|
| quote: | Originally posted by DigiNut
Most "supernatural" phenomena (ESP, exorcisms, Ouija boards, dowsing, poltergeists, magnetic bracelets, etc.) really are a load of crap because there are rational explanations (observer-expectancy and subject-expectancy effects, confirmation bias, ideomotor response, cold reading, hallucinations, placebo effect, or just outright fakery) that the proponents of said phenomena simply refuse to believe or acknowledge. In other words, these beliefs CAN be tested but the believers simply refuse to subject them to any scientific scrutiny.
Most theists, with the notable exception of the "creation science" crowd, explicitly acknowledge that their beliefs are not scientific and cannot be tested. Thus, there is really no argument.
It's just unfortunate that certain people (Yohan and Elyot, I'm looking at you) have to poison the debate by introducing tangential elements like exorcisms and Friday the 13th that are sorta kinda similar but actually not really. |
Well, I thought my example of Friday the 13th was extremely relevant. I'm not just trying to trash religion for its attempt to explain supernatural events; I'm also trashing it for causing irrational and damaging behaviour among the general public. I claimed that the damage that would be caused by an irrational and unfounded fear of Friday the 13th would be unacceptable, yet the damage caused by the religious condemnation of practices like homosexuality and birth control are even worse.
I don't see how that is irrelevant at all. It is the primary reason WHY I detest religion. People running around and believing in ghosts and a mystical fairy man in the sky... well, if it was just that, there wouldn't be a problem. But ACTING based on this "faith" and making decisions based upon it (like hating your homosexual neighbours because your magic book says that homosexuality is an abomination, or refusing to use a condom because your pointy-hatted religious leader tells you not to)... well, that is incredibly damaging to society. I don't feel like I should tolerate that just because you think your magic book is "holy".
I'm not so much interested in discussing whether or not one is justified in believing something that they can't explain. The question is about whether taking action based on such a belief is justified.
___________________
I am nobody. Nobody is perfect. Therefore I am perfect.
|