Also, minimal can be alot more interesting if played right. Layering 3 tracks together is fun

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by ******** Seplling don't demonstrate intelligence and educatoin - knowing does.

quote:

Originally posted by Clovis86 Also, minimal can be alot more interesting if played right. Layering 3 tracks together is fun

you're giving people too much credit. they probably only know 3 minimal songs and have made their opinion of an entire genre off of them


good minimal is far from boring and leaps beyond this track...

ummm... the topic left this track about 3 pages ago...

quote:

Originally posted by iammesol ummm... the topic left this track about 3 pages ago...

So that obviously means we can't go back on topic at all ever.

In hindsight, this thread wasn't even worth creating.

Not even for the entertainment value.

___________________
last minute disco dot net

quote:

Originally posted by Demoted So that obviously means we can't go back on topic at all ever.

I never said that.

Everyone keeps relating the minimal arguement back to this track. Noones concerned about this track. It's nearly unanimously voted "suck."

quote:

Originally posted by DJ RJT In hindsight, this thread wasn't even worth creating. Not even for the entertainment value.

You've created a monster RJT

I don't really agree with the "worst track ever" and 0/10 reviews, but its pretty boring IMO. I think the bassline chugs along nicely but other than that, I don't get this track. I don't listen to minimal (does James Holden's recent mix album / essential mix count?) so I can't really call them out on bandwagon jumping either.

82-83 is so much better than this track, that is all I will say.

___________________
movies

blog

it's time to party

quote:

Originally posted by iammesol Everyone keeps relating the minimal arguement back to this track.

well people seem to equate this song with the entire genre with comments like "if holden made this everyone would love it"

quote:

Originally posted by Floorfiller well people seem to equate this song with the entire genre with comments like "if holden made this everyone would love it"

Because it's true. If this had Holden's name on it, everyone would be praising it.

___________________
"We did not choose to become robots. There was an accident in our studio. We were working on our sampler, and at exactly 9:09 a.m. on September 9, 1999, it exploded. When we regained consciousness, we discovered that we had become robots."

I cannot get over the amount of fanboy bullshit bantering in this thread.

How many times am I going to have to say it: If Holden made this track, I'd be criticizing Holden. It's not the artist - It's the track.

If any of you really believe that the only reason this track is getting shit on is because it's got Angello and Ingrosso's name on it, then honestly, I feel utterly disrespected. Essentially you're implying that all of us criticizing the track care more about a name, about looking and sounding cool, than the music. Any of you who've read my posts across MD and the new release forum damn well know that myself, along with Jason and Clovis and countless others, put an insane amount of effort into finding the music we love, and part of that love is discussing the music, good or bad, positive or negative.

This track is rubbish, it would be rubbish if it were named:

James Holden - Click
Ritchie Hawtin - Click
Loco Dice - Click
Armin Van Buuren - Click
M.I.K.E. - Click
Stefano Greppi - Click
Scooter - Click

The amount of people who keep championing the same argument here need to get a fucking clue - I tire of seeing the same series of posts every fucking day.

___________________
last minute disco dot net

Last edited by RJT on Jun-22-2006 at 18:38

quote:

Originally posted by DJ RJT I cannot get over the amount of fanboy bullshit bantering in this thread. How many times am I going to have to say it: If Holden made this track, I'd be criticizing Holden. It's not the artist - It's the track. If any of you really believe that the only reason this track is getting shit on is because it's got Angello and Ingrosso's name on it, then honestly, I feel utterly disrespected. Essentially you're implying that all of us criticizing the track care more about a name, about looking and sounding cool, than the music. Any of you who've read my posts across MD and the new release forum damn well know that myself, along with Jason and Clovis and countless others, put an insane amount of effort into finding the music we love, and part of that love is discussing the music, good or bad, positive or negative. This track is rubbish, it would be rubbish if it were named: James Holden - Click Ritchie Hawtin - Click Loco Dice - Click Armin Van Buuren - Click M.I.K.E. - Click Stefano Greppi - Click Scooter - Click The amount of people who keep championing the same argument here need to get a fucking clue - I tire of seeing the same series of posts every fucking day.

HUGE gigantic plus motherfucking 1. I pride myself in not being a fanboy. If a track a certain producer I like makes is shit, I openly and frequently call them on it.