the big deal is that he makes good shit, and most trance fans can appreciate it.
the same way most prog heads CANT appreciate uplifting and most uplifters cant appreciate prog...those who are inbetween can see whats good about both, and like it...
and dont bother trying to label it cause no one knows what they are talking about|
___________________
'That's like telling a Kodiak bear to stop fcking older men.'
Nov-21-2002 19:03
vmc
Travelling Without Moving
Registered: Jan 2002
Location: Poland
I don't consider his stuff house, it's progressive I guess. Too little high hats for house (for example).
if you ask me, id label him 'progressive trance' - whatever it is labeled as its still ownage
___________________
rewinding ; Terry Grant - 'I'll Kill You' (Bedrock)
--
"Playing records you love to people that like them is probably one of the best jobs there is, and I wouldn't swap it for anything. Apart from inventing new lego, which is probably more fun and has less late nights and long aeroplane journeys"
- James Holden
Nov-21-2002 19:15
capricorn15
__
Registered: May 2001
Location: CA
maybe becasue of his song horizons, that sounds like trance to me, but i like progressive too, so i dont really care
Nov-21-2002 19:56
shoXx
IDM addict
Registered: Jun 2001
Location:
quote:
Originally posted by liquidxxd
maybe becasue of his song horizons, that sounds like trance to me, but i like progressive too, so i dont really care
Please check your pm-box m8.
___________________
when there's no more room in hell, the dead will walk the earth
Nov-21-2002 20:07
Holden Forevah!
tranceaddict in training
Registered: Nov 2002
Location: Leiden, Holland
I agree with Basd here
quote:
Originally posted by basd
*yawn*
Putting every track in its own small labeled box is laughable.
Why do people want to classify every track they hear? More important, why do people argue about bs like this? Just enjoy it..
*/yawn*
I have to agree with Basd on this one. As you may see in my profile I'm a huge admirer of the "stuff" James produces, but I never wondered for a minute what style it's supposed to be. Who cares? The only time it mattered was on Innercity 2001 cause they had to put him in a hall. They chose the "progressive hall" for him, but I would have listened to him if he was in the "Full of shit hall" (yeah, I know, it doesn't exist but it would be fun if they had one ) as well. As long as he remains the number one dj I'll always go where he goes, nomather how they call it.
I've always wondered what it is with house and the box-mentality. Just enjoy the music whatever it's called. Grtz Crazy K.C.
___________________
Every special night I wonder, why do days exist again?
Number one song ever!!! : Accadia - Into the Dawn (James Holden Remix)
Nov-21-2002 20:19
netw3rkd
trancEaddict in JAIL
Registered: Jun 2002
Location: Kitchener / ON
Dude we all know epic trance is DA SHIT!!! Tiesto is the best DJ in the world and armin owns you all. EPIC TRANCE 4 EVAR DAWg
! ;x
Nov-21-2002 20:57
Ste
Planet Zogg Addict
Registered: Oct 2001
Location: Outer Dementia
Re: The Big Deal About James Holden
quote:
Originally posted by Bedrock
what is it with trancers and James Holden? I'm at a loss to why his productions are viewed as trance, and yet most progressive house gets passed as 'boring'?
because theyre arrogant ****s and try to re-pigionhole music they like?
ive always thought holden as a prog house dj/producer. i dont knwo where the fuck the trance element comes from in some peoples minds...
___________________
Fave Tune at the Moment: Mesmerizer - Taking Control
This is prog house with trancey elemnts, theres much much more of a trance structure to Holdens music than a lot of prog house producers.
Hes not trance but he wouldn't be out of place playing a longside trance djs
Nov-21-2002 21:37
Cobalt
Trance Isn't Trance
Registered: Apr 2002
Location: Vancouver, BC
Re: The Big Deal About James Holden
quote:
Originally posted by Bedrock
what is it with trancers and James Holden? I'm at a loss to why his productions are viewed as trance, and yet most progressive house gets passed as 'boring'?
...
No comment.
Nov-21-2002 22:26
Elyksir
Supreme tranceaddict
Registered: Jul 2001
Location: Slovenia
quote:
Originally posted by X-Hale
Hes not trance but he wouldn't be out of place playing a longside trance djs
wasn't he resident @ passion, playing more with trance than prog djs?
i liked what he said about prog in mixmag and how was he dancing at bedrock party... lol...