|
| quote: | Originally posted by webbie
I think DJs who use BPM counters and "learn to use them" has a disadvantage.
They take precious time away from a moment where they can continue
to train themselves and their own ears.
If you start to use them there is a huge possibility that you might
become to reliable TOO much on them, say you come to a club without
any BPM counters and you are a bit rusty when it comes to matching
with your ears but an "ace" when you matches with counters, not good.
That could be your future carrear you are throwing out of the window
just because you want a little machine to do some of the work for you.
But on the other hand, if you always rely to your ears and learn to do
it by yourself you will always get by, I have yet not seen a DJ come
to a club and not bringing his ears with him.
I dont know about cds tho, I only mix vinyl and sure in the start
there was a painstaking course of matching, i was never able to match
before the tune ended (8+ minutes) and now it takes me about 10 seconds
at max. I dont decrease/increase the pitch slowly, you hear where the
pitch should be and move the slider there and I expect to get even
better with more training.
If I was to use a BPM counter to guide me, well, why? I have prolly
matched the beats before the counters have gotten a semi-good guess
at the true BPM.
But ofcourse, this is on vinyl, I dont know cds, I have never tried
spinning cd and will prolly not do that in the near future.
A BPM counter is nothing that you NEED to know how to handle or use,
a mixer is important to be able to handle, the players and F/X machines
if you want to use thoose, but a BPM counter is not important for you
spinning.
Just bring your well trained ears and you will be alright. |
I will address my position to your post on a point by point statement.
First you state that Djs who learn to use a BPM counter have a disadvantage, but my whole point to my first post is that if you learn to use a BPM counter as a shortcut tool instead of something that you "depend on" to beatmatch, then there is no time taken away from training your ears to listen to what is important. The important part is being able to sync two beats with absolute perfection. As I stated before, a BPM counter can never help you do this, it will only help you to reduce the time that it takes you to do this. And if you need to take more time to train your ears, then go ahead. The painfull process of learning how to beatmatch can be learned quicker, in my opinion, with the PROPER use of a BPM counter.
Your second point was the dependance on a BPM counter. In no way, if you use the BPM counter the correct way, will you ever become dependant on it. As I have stated so many times now, it is only a shortcut tool to help you reduce the time it takes you to beatmatch, and again, it does not instill the ability to beat match in you. If you can't beatmatch without a BPM counter, then either you are not using the counter in the right way, or you really haven't learned how to beatmatch in the first place. If you train your ears to learn how to synch the beats, then why would you trust the BPM counter over your own ears? Ever? Your own ears are, as you said, the only things that every Dj brings with them. These are ultimately what helps you to beatmatch, NOT the BPM counter. Again, to reitterate, the BPM counter will NOT give you the ability to perfectly beatmatch, it is ONLY a shortcut to get you there quicker and if you don't have one, then well, it may take you a bit longer, but in no way should you become dependant on it because if you can beatmatch in the first place, the lack of a beat counter can not take that away. My main point is that if you are just starting out, then it is a way to help you learn much quicker. Once you learn how to beatmatch, that doesn't go away. If you are an "ace" with the BPM counter, then you will definitely be an "ace" without one, becaues the BPM counter doesn't sych the tunes--you do!! My position is that you can't be an "ace" with a BPM counter if you are not and "ace" without one. Once your ears are trained, then that is it. Period.
And as you said, "if you always rely on your ears and learn to do it by yourself you will always get by". I totally agree, because, again, to repeat myself, the BPM counter doesn't beatmatch for you! It is a tool to help you beatmatch quicker!
As far as not being able to deal with the "painstaking course of matching", it would have been much easier if you could have eliminated the obvious differences in tempo right of the bat with your BPM counter and progressed right to the fine tuning very quickly, which is exactly what a BPM counter helps you do. Cds are no different than vinyl, just the physical manipulation of the equipment is a bit different.
And how can you say that it takes you 10 seconds to beatmatch? It takes me almost 10 seconds or more just to set my cue point, adjust the gain and switch over the proper headphone cue buttons on the mixer! Then it will take me another 3-5 seconds to course tune the beat to within a couple BPM. From there it takes over a minute because when you are fine tuning the beatmatch, sometimes it takes over 20 beats (about 10 seconds at 140BPm) just to let the beats separate. Then you have to check one last time to make sure. At BEST, you are spending about 30-40 seconds to beatmatch--more than likely it take over a minute and you're really not accurately portraying how long it really takes you to beatmatch.
A BPM counter, as you said, should not be something that you need. I agree. You should never NEED it, but as I've been saying all along, if you learn how to use it properly, then it will help you beatmatch much quicker so that you can spend time on things like learning how to use your sampler or effects. I do think that a BPM counter IS important though, to help you spin more efficiently and to allow you more time to do things like effects. As I said in my first post, there is SO much more to Djing then beatmatching. If you are so concerned about beatmatching and taking the long way to do it, then you will never survive as a Dj because you can never spend any of the 6 or so minutes per track that you play doing anything else other than beatmatching. If you can use a tool to allow you to free up part of your time, why is everyone resisting the use of a tool that can help so much? Fuck being able to "do it the hard way" There is no hard way, there is only the smart way and the stupid way. The stuipd way takes more time and is much less efficient.
Your last statement was "Just bring your well trained ears and you will be alright." If you don't have well trained ears in the first place, you shouldn't be spinning out. Maybe that is why people are so against BPM counters, because they feel the intense urge to spin out before they are ready to do so. Patience is a virtue.
___________________
When you dance, the DJ takes you on a journey, but he or she is usually not the focus of your experience at a club or festival or wherever you hear the music. Dancing is. Music is.
Last edited by Dj Flesch on Jun-15-2003 at 06:11
|