Become a part of the TranceAddict community!Frequently Asked Questions - Please read this if you haven'tSearch the forums
TranceAddict Forums > Main Forums > Chill Out Room > How do you British/Irish TAs feel about the IRA
Pages (4): « 1 2 [3] 4 »   Last Thread   Next Thread
Share
Author
Thread    Post A Reply
Disco_Gibson
Supreme tranceaddict



Registered: Sep 2004
Location: Flutlichtville

quote:
Originally posted by tu_face
that for one is bullshit


bullshit? then prove me wrong.did u not see my post i said most of the time they went after military targets.here in northern ireland where i live,not where you live,they were forever shooting cops,soldiers,bombing patrols,army stations etc etc.of course they did the atrocities,which i mentioned and did not agree with but they occurred the odd time compared to the amount of military targets they went after.the IRA killed more/targeted more members of the security forces than they did innocents.fact.

stay out of the argument if you dont know what your talkin about.

Old Post Dec-06-2004 22:52  Ireland
Click Here to See the Profile for Disco_Gibson Click here to Send Disco_Gibson a Private Message Add Disco_Gibson to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
donegalredneck
Senior tranceaddict



Registered: Apr 2001
Location: Bun Cranncha, Inis Eoghain, Tír Chonaill, Éire

That's what sets them as freedom fighters apart from loyalist terrorists (concentrating on British military targets, personnel, etc. rather than targetting and murdering people because of their religion).

To overdose006, in return for the provos surrendering weapons some British instalations will be closed and other operations scaled down. At present there are more British military personnel in Ireland than there is in Iraq (c.12,000).
The sitaution with the loyalists differs from the situation of Republicans. Go back a few decades to the end of the 60s when it started. Republicans joined the one movement (albeit different wings of the movement; Óglaigh na hÉireann, Sinn Féin, Na Fianna Éireann, etc.) Republicans of all intellectual abilities joined the one movement. On the unionist side the more intellegent members of the community joined political parties and middle-class unionists who wanted to have a role in a physical force sense joined the police or the British army (this obviously wasn't an option on principle for nationalists, well-educated or not). Working class loyalists with little intellect or education tended to be drawn to loyalist terrorist gangs such as the UDA and UVF instead of the Brit Army, police, etc. The result was that when the ceasefires were called loyalism was without an element of people who could lead it politically (since those who had the ability to lead the loyalists politically were involved in the UUP and DUP). The political process went on without them, and since they or their political wings have no part in the process they're not really obliged to decommission, since they wouldn't gain politically from it. The political wing of the provisionals are continually held back because the military wing of the movement have weapons, and since they're seen as two sides of the same coin the military must be gotten rid of before the political can become absorbed into the establishment. Hence all the fuss about PIRA decomissioning and none about UDA, UVF, Red Hand Commando, etc.


___________________
"Níl saoirse gan saoirse lucht oibre."

Old Post Dec-07-2004 00:25  Ireland
Click Here to See the Profile for donegalredneck Click here to Send donegalredneck a Private Message Add donegalredneck to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
smokeape
Lowland Trance Addict



Registered: Jul 2003
Location: Heart of Dixie

Who instigated this thread? A damn Yankee. Why worry about the Brits and Irish? We still ain't forgot about the war over here!



Leave them folks be.


[[[smoke]]]

Old Post Dec-07-2004 00:37 
Click Here to See the Profile for smokeape Click here to Send smokeape a Private Message Add smokeape to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
UglyDave
i ran a marathon : )



Registered: Jan 2003
Location: Buncrana, Éire

quote:
Originally posted by smokeape
We still ain't forgot about the war over here!

[[[smoke]]]



what war?

Old Post Dec-07-2004 10:43  Ireland
Click Here to See the Profile for UglyDave Click here to Send UglyDave a Private Message Visit UglyDave's homepage! Add UglyDave to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
rooibos
Suspended User



Registered: Nov 2004
Location: 06/TDT/03:13 Real Reg Date: 2002

Da wizzar on da streets, mang. Cock yo Mac 11'z n shit.


___________________

Aer yuo drameign?

Old Post Dec-07-2004 11:05  Canada
Click Here to See the Profile for rooibos Click here to Send rooibos a Private Message Add rooibos to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
tu_face
No Known Cure...



Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Sheffield, UK

quote:
Originally posted by Disco_Gibson
bullshit? then prove me wrong.did u not see my post i said most of the time they went after military targets.here in northern ireland where i live,not where you live,they were forever shooting cops,soldiers,bombing patrols,army stations etc etc.of course they did the atrocities,which i mentioned and did not agree with but they occurred the odd time compared to the amount of military targets they went after.the IRA killed more/targeted more members of the security forces than they did innocents.fact.

stay out of the argument if you dont know what your talkin about.


as i said, i don't want to get into this argument, but the IRA were just as bad as the UVF for killing innocent people.

there are no innocent parties in this argument, except innocent victims.


___________________
MUGGETS

Old Post Dec-07-2004 15:32 
Click Here to See the Profile for tu_face Click here to Send tu_face a Private Message Add tu_face to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
donegalredneck
Senior tranceaddict



Registered: Apr 2001
Location: Bun Cranncha, Inis Eoghain, Tír Chonaill, Éire

You don't want to get into the argument because you can't defend your unfounded claims. I can't see how you can claim that, with the exception of a small number of cases, members of the IRA set out to intentionally kill civilians, and compare their actions to those of people who most definately did go out and intentionally kill civilians for the most part.
Of course the IRA killed innocent victims, they generally didn't have innocent targets however.


___________________
"Níl saoirse gan saoirse lucht oibre."

Old Post Dec-07-2004 18:20  Ireland
Click Here to See the Profile for donegalredneck Click here to Send donegalredneck a Private Message Add donegalredneck to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
tu_face
No Known Cure...



Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Sheffield, UK

it was very rare to find a military target in any of the IRA bombings on the UK mainland, but i suppose these don't count? both sides were just as guilty of being complete ****s, in all areas of this conflict.



the reason i don't want to get in to this argument is because its all been done before and there is no need to do it again, this is the reason i am proud of the processes that are going through at the moment; because the people that matter can put differences behind them and concentrate on what is happening now.

my point was not to defend/provoke either side, just to state that it is bullshit that 80% of the IRA's targets were military.


___________________
MUGGETS

Old Post Dec-07-2004 22:31 
Click Here to See the Profile for tu_face Click here to Send tu_face a Private Message Add tu_face to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
CynepMeH
Let me wash your Apple!



Registered: Oct 2002
Location: Miles away from ordinary...
Dunno

Insn't Ira a Jewish accountant?


___________________
Proud member of the "Filthy Zionist" coalition

Old Post Dec-07-2004 23:03 
Click Here to See the Profile for CynepMeH Click here to Send CynepMeH a Private Message Add CynepMeH to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
UglyDave
i ran a marathon : )



Registered: Jan 2003
Location: Buncrana, Éire

quote:
Originally posted by tu_face
both sides were just as guilty of being complete ****s, in all areas of this conflict.


you's started it!


Old Post Dec-08-2004 11:54  Ireland
Click Here to See the Profile for UglyDave Click here to Send UglyDave a Private Message Visit UglyDave's homepage! Add UglyDave to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
Disco_Gibson
Supreme tranceaddict



Registered: Sep 2004
Location: Flutlichtville

quote:
Originally posted by tu_face
my point was not to defend/provoke either side, just to state that it is bullshit that 80% of the IRA's targets were military.


Lets just see what the atrocities were that took place in England...

taken from news.bbc.co.uk

1971 - Post office tower bomb (0 killed,0 injured)
----------------
1972
----------------
1973 - Central London bomb (0 killed)
-----------------
1974 - Parliament bomb (0 killed)
1974 - Tower of London bomb (1 killed)
1974 - Guilford bomb (4 killed)
1974 - London club bomb (0 killed)
1974 - Birmingham bomb (19 killed)
-----------------
1975 - London Hilton bomb (2 killed)
-----------------
1976 - West end bomb (0 killed)
-----------------
1983 - Harrods bomb (6 killed)
-----------------
1984 - Brighton bomb (2 killed)
-----------------
1990 - Stock Exchange bomb (0 killed)
-----------------
1992 - Baltic exchange bomb (3 killed)
-----------------
1992 - Manchester bomb (0 killed)
-----------------
1993 - Warrington bomb (1 killed)
-------------------
1993 - City of London bomb (1 killed)
-------------------
1996 - Docklands bomb (1 killed)
1996 - Manchester bomb (0 killed)
-------------------
2001 - Ealing bomb (0 killed) <---- Not valid as this was not the PIRA BUT THE RIRA.different organisation.



18 bombs over 40 years
Number killed by these bombs - 40

"...Of the 1778 people murdered by the IRA, 642 (36%) were civilians" http://www.billyarmstrong.co.uk/the...as_to_blame.htm

"The IRA have also been responsible for the murder of 273 police officers (Protestant and Roman Catholic) and 638 soldiers (Protestant and Roman Catholic)http://www.billyarmstrong.co.uk/the...s_to_blame.htm,"


Number of security forces members killed = 273 + 638 = 911
Number of English civillians killed = 40 (less than 2% of overall killed)

so if 36% of the people killed by the IRA were civilians that means that 64% of the pople killed by the IRA were miliary targets,members of the security forces,agents,members of government etc etc

so i was 16% off a right answer.not bad.

overall,the IRA went for more valid targets than just innocent people.case closed.

Old Post Dec-08-2004 21:19  Ireland
Click Here to See the Profile for Disco_Gibson Click here to Send Disco_Gibson a Private Message Add Disco_Gibson to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message
tu_face
No Known Cure...



Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Sheffield, UK

quote:
Originally posted by Disco_Gibson
Lets just see what the atrocities were that took place in England...

taken from news.bbc.co.uk

1971 - Post office tower bomb (0 killed,0 injured)
----------------
1972
----------------
1973 - Central London bomb (0 killed)
-----------------
1974 - Parliament bomb (0 killed)
1974 - Tower of London bomb (1 killed)
1974 - Guilford bomb (4 killed)
1974 - London club bomb (0 killed)
1974 - Birmingham bomb (19 killed)
-----------------
1975 - London Hilton bomb (2 killed)
-----------------
1976 - West end bomb (0 killed)
-----------------
1983 - Harrods bomb (6 killed)
-----------------
1984 - Brighton bomb (2 killed)
-----------------
1990 - Stock Exchange bomb (0 killed)
-----------------
1992 - Baltic exchange bomb (3 killed)
-----------------
1992 - Manchester bomb (0 killed)
-----------------
1993 - Warrington bomb (1 killed)
-------------------
1993 - City of London bomb (1 killed)
-------------------
1996 - Docklands bomb (1 killed)
1996 - Manchester bomb (0 killed)
-------------------
2001 - Ealing bomb (0 killed) <---- Not valid as this was not the PIRA BUT THE RIRA.different organisation.



18 bombs over 40 years
Number killed by these bombs - 40

"...Of the 1778 people murdered by the IRA, 642 (36%) were civilians" http://www.billyarmstrong.co.uk/the...as_to_blame.htm

"The IRA have also been responsible for the murder of 273 police officers (Protestant and Roman Catholic) and 638 soldiers (Protestant and Roman Catholic)http://www.billyarmstrong.co.uk/the...s_to_blame.htm,"


Number of security forces members killed = 273 + 638 = 911
Number of English civillians killed = 40 (less than 2% of overall killed)

so if 36% of the people killed by the IRA were civilians that means that 64% of the pople killed by the IRA were miliary targets,members of the security forces,agents,members of government etc etc

so i was 16% off a right answer.not bad.

overall,the IRA went for more valid targets than just innocent people.case closed.


i think 64% to 80% is a big difference in terms of people killed.


___________________
MUGGETS

Old Post Dec-08-2004 21:44 
Click Here to See the Profile for tu_face Click here to Send tu_face a Private Message Add tu_face to your buddy list Report this Post Reply w/Quote Edit/Delete Message

TranceAddict Forums > Main Forums > Chill Out Room > How do you British/Irish TAs feel about the IRA
Post New Thread    Post A Reply

Pages (4): « 1 2 [3] 4 »  
Last Thread   Next Thread
Click here to listen to the sample!Pause playbackCarl Cox - 2001.02.03 [08] [2004] [0]

Click here to listen to the sample!Pause playbackJ K Walker vs. Marcos - "Night Finder" (Marcos Mix) [2004]

Show Printable Version | Subscribe to this Thread
Forum Jump:

All times are GMT. The time now is 01:26.

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
[IMG] code is ON
 
Search this Thread:

 
Contact Us - return to tranceaddict

Powered by: Trance Music & vBulletin Forums
Copyright ©2000-2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Privacy Statement / DMCA
Support TA!