|
First, allow me to apologise if I get carried away in making sarcastic comments and such. You have to understand though, I have to defend my beliefs on stuff like this constantly. I can only hear "How can you think that, blah, blah, blah" so many times before I snap and start firing back asking people how *they* can think what they do, often in a snide way.
It's a weakness that I've largely toned down over the years, but it's still a weakness, so please don't take it too personally.
On with a response then:
| quote: | Originally posted by ABTsportsline
It just seems from your arguements that there is (forgive the lack of a better word) "tree-hugger" effects coming from your criticisms - |
Well, that'd make sense, since I *have* been known to quite literally give trees a hug, so I naturally don't take offence to the term.
Frankly, I think environmental concerns are tossed aside a little too easily by too many people. You know that desert that Baghdad is sitting in? That used to be the most prosperous place in the world, the birthplace of civilisation, and look what it is now...a desert.
I don't propose that humans are going to irreversably damage the planet, but I think we can easily destroy all the life on it, and our own prospects for survival, which is pretty much the same end result in my book.
I think my regard for things like this is most obviously manifested in some of my Taoist and Aboriginal oriented beliefs that speak to finding our own place in nature, a balance as it were.
Western religion has always taken nature as a *gift from God to be used* while I disagree vehemently. The world is no more ours than it is anything elses, and as the "highest" creatures in existence here (that we know of at least) I think we have a little bit of an obligation to play the caretaker.
So yes, I'm a very green oriented person.
| quote: |
i don't see how you figure this and how it bothers you or effects this thread.
|
I answered the first part, and the only reason it really entered this thread was because you asked why I have so much animosity towards the US, and I answered.
Sorry if it's out of the context of this thread, but to be honest your initial question probably was as well if you want to get picky about it. I generally just let things flow where they will in this forums, and I don't think anyone in general takes offence to digression that springs off the main topic. :shrug:
| quote: |
If you wanted to really break it down, most modernized countries do these things and are guilty of said charges. I know its an "american" thread, but i never see any criticisms from you about any other country. |
I dislike the things capitalism *in general* has done to the planet, but I'm most familar with US based actions, so again, I usually chime in, as I said earlier.
I agree that I probably touch on the US a little too much, but that's really just because I'm sick and tired of people in the country presenting this rosey picture instead of seeing things as they actually are. I don't deal with hypocrisy in the UK for instance, so I'm not as pissed off about it.
I like the TA forums because they're an international representation, and it's refreshing to hear other people who share my opinions from other parts of the world on US policy and so forth, so yes, I hit the US regularly and hard, but that isn't to say I don't dislike the things capitalism in general, religion in general, and so forth have done.
| quote: |
Just to add a point about the deforestations, thats not US government, thats big business - and remember _someone_ is selling this land to the companies to do this. |
The US government has shown itself time and time again to be in full support of business practices and policies. The few rules we *do* have regarding things like monopolies are regularly ignored when the business in question is powerful enough (ie: Microsoft anyone?)
Capitalism is almost inseperable from the US government policy at this point, so it's hard for me to level criticism *only* on the business, because the government *could* regulate if they wanted to.
I'm certainly not saying the people selling the land down there to US interests are people of high moral code, but just because someone is willing to sell doesn't mean we should buy if ethics state otherwise.
IMHO environmental based ethics would certainly state that deforestation is a loss that isn't worth the gains.
| quote: |
If this aspect really bothers you, you should definitely consider writing a letter to these companies. (and realtors in south america). But it would be naive to think that the human race is going to destroy earth. She's been here for billions of years, through a LOT worse than us.... |
I already touched on some of this in other parts, but in short:
The human race might not be able to physically destroy earth (as in, reduce it to the cosmic dust it started as) but we can certainly make the planet uninhabitable for life, that's really not a very tall order at all.
Detroy some ecosystems, poison the water, cut down the trees, and eventually you'll get a nice large series of deserts with poisoned water surrounding them. That might not be total destruction, but it certainly isn't the kind of planet *I* would like to be born into.
Do you honestly believe that writing a few letters to some realtors (or to the corps in America buying) would actually have an affect?
That view just strikes me as naive...
Companies could care less about anything other than:
A) What they can get away with
B) Making money
Unless they think there's money to be *lost* in doing something it's unlikely they're going to do it. In an ideal world where people actually gave a shite, and signed a mass petition (thereby threatening a loss of income), yes, the companies involved might rethink things.
But this isn't that world.
| quote: |
It honestly hurts me deep down to see so many americans slandering their own country, and here's why. Remember i fight for my country's freedom, to protect your freedoms, etc. I have been to war and will probably go again soon. I might take a bullet next time i'm out just to help preserve what you have now, i never know. Can you honestly say that your life is that miserable? think of what *you* actually do to try to fix or help contribute... what are you doing about all these "wrongs" going on?
|
Good emotional plea here, but I'm a pacifist, remember? I'm not going to call you a devil for going off to fight for America (I've got a few friends in the military myself), but I'm not going to support you either. Trust me, there are plenty of people who will though, probably without giving a second thought to it.
And you're missing the point in my statement to a large extent. I'm upset with the state of affairs in the US for the long list I laid out. I'm not miserable, I'm simply unhappy with the popular opinions, policies, and perspectives in this country, enough so that I want to leave.
My primary issue, the absolute killer, is that Americans have a built-in disdain for the poor, and for socialised programs. Take that away, and I'd at least have hope, but the normal attitude towards these kinds of things is so far right field from me, that I can't even begin to understand where many people are coming from.
I really equate this to an overall lack of empathy in America, and *that* is the largest issue here IMHO.
As such, the best thing I can do to change things is what I'm doing right here...talking to people, and offering them a new perspective. If more people had an understanding of what it's like to be poor, had an understanding of what the US led sanctions on Iraq are doing to ordinary people, and so forth I'd like to think that they'd be able to find a little bit of empathy somewhere in their cold, ego-centric lives.
I'm going to school in both History and Philosophy, and will likely wind up writing books and teaching at university level at some point in my life, again, trying to affect change by helping people to see other perspectives.
| quote: |
It feels like i'm doing everything all in vain when there is no gratification. I am not doing this for the pay, thats for sure (pay's a joke here).... i'm doing it to see smiles on americans faces, to see the reaching out of arms of the civilians in the 3rd world countries when they see us marching in, to see the relieved looks on faces in afghani villages when the locals have realized we kicked out the taliban forces..... and most importantly, for american citizens. Nothing is more satisfying than walking into Subway to get a sandwich (wearing my uniform), and having someone behind the counter just say "hey, thanks for doing this for us - for protecting us." Thats happened a couple of times and it makes it all worthwhile.... 
i know that sounds sappy, but its the truth. I don't ask that you praise your government or be content with it. Just to realize that nobody is perfect, and we never claimed to be. Our only job and efforts have been to make life safe and easy for you. And correct me if i'm wrong but we've been doing a pretty good job at that... |
My life is safe (though most people seem to not think that it is, note locked doors, high gun sales, and so forth) and it's relatively easy, but that's due in large part to my luck of having parents who are at least working class. I don't think life is easy for people born into the inner city, the reservation, or any number of other unpleasant situations.
Again, I can appreciate your feeling about being a soldier, but I can't support it, as people can have their hearts in the right place, but still be doing the wrong thing.
As I said above, it's not as though my opinion is a majority one. Keep walking down the street, I'm sure you'll get pats on the back, and happy greetings. I'm sorry if it ruins your day to realise that some people have different views on what's right, important, and so forth, but that's what happens when you let people think for themselves *and* they actually do it.
Trust me, perfection is the furthest thing from my agenda. (well, my immediate agenda at least) One of my favourite sayings is "Screw up, and be a human" because we're a very imperfect species. And I like it that way, to live among perfection is to live among Gods, and that doesn't sound very appealing to me.
But lack of perfection isn't what I'm chiding the US government for, it's outright disregard for principals that matter to me.
For example, socialised health care.
Canada's system is far from perfect, and it's in a state of serious overhaul right now. I don't hold the chaos that exists currently against them though, because they've at least got their hearts in the right place, while the US opinion seems to be that health *isn't* an essential right, and that it's just fine for people to die due to inadequate treatment that's a direct result of their strata in society.
And so on, honestly at this point to say more is to beat a dead horse. I do have to make one final distinction though.
As far as general life philosophy goes, I'm not an unhappy person. I can take profound joy in things that normal people don't even realise they're doing, like drinking a tall glass of icy water or taking a casual stroll through the woods, or even just breathing in winter air deeply.
The one area that constantly drags me down is political matters, and as such, on a forum like this, you likely get a view of me as a pissy, mal-adjusted, and none too happy person, and nothing could really be further from the truth.
I just wish more people could stop worrying about accruing *stuff*, and instead work on personal betterment. I wish capitalism would go by the wayside so we could have a sytem set up where people work rarely, and have more time to actually *live*. I'm a Buddhist economist in that I think our prosperity, as in the prosperity of our *souls* should be measured not by how much we consume, but by how little we require. Once you stop craving mass produced crap to feel good the economy as we know it starts to tumble, and actual progress can be made.
As long as people are obsessed with buying the biggest SUV so people think they have big dicks, the world is going to be lacking something for people of my stripe, and that's really all there is to it.
Consumption on the level that it exists today in capitalism is simply put, folly. If people wanted less, there'd be fewer things being made. Which means there'd be fewer jobs. Which means people would need to work fewer total hours to produce everything that was needed. And that increased free time to *live* is what's needed for real change.
Again, sorry if this went horribly off topic, but I generally just let my thoughts flow as they will...
|