|
| quote: | Originally posted by Nemesis44
If you have a strong melody then you don't need to go apeshit with the shakers, cowbells or anything else.
In this particular instance we can actully take the lead from a lot of rock bands as they actually only need bass, two guitars, drums and a vocalist. Not a big fan of rock but you can always hear a well written track.
|
I come from the rock and metal world, so it seemed odd to me how much layering is expected in Trance and other forms of EDM. I agree, if you have a good melody, you don't need to have to have a ton of things going on. Progressive Trance tends to have less melodies, or no real melody line at all, so that is made up for by adding a lot of percussion lines and FX, ect. Some of it sounds good, some of it is pretty sterile and boring.
I use shakers and tambourines a lot, and I'm always experimenting with new percussion sounds. I try not to overdo it though, and my tracks always have strong melody lines. Nonetheless, I gave in to the pressure of trying to fill every space of my tracks. This is mainly due to feedback I've gotten from other producers, so I assumed it was expected. I guess that's just the way it is nowadays. DJs and the average listener seem to expect it too.
I switched over to Progressive House, I think out of rebellion. Prog House seems to be more about the music, and doesn't rely so much on percussion layering and having a ton of things going on at once. It's more pure musically, much like the way Trance used to be.
___________________
soundcloud
Youtube
|