quote:

Originally posted by Robert . then a poll with the chosen tracks so everyone can vote. then offcourse we'll need some judges who are committed... any ideas on this?

quote:

Originally posted by Trancevision Perhaps we could search for judges in the Music Discussion or the chill out forum because there are much more people than here ( ) Trancevision

well lets just put 2 of them together, when all the tracks are in posty a STICKY Thread in the music Discussion or the chill out where anyone can download and vote

ATM it looks like its everyone against Robert and robstar

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.

Im in agreeance with HaaK if he has the accepella, it would be cool to remix other tunes aswell with accepella

i use midi to grab a hold of the track's notes for remix. i have several midis online at my page. but shouldn't a simple midi like pjotr g made be enough to get going on a track?

odrori : personally i think 5 tracks will be too much or dangerous to the compo since we would have like 5 remix compo's at the end if something goes wrong

the last point is that i think the judges should be chosen before the compo starts, that way the judges know what they're about to do later on. maybe think out a clear rating system too... everyone followed in peter's steps last time and in the end he happened to be the only one rating it completely.

cheers,
Wim/LW

___________________
Icone / Van Gelder / Blue Manta / The Elemental

Icone Home
Icone Store -> New Percussion SAMPLE CD here!
Icone MySpace

quote:

where anyone can download and vote

That's a good idea. We don't need no judges, so everyone can decide, which is the best track.

Or is it too dangerous because some might have more friends here at tranceaddict, which would vote for them ?

quote:

personally i think 5 tracks will be too much or dangerous

I think it is easier to compare all the contributions if we only have
one track to be remixed...

Trancevision

that is a good idea to get everyone to vote. to stop the 'ive got more friends=votes than you' problem the tracks would have to be anonymous.

nice idea.

Yeah i agree it should only be one track. how bout 5 tracks are picked by whoever is going to judge it then the people who are going to enter vote in poll. the winning track is then the track to remix. ?

good idea tho

___________________
http://www.factoria.co.uk

quote:

Originally posted by Lightworks the last point is that i think the judges should be chosen before the compo starts, that way the judges know what they're about to do later on. maybe think out a clear rating system too... everyone followed in peter's steps last time and in the end he happened to be the only one rating it completely. cheers, Wim/LW

no Judging for me this time with the time on my hands I might just be in this one.

I think the judges were picked to early last time and lost interest 2 weeks later, anyway lets just hope we can fully compleat this one

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.

quote:

Originally posted by delphini blue nice idea. Yeah i agree it should only be one track. how bout 5 tracks are picked by whoever is going to judge it then the people who are going to enter vote in poll. the winning track is then the track to remix. ? good idea tho

yea we did that one in the first comp, everyone just voted for there own track and ended up with almost one vote each.

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.

quote:

Originally posted by Robert that is a good idea to get everyone to vote. to stop the 'ive got more friends=votes than you' problem the tracks would have to be anonymous.

thats right only have the name of the track and when its over reveal who produced it

___________________
Signature is over the 500X150 limit, please resize.

right.. in about 12 hours i'll start a new thread with a poll for all the nominated tracks.. so post your track in this thread before then... or else....

i`m in this one again

i think its cool 2 remix an track with vocals, u can nicely play with those

___________________
www.luukmaes.tk

Robert, stickied this thread for u, good luck to all that participate

___________________
My Mixcloud Profile My Twitch Channel