|
| quote: | Originally posted by Allied Nations
I think the overall feeling of the night and vibe on the dancefloor is more important than the "theme" of the track or whatever idea the producer had in his head. If you find a track works better w/out a breakdown, get it out of there. I see what you're saying, but it's somewhat impractical when it comes to actually playing out. We've developed the technology to be able to rapidly edit songs in order to perfect them for dancefloor use - if that involves cutting out a breakdown (or adding one as I've done to plenty of techno records), so be it.
IMO |
I understand as far as the dancefloor is concerned but there are many trance tracks of the epic variety that to eliminate the breakdown, is to eliminate the basic ingredient in the track. There's a track called "Time To Say Goodbye" by Envio. The breakdown is massive, and to me..if that was to be taken out of the track...it would take something away from the track. Maybe other examples would be Hydra's "Affinity (Thrillseekers Dub)" or Mike Shiver's "Feelings (Cosmicman's Messah Remix)". Definitely Solar Stone's "Seven Cities" would be totally missing the magic of the track without it's unbelievably beautiful breakdown.
To me, not every track in a set should be this pounding rhythm, there needs to be some variety. If a set just had the same sounding bassline, kick drum, hi hats etc...it wouldn't keep me interested. There should be some melodic or harmonic elements, esp in a trance set. You could get away with not having that in a drum n' bass, breaks or techno set, but not trance or house IMO.
So I guess playing rhythmic tracks mixed in with tracks where there are breakdowns is better than playing all rhythmic tracks with no breakdowns or sets with breakdown after breakdown. Even if they are just minor breakdowns, there should be some release and tension, and I think breakdowns give a set this. Besides, not everyone has the stamina to dance non-stop for two or three hours...so having some variety or low points in a set either in the beginning, somewhere in the middle, or at the end...is good IMO.
Last edited by Spirit5 on Aug-06-2007 at 18:28
|