|
Re: ??
| quote: | Originally posted by dseabra
First of all, I want to know why all of that "fury" in the critic...you could just tell me what you think and done...don't making me feel like an idiot...another thing...I don't got why the critic about I am uploading and showing 3 musics of mine here...if you say that's because I am not a forum participant, that's ok, I got the idea and I will start to be more participative...but if not I want to know where's the problem... |
You know. I do try to be nice and try and be patient. I criticized three of your entries, last night, but this one was by far the worst while also capable of demonstrating the most potential. Apart from that, however, there was your attempt at glitch (I think) which took the form of a very loud distortion introduced inopportunely, completely out of rhythm, and with a tooth shattering loudness that, quite honestly, I don't think should be listened to; especially with headphones - and I was using headphones, last night.
So, yeah. You pissed me off. It was stupid to put something that loud, right in the middle of a mix like that. I'm trusting you, as a listener of your music, that you're not going to engage in some form of audio terrorism with the music you put out. That includes signals which aren't going to bust up my monitors or fuck with my ears - or just give me a jarring burst of loudness. If you don't want harsh criticism, don't post music with harsh noises.
Would you rather I blew smoke up your ass and tell you that you should send the song to a label? For fuck sake! Where's the value in that? I mean, really, what good is getting feedback if it's just a bunch of smoke up your ass and not really the truth. You can bitch and moan about how my words could have been phrased differently, and I probably could have put my critique in a nicer, more user-friendly fashion, but 1) that's no fun, 2) that's dishonest, 3) it's dishonest because it cheats you have the value of having someone's authentic reaction to your work.
If you can't or won't find value in that, I don't know what to tell you.
___________________

Now with extra singles!
my old stuff, not quite up to snuff - but I still dig it - UPDATED 9/23/2012
|