quote:

Originally posted by Jarvmeister I disagree, I enjoy being impressed by skill as well as the beats. Get the two right and I'm bouncing.

'skill' is a very relative thing

quote:

Originally posted by Jarvmeister I disagree, I enjoy being impressed by skill as well as the beats. Get the two right and I'm bouncing.

It takes skill to play good music, regardless of what an individual is using to create it.

quote:

Originally posted by Zoso I honestly thought you'd be a little more critical than that, Rob. Not trying to pick a fight, obviously, but I was under the impression that you weren't easily impressed with a "laptop" DJ. Perhaps I've misunderstood.

I'm impressed by artists who are impressive, not by the technology or medium they use.

Does that mean my standards for what qualifies as good are the same regardless of what medium an individual is using? Absolutely not, that's apples & oranges.

I just happen to think that levying any praise or criticism on anyone solely because of the format they use is ludicrous.

___________________
last minute disco dot net

what rjt said

quote:

Originally posted by RJT I'm impressed by artists who are impressive, not by the technology or medium they use. Does that mean my standards for what qualifies as good are the same regardless of what medium an individual is using? Absolutely not, that's apples & oranges. I just happen to think that levying any praise or criticism on anyone solely because of the format they use is ludicrous.

Gotcha. Well spoken.

I use an Xponent and my MBP most of the time for house parties. However I rarely use the auto beat-match function of Traktor. Good music and fun are the only things that matter though. I could care less what one does as long as he/she has good taste in music.

___________________

I also just want to add that I think part of the problem of the whole medium debate is that it seems many folks want to assert that the same standards for what qualifies as "good" dj'ing across the board between mediums (digital, CD, vinyl).

The way I look at it is that each of those formats (and any number of others) warrant praise and/or criticism for very different things. If you see someone flawlessly beatmaching and phrasing mixes perfectly on vinyl (or to some extent, CD's), it's a far sight more impressive than those same things are when watching a laptop DJ.

By the same token, however, sometimes guys on laptops can do things (dropping various samples, mashups, etc.) that either wouldn't work on vinyl or CD's, or might just wind up sounding so jumbled working from those mediums that you'd ask yourself "Why are they even bothering?"

....

Side note/thought experiment for you guys: I realize this isn't possible, but imagine you heard the best set you've ever heard of your life (with no qualifiers other than "the best set I have ever heard") - and imagine hearing it as a promo, live set download, or radio show where you couldn't see it being put together or the format, and then imagine hearing that same set out at a party or club in full view of exactly what the DJ is doing.

Would that set lose any quality if you found out it had been done on a laptop? Or would it remain an awesome set?



For me, if your answer is "My mind would change because of the format", that just seems a bit ridiculous.

___________________
last minute disco dot net

I think there is an important point to make with the way in which the gear is used.

I think what is being missed in this thread is the fact that the vast majority of people who use autobeatmatching tools e.g. Ableton etc. well, have some pretty high class skills both in terms of DJing (The traditional way) and in terms of productions so have a very different ear for music than someone who has just picked up Ableton and learnt how to warp beats.

As a DJ, I like to be impressed by other DJs, I like to see hardworking talented people behind the decks, regardless of their format.

I have a hard time accepting someone who is just stringing tunes together without thought whatever medium. And the only thing that separates the two mediums in this case is that one of the crap DJs will have perfect beatmatching, but both track selections will be arse and will most likely clash harmonically (Yes I know this doeesn´t upset all of you). A bad DJ is a bad DJ.

On a personal level however I still have yet to be impressed by the autobeatmatchers... and if anything the only thing it´s really done for DJing in my opinion is take the fun out of it.

Cheers
Nem

___________________
https://www.mixcloud.com/Calvin_Karass/

quote:

Side note/thought experiment for you guys: I realize this isn't possible, but imagine you heard the best set you've ever heard of your life (with no qualifiers other than "the best set I have ever heard") - and imagine hearing it as a promo, live set download, or radio show where you couldn't see it being put together or the format, and then imagine hearing that same set out at a party or club in full view of exactly what the DJ is doing. Would that set lose any quality if you found out it had been done on a laptop? Or would it remain an awesome set?

Well...to be sure if its the best set I've heard there's prob a lot more going on then simply what is being used for putting the set together. It could be done on a Ipod mixer from Numark for all I care.

This seems darkly similar to the "DJs aren't musicians babblespeak" ...DJs aren't TRUE DJs because they don't use vinyl or whatever.

If its the best set I've ever heard:

A)There's shit I've never heard before and probably never will ever again
B)Bringing in a classic at the right time
C)It flows like a river
D)There's some new stuff that's blows your socks off
E)The beginning is EPIC
F)The ending makes you suicidal because its over. And its over. No encores.
G)I don't need drugs to get high while listening to it.
H)I dance my ass off.
I)Its long as hell

And it pretty much becomes that highly regarded, classic set that gets bounced around for a while...never losing its place on my ipod.

So it pretty much supports the argument.

BUT performance wise...live etc. a laptop seems honestly lame.
If its live prod, sure.

To be perfectly honest I don't pay attention to the DJ at all at clubs.

quote:

Originally posted by jpgrdnr To be perfectly honest I don't pay attention to the DJ at all at clubs.

Good man, but then it also goes to say that format should never matter to you, period.

___________________
last minute disco dot net

as long as the music is good and they're not using mixed in key, I think it's fine.
Having a program beatmatching for you is one thing, but practically picking the records for you as well?..... fuck no.

Perfect beatmatching doesn't constitute a great DJ. There are many other factors.

___________________
I've never been able to eat a whole baby.
Kill the women. Eat the children.
It's just one of those days where you want to bend over everyone you know and kiss their ass goodbye with a big sideways boot.

Latest Mix