lets not get too far off topic now

What i was wondering when i started this thread, was wether the use of vocals in some remixes is beyond the remixer's control... Its perplexing that they would create such a solid track in the first place that the vocals sound out of place , its almost like they were just doing their stuff making great music, until the time comes to actually include the vocals into the track... I cant count anymore the number of times ive been led into the song with a great buildup, only to be dissapointed when the vocals come in

Last edited by carmatic on Nov-22-2007 at 06:09

I generally don't like vocals in the more mainstream genres of electronic music, like house or trance. Some of the less "well defined" genres though, I feel completely the opposite. Groups like Massive Attack do some incredible stuff with their range of different vocalists.

Edit: Sorry, I'm a bit off topic.

___________________

quote:

Originally posted by carmatic lets not get too far off topic now What i was wondering when i started this thread, was wether the use of vocals in some remixes are beyond the remixer's control... Its perplexing that they would create such a solid track in the first place that the vocals sound out of place , its almost like they were just doing their stuff making great music, until the time comes to actually include the vocals into the track... I cant count anymore the number of times ive been led into the song with a great buildup, only to be dissapointed when the vocals come in

Ok, to directly answer that...

Maybe they thought adding the vocal track was an improvement to the song? Because you don't like it, doesn't mean they don't. Often, remixers will remove large chunks of the vocal track, but I would think that is also due to their own taste. I'm not sure it sounds reasonable that a producer would be "forced" to include a vocal track?

Another reason for using vocals in EDM might be in order to appeal to a more mainstream market, and get some radio time/record sales. Again, it's not necessarily forced, but hey, it's nice to make a few bucks right?

___________________

hmmmmm, this is going to have to be precise


i pick:
Iio - Rapture (AVB remix)

___________________
Everything is beautiful. Let the music carry you. Baby I will follow you forever. Nowhere else I'd rather be when you're lying next to me. Let the music carry us together.
anti-JennyPie Alliance
SuspicionVandit: Are you God?
Paul Van Dyk 09-24-2009: No, but I can sign your sleeve under that name if you let me!

Vocals definitely fit house music the best. Some vocal trance tracks are okay, but house music just does them so much better...even those diva tracks! Justine Suissa is probably up there with Jan Johnston for vocal trance tracks....of all vocalists Jan Johnston has done the most for trance IMO

quote:

Originally posted by Sykonee 2 Unlimited - Get Ready For This

I always thought it was the other way around for 2 Unlimited, because the UK versions were usually the largely instrumental ones. Apparently they thought that the UK would prefer more dancey, less poppy tracks. However, seems I was wrong.

On the subject more generally, vocals often work perfectly well in electronic music, provided the track was specifically written for them. Shitty "slap a vocal on" money-grabbing versions almost always suck, even though there are occasional exceptions.

That said, I rarely have time for vocals in trance.

___________________
Mixes:
> Maximum Elevation [Progressive House]
> DI.FM 26th Anniversary Guest Mix [Progressive House]
> Live @ Dance:Love:Hub London, 11.10.2025
> Higher Peaks [Progressive House]
> Dance:Love:Hub Afterparty (The Return) 23.11.24

Like these sets? Come see me play live at Kibosh in Manchester: https://www.instagram.com/kibosh.mcr/