|
Hmm you guys have some points, but theory differs from practical use quite often.
Take two tunes that have the same key at nominal speed (so when those tunes are at their 0%). But one tune is slower than the other.
Theory says that when pitching up/down tunes, a difference of 5.9% will mean a difference of one semitone (for the guys that know nothing of music, picture a piano, hit one key, the key next to it is a semitone).
Theoretically when you calculate, this means that at (roughly) 3%, the difference will be a quarter tone. Two tunes at a quarter tone will sound pretty crappy, in theory...
But from experience I can tell it will still sound good. Up to say 4.5-5% it will still be good enough to call it an harmonic mix.
Once you go over that, you're better off to take another record (either same key at roughly the same speed, or a semitone difference if the speed difference is high).
I agree, harmonic mixing isn't required to make good mixes. Harmonic mixing is an extra. I just found that mixes needed something more, and harmonic mixing has that little extra. When you know the keys, it's much easier to make perfect blending mixes whereever you want (no clashing basslines, and don't tell me use the EQ, you'll still perceive it as wrong, and no boring intro-outro mixing). But it gets even funnier if you try mixing more than two records. Mixing in chords. It's very very difficult with melodical trance, because so much is going on. But knowing your keys makes it a whole lot easier, and when you're able to pull of such mixes, believe me, you'll be happy you did.
|