I guess this is OK because the music I listen to now has made me happy and that is all that really matter...

my answers to your 2 questions:
1. no genre is superior
2. you CAN appreciate 2 different genres at the same time. the more the merrier.

i love that feeling too, =P.
maybe you're just looking for more from music that trance isn't giving you.

that's just my view though...

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by mr. poopyhead my answers to your 2 questions: 1. no genre is superior 2. you CAN appreciate 2 different genres at the same time. the more the merrier. i love that feeling too, =P. maybe you're just looking for more from music that trance isn't giving you. that's just my view though...

i think you misunderstood. trance gives me feelings that i cannot seem to get with other types of music. but i remember getting those feelings at phish shows in the past. did i really feel that strongly about phish then? it's weird that i can't get into other tyoes of music the way i used to ever since i started listening to trance a lot.

the only exception is dark classical music.

the only other kind of genre that makes me feel the way trance makes me feel is a live female voice.. be it pop, r&b, or opera. same tingles.

only trance is music. the rest is just noise. i'm glad u've found trance

quote:

Originally posted by AnotherWay83 only trance is music. the rest is just noise. i'm glad u've found trance

i wouldn't say all other music is noise (some, though), but I am glad I found Trance, too.

quote:

Originally posted by MisterOpus1 "So my question is, is Trance really THAT superior? Why can’t I appreciate 2 different types of music at the same time? I love it when music takes me away but I don’t understand how a whole genre of music can lose its ability to do that for me." I had a friend who toured with Phish for 3 years, and she feels the exact same way. I also feel this way about some of the old stuff that used to appeal to me. A few months ago me the Mrs. went to a U2 concert here in KC, and while it was a good show, we didn't leave with that certain "euphoric" feeling (no, I don't mean drug-induced). But a couple of weeks ago we went to an afterhours party for $10 bucks and witnessed a killer house set from Astroglyde (NY residents at Groovejet). A few months back, we saw an incredible set from Sasha and Digweed. So far, no other music genre has come close to electronica, especially live shows. However, I still like to listen to other music. I feel a lot more balanced when I do, for some reason. I'll balance out the dance beats with some John Coltraine or Miles Davis on occasion. Or I'll throw in my old college tunes of Everclear, 311, Samples, etc. And then there's those nostalgic occasions of high school music that I must throw in, like the Cure, Smiths, Pixies, Depeche Mode, Love and Rockets, Christ I need to stop! I am really feeling old now! *throws PVD CD in computer and scrambles for the headphones.....*

Man, do I hear THAT!!!
That's exactly how I feel; I'm glad I'm not the only one out there
Yea, so I'm a little older than most of you, big deal.
I actually think I have a better, overall perspective when it comes to 'electronica' because I was there before it even became a 'gendre'.
I used to listen to all the alternative 80's new wave stuff, but I had no idea at the time that it was would spawn into what we now know as Trance.
I love going out to listen to a great live set. It's such a natural, euphoric high for me. I know it's awesome when I get a grin on my face while I'm dancin' on the floor.
I can't help myself but think, "This is incredibly awesome!"
I listen to many, many different types of music but nothing does it like Trance does.

___________________
"...End? No, the journey doesn't end here. Death is just another path...one that we all must take.
The grey rain-curtain of this world rolls back, and all change to silver glass...and then you see it...
...white shores...and beyond...the far green country under a swift sunrise."

quote:

Originally posted by iMaGe the only other kind of genre that makes me feel the way trance makes me feel is a live female voice.. be it pop, r&b, or opera. same tingles.

yeah, my thoughts too.
i could care less about other genres, but if i hear a female voice especially r&b it's like, stop everything and tune in. artist? title? damn, no ag!! lol. over the weekend there was a 60 min segment on counter-tenors. i'm not gay alright!! but this dude's voice had me mesmerized.

don't take this the wrong way butterfly, but maybe it's because you're blossoming. you are expanding new areas of your consciousness?? i didn't like trance the first time i heard it. 6 months later for some reason, borrowed a cd from a friend and got hooked. you can listen to the same song and have a totally different emotion to it the second time. wait. now i'm confused. aaarrrghghghg.
(note to self: lower medication)

i think what i'm trying to say is that since music is a form of expression, it doesn't help you express your feelings, but it helps you reach a lot of those emotions that were hidden , unaware to you, or even bottled up maybe. other types of music were just loud, angst-ridden good for rebelling and yelling back at the world, or no nonsense popish fluff, or something psychedelic. with trance, and without words to get in the way, you can experience it on a deeper level.
ok.
time for me to stop.
just my opinion, hope this helps somewhat.

quote:

Originally posted by SNAFU_man yeah, my thoughts too. i could care less about other genres, but if i hear a female voice especially r&b it's like, stop everything and tune in. artist? title? damn, no ag!! lol. over the weekend there was a 60 min segment on counter-tenors. i'm not gay alright!! but this dude's voice had me mesmerized. don't take this the wrong way butterfly, but maybe it's because you're blossoming. you are expanding new areas of your consciousness?? i didn't like trance the first time i heard it. 6 months later for some reason, borrowed a cd from a friend and got hooked. you can listen to the same song and have a totally different emotion to it the second time. wait. now i'm confused. aaarrrghghghg. (note to self: lower medication) i think what i'm trying to say is that since music is a form of expression, it doesn't help you express your feelings, but it helps you reach a lot of those emotions that were hidden , unaware to you, or even bottled up maybe. other types of music were just loud, angst-ridden good for rebelling and yelling back at the world, or no nonsense popish fluff, or something psychedelic. with trance, and without words to get in the way, you can experience it on a deeper level. ok. time for me to stop. just my opinion, hope this helps somewhat.

it does help, thanks. evrything that ppl have written is making sense. but part of my problem is that these other types of music used to evoke equally stong feelings and now that i listen to trance, they don't anymore. i feel like trance might have taken something away that i used to cherish.

hey i used to listen to alot of hard rock and stuff and i always thought that gave me a good feeling until the day i heard..Sasha and John Digweed- northern exposure:expeditions (disc 1)

My feelings of all the stuff I used to listen to ran off and I couldn't believe there was something out there that could promote this awesome feeling that I'd never felt before in other types of music. So since then I've been completly sold out and the other genres of rock/jazz/pop I used to listen to completly faded out and now I just see them as a completly boring genre of music to listen to.

Nowadays people here in the south (macon, georgia) haven't actually heard any of this stuff so when i say trance they think of Darude-Sandstorm and all that crap.

Oh golly....it's been a crazy relationship I've had with trance but now i love it more than anything.

___________________


http://www.garageband.com/artist/sunburn

t.r.a.n.c.e
take me away..a million miles away from here..you're takin me higher...high as i can be..take me away
the land of the free minded...trance...everyone's mind journey is different...its intimate and extremely personal. listen to trance and close your eyes and tell me what picture you see when you listen to trance. whats going through YOUR mind.

___________________
I PUT TRADEMARKS AROUND YO MOTHAFUCKIN EYE
JUST ME N YOU