many reasons paulie.

rock stars are born. they suffer. they go through all sorts of shit and in the end they make it big - but most of em dont wanna be big - -they just wanna express themselves.

the kharntz on this show just wanna be big. therefore they are wannabes. plain old kareoke singers. yes most of em are pretty good performers, and can sing. but u do not select a rock star on a reality show. rock stars get there just cos they are rock stars.

it also expsed inxs as total wankers and i havent seen to much of this season - but im backing its doing the same for these guys.

i dunno mang - i just dont like it. its not real.

___________________
CLICK HERE FOR SOUNDCLOUD

quote:

Originally posted by Light The Fuse absolute crap. dave navarro should shoot himself in the head. lost all respect for the guy. the aussie is toby - the girlz at work lub him and used to go watch him sing is his coverband before he got on the show

you had respect for dave navarro?

I agree a bit though. Itsjust the same as idol. Its contrived just probably with people who are more up themselves.

___________________
Man who paint toilet not necessarily shithouse painter.

Fair point JPL! No doubt it is a little bit contrived. In comparing with a similar show like idol it doesnt even compare! There is talent there...I think most of them have been on a pretty hard road as it is, and its a good break for them, but i see where your coming from.

___________________
Oh, life is bigger ,It's bigger than you,And you are not me,The lengths that I will go to, The distance in your eyes ,Oh no, I've said too much, I set it up

That's me in the corner, That's me in the spotlight, I'm Losing my religion, Trying to keep up with you ,And I don't know if I can do it, Oh no, I've said too much,I haven't said enough, I thought that I heard you laughing, I thought that I heard you sing, I think I thought I saw you try.

But that was just a dream, That was just a dream, But that was just a dream, Try, cry, why try? That was just a dream ,Just a dream, just a dream, Dream

SO IDOL HAS NO TALENT WHATSOEVER?

LOL

watch an episode of rockstar then an episode of idol, then compare. It doesnt compare.

___________________
Oh, life is bigger ,It's bigger than you,And you are not me,The lengths that I will go to, The distance in your eyes ,Oh no, I've said too much, I set it up

That's me in the corner, That's me in the spotlight, I'm Losing my religion, Trying to keep up with you ,And I don't know if I can do it, Oh no, I've said too much,I haven't said enough, I thought that I heard you laughing, I thought that I heard you sing, I think I thought I saw you try.

But that was just a dream, That was just a dream, But that was just a dream, Try, cry, why try? That was just a dream ,Just a dream, just a dream, Dream

LOL YOU BOY WATCH THE ORIGINAL 'ROCKSTAR'

STAND UP AND SHOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUT

hahahahahahah

would love too see more musicianship on inxs

___________________

• TRACKS FOR GRAPE PICKING
• TRACKS WHEN YOU HAVE GLITTER STUCK ALL OVER YOU

JPL is the TA rockstar, he knows what he is talking about

To be honest I think that its great to give people opportunity in these kind of competitions. Its also very entertaining to watch (or very funny). I get your point but you can still enjoy your "organic" talent while watching these "manufactured" stars.

Watched Idol for the first time (this series) last night. I thought some of the people they picked were really bad Nobody will ever beat Guy Sebastian

___________________
www.clubsguide.com.au

nothing compares....to youuuuuuuuu!!!

___________________
new set online, Summer Journeys

HAHAHA@PHILBY HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA


What do you mean NO ONE BEATS GUY SEBASTIAN?
rofl that f'n Stevie Wonder, Prince wannabe only sang ONE GOOD TRACK, the mountains one....HAHAHAHAHAHA

Even though he is a little man, he has a great voice- NO ONE CAN BEAT ANTHONY CALLEA in Aus Idol!
Especially when he sang in Italian!
Still cant belive Casey won that year......i nearly punched a hole in the wall!

quote:

Originally posted by MiSSyM HAHAHA@PHILBY HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA What do you mean NO ONE BEATS GUY SEBASTIAN? rofl that f'n Stevie Wonder, Prince wannabe only sang ONE GOOD TRACK, the mountains one....HAHAHAHAHAHA Even though he is a little man, he has a great voice- NO ONE CAN BEAT ANTHONY CALLEA in Aus Idol! Especially when he sang in Italian! Still cant belive Casey won that year......i nearly punched a hole in the wall!

You just love faggy European types!!

As soon as the record company got a hold if Guy they turned him in to some stupid r n' b fucktard! I know there is a star inside him

And yes, I cry everytime I watch him sing "Climb Every Mountain" on my first season Australian Idol DVD

quote:

Originally posted by MiSSyM Still cant belive Casey won that year......i nearly punched a hole in the wall!

the thing you gotta remember, Caella would have been (and has been) a star anyway, so why not try to produce 2 stars by giving the weaker one the win? I doubt Idol is rigged but its gotta be pushed in a particular direction.


and Idol sucks, I can't bare to watch it at the best of times, even the ads shit me off majorly

___________________
**Man I'm Pretty**