by the look of things the first 5 that replyed in this thread are the Judge's.




Judge's

Robstar
Project T
dj dave b
Peter Campbell
Waxen

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.

Last edited by Peter Campbell on Apr-11-2002 at 11:41

quote:

Originally posted by McBigMac Damn wanted to enter but didnt have time at that moment...... but anyway id really REALLY want to judge. i like the creativity, originality, Songwriting, Choice of sounds and mix/mastering idea. But i think each judge should give their own points for this, so you get like 5 scores close(Hopefully heh) to 100 and then do a average of it. Icq:144002277 Mail: [email protected]

you may have just missed out McBigMac,

exp of how the Judging should work



JO blogs

Creativity......Judge1 16 Judge2 18 Judge3 16 Judge4 18 Judge5 14 = 78

Originality.....Judge1 17 Judge2 14 Judge3 18 Judge4 18 Judge5 15 = 82

Songwriting.....Judge1 19 Judge2 14 Judge3 16 Judge4 18 Judge5 19 = 86

Choice of sounds.....Judge1 16 Judge2 11 Judge3 16 Judge4 18 Judge5 14 = 75

Mix and Mastering.....Judge1 17 Judge2 13 Judge3 16 Judge4 11 Judge5 17 = 74

_____________

78
82
86
75
74 = 395 divide by 5 = the total 79 points for JO Blogs

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.

Thats how i meant........

LoL

thought it was like

you had 5 judges for creativity,originality, songwriting, choice of sounds and mix/mastering.

Then 1 judge was for sounds, another for creativity etc etc

and then calculate.

bah who cares im not judge anyway...... ((

cheers,
MaC

___________________
"Who is General Failure and why is he reading my A: Drive ?" - WP

"Applications programming is a race between software engineers, who strive to produce idiot_proof programs, and the Universe which strives to produce bigger idiots. So far the Universe Is Winning".

When does the judging begin?
If someone could pm me with details.. that would be great. Thanks.

~S~

___________________


Heal the Past :: Live the Present :: Dream the Future

It would be pointless having a section for marks on the chord structure and melody cuz each song will have the same

[Dan]

___________________
mner

I don't think that would be pointless, cause there's more to a tune than a main theme. We can add some twists to the melody, and even though we're using the same chords, the melodies can sound different

___________________


Uncredible Haak on Soundcloud
Uncredible Haak - September 2008 mix

Isnt Creativity and Originality pretty much the same thing? Being creative is being original. if you just use the same old structure as every other song out there, its unoriginal, plus its not creative.

I'd love to judge...if only I had the slightest chance of being considered...*sigh*

___________________
World of WarCrack addict.
Still bangin the trance, lovin the sets...thanks to all who make them available (you know who you are)

quote:

Originally posted by DJ Chrono Isnt Creativity and Originality pretty much the same thing? Being creative is being original. if you just use the same old structure as every other song out there, its unoriginal, plus its not creative.

yes right, but having 3 melodies playing at one time is creative but its been done before so its not original.

they don't mean the same thing, but as you said before being creative can be original only if no one els has done it before

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.

I think there should be 2 categories of marking, not all this shit.

1. What we believe to be most musically accomplished and...
2. Our favourite.

And there to be 2 awards, eliminating all the uncertainty.

___________________

w: www.luketerry.com

quote:

Originally posted by Waxen When does the judging begin? If someone could pm me with details.. that would be great. Thanks. ~S~

sure thing Waxen I will PM you latter , I think the Judging starts around the 22 of April

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.

quote:

Originally posted by Project T I think there should be 2 categories of marking, not all this shit. 1. What we believe to be most musically accomplished and... 2. Our favourite. And there to be 2 awards, eliminating all the uncertainty.

so your saying we only need to do 2 reviews? if we did it that way there sure is going to lots of people getting no feed back at all,

I still think all the producers should know how they went and where they placed or this will just be a waist of time for them, and next time around there will be fuck all entering...

ok what I will do is put it to them to see what they want.

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.