|
| quote: | | But the value of gold - or any other hard commodity - is just as prone to supply / demand fluctuations as any currency is! |
Who are talking about hard commodities. it is a total myth that gold represent any value, it does not represent any value other than one agreed upon by the marked place. Why, because gold is pretty much useless. So we have an imagined value for it, and this is the key point. money is an imagined entity, it can be anything, but the SYSTEM behind the money, the idea. Has to change, and gold has been suggested. Im not overly keen on the idea of Gold, for the same reasons you are, but as i said allready. youre whistling flour. A gold standard makes no sense if we pretty much keep the system as is, i agree.
| quote: | | And how are you going to "trade" from this autarky unless you acknowledge that your currency - whether its gold or the dollar - has a variable value relative to the currencies of the countries your going to be trading with? |
again, money is an imagined entity, what really exchanged, is services and or goods, and money only represents a certain amount of either. You could say money is liquid representations of work hours and or efford.
| quote: | | Are you going to mandate that they trade exclusively in gold too? What's that going to do for demand for (and therefore the value of) gold? |
whatever they please aslong as there is a mutually agreed upon exhcange of actual value taking place. Actual value isnt money obviously, unless money is made of something we concive to be worth something on its own, unlike paper and nickel. money has become nothing but a distraction.
| quote: | | Credit creation is a legitimate means of distributing wealth so long as the credit is ammassed on solid, reliable foundations. | [
which they arent and havent been since mid 1700's for europe, somewhat later for the states. The mad inlfation is a direct result of this way of trading. it is not trading in goods and servies but promises which are...well worthless.
| quote: | | I agree that the US market has a problem with writing checks that it can't afford, but that's more a sign of poor management than of systemic market failure. |
nope, thats the whole world in that clap trap but a very few places, it is just blatantly obvious with the US atm. every money you borrow, whatever it is, undermindes the value of all the moneis allready present in the system if it is not backed by an agreed upon exchange of value, some insist gold is the magic solution, to me it makes little difference if it is gold or the actual services represented by "hours" instead of monies.
| quote: | | This should clear things up: |
clear up what excactly?
| quote: | | I suppose it performs exactly the same function as the federal gold bureau would in your libertarian utopia (i.e. to manage the supply and value of a given currency)? |
in "my libertarian utopia" what the fuck is wrong with you people constantly trying to smack people into a safebox, so you can safely handle them by saying to yourself "i know who he is, or is with". And no, that is not what a central bank does. Try again!
___________________
edit sig- image too large edit sig - image too small edit sig - image too green edit sig - image too ghey edit sig - image not canadian enough edit sig - wtfeva!
|