|
Re: Teh Review
| quote: | Originally posted by |3 |_ @ Z 3 |)
... OMFG REVIEW ...
|
first of all, many many thanks for your indepth review. dunno what to say, really Your states truly hit the spot. Im going to keep these in mind.
now, let me clarify few things or maybe add my point of view from time to time.
| quote: |
03) 6:48 -- Good transition but the bass seemed too low. Without a doubt this is one of my favourite tracks of all time. Just love that melody at 8:56, nothing more blissful than that synth
|
03) Refering to basses. I totally agree. I cut lows on previous track near the end to fit to Petibonum, but I should have increased basses on Petibonum instead. About that track... this is one of my favourites of all time. I love to have it played a little faster, like Armin played on WMC back in 2004. Saying this track is blissful is the best way to describe it!
| quote: |
04) 12:01 -- Very good transition. 12:30 -- Should have fully transitioned to track 4 instead of cutting highs at 12:37. I would have dropped this track in right when the bass kicked at 12:58 but this buildup worked great anyways. 13:26, 14:45, 15:43 -- Not a fan of excessive flanger use. 13:55-14:22 -- Clipping throughout. So far perfect flow as far as keeping the listener in a melodic state of mind.
|
04) Unfortunately, Petibonum ended on 12:48 with this chirping. But I still would turn down Petibonum to have more powerful buildup.
| quote: |
05) 16:46 -- Final transition here was very good. So far this track is easily my favourite melodic trance tune of the year, but in this case I love the Original best -- However, I think with the previous tracks in place this remix was well suited to follow. XLNT choice.
|
05) I can't see significant differences between LNQ remix and original apart from this additional, melancholic melody which appears later on the track.
| quote: |
06) 21:59 -- Perfect transition. Hardly noticed this was the next track. Some Clipping is evident throughout this track. Very soothing vocals in this track but I wasn't digging the melody at 23:52.
|
06) This tracks comes at 20:15 and Bali is noticable up to 22:27. Clipping here is really annoying :<
| quote: |
07) 25:44 -- Nice transition but again bass is too soft here. Good track to follow up on. 27:36 -- Quick breakbeat to give the listener a breather. Love that hypnotic synth.
|
07) Hmmm... I didn't want basses to be dominant in this set, but I can't remember if lows are cut here. I wasn't sure about this breakbeat part, I'm glad it worked here.
| quote: |
08) 32:03 -- Ugh, that was a rough transition to say the least. Too much going on when you transitioned, you should have completely cut a freq or two. This tracks bassline completely changed the flow of the set. Never enjoyed the original mix of Green Astronauts and unfortunately Mr. Harding can't save this song either.
|
08) That's the technical turning point for this mix. I wanted to drastically change the key of the tracks for upcoming tunes (AFAIR Kay Stone was Fm while Green Astronauts Cm) and I wanted badly to play Green Astronauts. The only chance was here, because it's not a peak time tune obviously, so the later - the worse. Rough mix was a compromise.
| quote: |
09) 37:39 -- Good transition to get the set a flowing a little faster. XLNT melody and good track to get the energy of this set kicking. Nice buildup at 40:54.
|
09) wrd. Eternal Light aspires for a main track on this set IMHO.
| quote: |
10/11) 43:13 -- Hmmf. When you transitioned there is almost no bass though to keep the flow thumping. The pitch is probably alot faster on this song than usual sounding like its skipping a beat making it seem like a double bass. Presume thats your style when you mix, like to slowly bring in the bass AFTER you've transitioned to the next track. This track didn't cut it for me. Definately gave me a nostaglic feeling but not necessarily a good one :P
|
10/11) Both tracks (mashed up) started with kick only and bassline appears later :/. Double bass here is an effect of not cutting the lows on After Love entirely. My fault
| quote: |
15) 60:07 -- Heard the bass slowly creep in here as you were turning down a freq. 61:08 -- Creeping in even more. 62:58 -- Final transition here was good. Unfortunately I could not stand this remix of the popular track Incognition.
|
15/16) hehe, got you ;p
at 59:36 comes Zirenz blended with Angel. Angel gets back in 61:08 
Then, on 62:58 there is a mix into Incognition. You must haven't known these tracks/remixes before 
| quote: |
16) 67:38 -- Good transition. This was a good end of the night tune but it still had alot of energy IMO and could have been placed a little earlier on. I still think you should have left track 14 for the conclusion of this set.
|
17) My idea was to leave listener wanting more... Thats why the last track is emotional but on the other hand - energetic. For a while I was thinking about Epos - Vivagio for an ending.
Thanks for your constrictive criticism, and also for your kind words about the set. I'm happy that you enjoyed it overall 
___________________
My recent collaboration mix: Crosswinds (with DJ Metatron)
|