|
hey cool ive downloaded and listened to them all, here are my comments in the order of download:
1. robert: i think the kick is a bit too loud and the piano has too much reverb (the last tone always sounds weird to me), but what you did to the melody. OMG! i love it very very much! the bassline is awesome as well! overall great track!
2. haak: not very uplifting, but very original like the kick, love the bassline, dont really like how the melody comes in around 3.20. but at 4 mins its great! like the feel you gave to it, man. great track as well
3. xfer: powerfull remix! a little boring tho, dont like the part with the silence between the kicks around 4mins. very decent remix, but nothing special.
4. davec: the song is too loud..makes it distort a bit. sounds not very original, but i like this track, just remaster it
5. mehari: song starts a bit too 'explosive'. i like that submelody thats behing the mainmelody! the piano that comes in doesnt fit in it and its too loud. the part from around 4 mins makes me happy but you should have used either the more happy sounding melody or the original, both makes the song a bit messy.
6. madthijs: very nice and relaxing, but lacks percussion and bass. the idea is good, but it sounds to simple. i like what you did with the melody, but the lack of percussion is big, kick could be louder as well.
nice work guys i hope my points helped you for your next tracks. (although i have no knowledge about music, i just say what i think does not sound good on my radio  ) i liked listening to all of the tracks and i can live with the winning one
greetz,
john
___________________
ta-forum-members midi site
|
