quote: | Originally posted by 8Wonders
Apples and Oranges. Like I mentioned earlier, if you are going for the 'raw and dirty' feel like Liebing does, then do it through proper mixing and careful sound sculpting. Oliver's tracks, despite being raw, still sound well mixed and mastered, which unfortunately I cannot say for Mr. Digital Blonde's tracks.
The foundation is there, it's just not polished. |
olver liebing
i can completely see where your coming from and can respect your view. i was actually expecting to write similar comments after i first flicked through the album and even contemplated starting a whole new thread discussion the importance of production standards. when i'm browsing through recordstores looking for stuff to buy, crisp & powerful sounding stuff is paramount, i can usually rule out dodgy sounding stuff in about a second of listening to the respective samples.
the thing with this though, is that i saw it as less of a collection of club tracks, more as an artistic product, and with the amazing work that's gone into the atmosphere in the tracks, i was able to forget about the dodgy production standards. long story short if these were all individual tracks i'd probably skip by most of them, with the possible exception of only you & concerto. just in the context of the album i think it works, in some cases like ritual it even benefits it
chicane's first album is similar in that respect, even tho it's older. but still the production sounds incredibly dated now, but it still works cos of the atmospheric journey the album takes you on
|