Deadmau5 was THE MAN of the year in the minimal section!!!
Other favorites where Ame-Rej, Francois Dubois-I Try, Ozgur Can-Spara Mig, Antena-Camino Del Sol and you can't forget the massive Julian Jeweil-Air Conditionne!
Originally posted by JohnBeaver
I consider alot of his stuff minimal such as Jaded, Faxing Berlin and Contact! I guess I would call it minimal trance
well it's NOT FUCKING MINIMAL so I guess that makes you directly wrong. These genre labels actually have meanings and they're not subjective. Deadmau5 makes boring (i.e. formulaic and unimaginative) prog and occasionally a halfway-decent tech house remix.
People call so much stuff minimal that isn't remotely minimal. Stop. Samim is not minimal. Supermayer is not minimal. Gabriel Ananda is not minimal. Sasha is REALLY not minimal. Just because something isn't as big sounding as another song of the same genre does not make it minimal.
Dec-07-2007 20:56
bullz
Senior tranceaddict
Registered: Mar 2006
Location: a windmill down by the river
quote:
Originally posted by progressiveMOJO
well it's NOT FUCKING MINIMAL so I guess that makes you directly wrong. These genre labels actually have meanings and they're not subjective. Deadmau5 makes boring (i.e. formulaic and unimaginative) prog and occasionally a halfway-decent tech house remix.
People call so much stuff minimal that isn't remotely minimal. Stop. Samim is not minimal. Supermayer is not minimal. Gabriel Ananda is not minimal. Sasha is REALLY not minimal. Just because something isn't as big sounding as another song of the same genre does not make it minimal.
Samim produces techno- tech house and occasional minimal when he teams up with Michal Ho.
Supermayer is on this thread cuz they produce techno too. Gabriel Ananda also procudes techno and the occasional minimal. You can't say that the artist you said are not whatever genre you said. They are just producers/dj's which make whatever genre they decide to. (Like Holden for ex. He just produces whatever the hell he wants to. He started making trance[horizons], then got into techno[a break through the coulds], then to some crazy experimental shit[the idiots are wining lp])
The music is labeled, not the artist.
I know your point though... its just that people who incorrectly label music wrong dont listen to "minimal" enough to know. They're probably ASOT listeners... you can't get all pissed off at that shit... give 'em a break.
Originally posted by JohnBeaver
Deadmau5 was THE MAN of the year in the minimal section!!!
Other favorites where Ame-Rej, Francois Dubois-I Try, Ozgur Can-Spara Mig, Antena-Camino Del Sol and you can't forget the massive Julian Jeweil-Air Conditionne!
you don't have the slightest idea what minimal is do you? because none of the above is even remotely close to minimal.
quote:
I consider alot of his stuff minimal such as Jaded, Faxing Berlin and Contact! I guess I would call it minimal trance
again, not even close, just because "you consider it" minimal trance doesn't make it so. plus deadmau5 is boring, i can barely even tell his tracks apart they all sound like the same thing.
....and progressiveMOJO is right.
quote:
I know your point though... its just that people who incorrectly label music wrong dont listen to "minimal" enough to know. They're probably ASOT listeners... you can't get all pissed off at that shit... give 'em a break.
yeah most likely ppl who listen to ASOT probably think anything that doesn't sound like progressive house or trance is minimal
expand your horizons yo!
___________________
quote:
Originally posted by Direct
She indeed is a goddess. I would cut her body in half and hang her upper half in the shower and take her lower and fuck it on my bed.
check out my music @ http://www.xstreamist.com/members/270/audio.php
www.bucke.podomatic.com
Dec-09-2007 06:12
JohnBeaver
Supreme tranceaddict
Registered: Aug 2006
Location: San Jose, CA
quote:
Originally posted by bucke
you don't have the slightest idea what minimal is do you? because none of the above is even remotely close to minimal.
again, not even close, just because "you consider it" minimal trance doesn't make it so. plus deadmau5 is boring, i can barely even tell his tracks apart they all sound like the same thing.
....and progressiveMOJO is right.
yeah most likely ppl who listen to ASOT probably think anything that doesn't sound like progressive house or trance is minimal
expand your horizons yo!
Whoa I never ment to offend anyone in this thread! I was mistaken and I assumed that these tracks where labeled as minimal because like people pointed out everyone normally calls this stuff minimal. I stand corrected!
Originally posted by progressiveMOJO
well it's NOT FUCKING MINIMAL so I guess that makes you directly wrong. These genre labels actually have meanings and they're not subjective. Deadmau5 makes boring (i.e. formulaic and unimaginative) prog and occasionally a halfway-decent tech house remix.
People call so much stuff minimal that isn't remotely minimal. Stop. Samim is not minimal. Supermayer is not minimal. Gabriel Ananda is not minimal. Sasha is REALLY not minimal. Just because something isn't as big sounding as another song of the same genre does not make it minimal.
Damn, someone was having a bad day!
Dec-09-2007 07:16
progressiveMOJO
Supreme tranceaddict
Registered: Aug 2004
Location: Black Rock City
i ran out of weed
Dec-09-2007 11:42
djillicit
Supreme tranceaddict
Registered: Sep 2003
Location: The Netherlands
LOVING Dubfire - I Feel Speed, Original and UNKLE remix FTW!
"Only after the last tree has been cut down,
Only after the last river has been poisoned,
Only after the last fish has been caught,
Only then will you find that money cannot be eaten."
--- Cree Indian Prophecy
Dec-09-2007 12:57
dcctnycprincess
TechnoAddict
Registered: Feb 2006
Location: Getty's Central Garden
quote:
Originally posted by JohnBeaver
Deadmau5 was THE MAN of the year in the minimal section!!!
Other favorites where Ame-Rej, Francois Dubois-I Try, Ozgur Can-Spara Mig, Antena-Camino Del Sol and you can't forget the massive Julian Jeweil-Air Conditionne!
