|
Re: Re: Texas school district to let teachers carry guns
| quote: | Originally posted by DigiNut
How likely do you think it is for some runt to pull a gun in school - either on a teacher or another student - knowing that the teachers are armed?
I'm not sure why you mock it with sarcasm - it is quite logical. |
come on...you actually support this?
well, let's just arm EVERYONE. if everyone can have a gun, no one will shoot anyone else, right? 100% deterrence!!!
come on...
when someone is about to shoot someone else, or even just threaten them with a gun, they generally don't stand up on a chair and shout "get ready, you have 5 seconds before I pull out mah gun!"
don't they pull out a gun and point it in the heat of the moment or they plan out an attack in advance? what 'prevention' can happen here if some teachers are armed?
deterence? maybe. that's really the only *remotely* credible motive here, IMHO, and I'm not convinced that's really going to be the case.
there *may* be a deterrent effect on those who aren't truly fucking nuts. you and I, rational human beings, probably would think again about pulling out a gun knowing someone else might have one too. the problem is that rational human beings tend not to be the ones threatening other students with guns or shooting up schools.
if anything, doesn't this mean that teacher is going to be the first one to eat a bullet when something *does* happen? doesn't this increase the possibility of an accident? what line is being drawn here? Will a teacher who fears for student or personal safety due to a fist fight be able to point a gun to break it up?
I really would like to see the study that provides a shred of credibility for this type of policy. If there is merit in it, why does no other school district in the U.S. apparently permit/condone this? So the adminstration of the "Harrold Independent School District", that serves a whopping 110 students, has achieved some level of enlightenment that has baffled experts in gun violence for all this time?
sorry...I don't buy it.
btw...what would have happened differently on that Greyhound bus if someone had a gun? NOT MUCH. The victim was suddenly and repeatedly stabbed with a hunting knife, by a nutjob sitting right beside him, without any warning whatsoever. If someone had a gun, I suppose the victim wouldn't have been DACAPITATED though...he would just be dead. fantastic.
I'm not saying "do nothing" and just accept gun violence in schools as 100% beyond control...and I see your point that becoming complacent and "solving everything with discussion" can be naive...but is arming teachers *really* a good solution here?
by that logic, wherever there is gun violence (i.e. pretty much anywhere), someone should be armed?
Last edited by MarkT on Aug-16-2008 at 02:26
|