 |
|
|
|
 |
shaolin_Z
Hei Hu Quan

Registered: Nov 2004
Location: Austin, Texas, USA: TXTA #102
|
|
|
| quote: | Originally posted by DrUg_Tit0
So anyway, what's the exact difference between sunni and shia muslims? Do they have any different scriptures, or do they just use the same scriptures but are organized differently, like catholic and orthodox church? |
Well, all "sects of Islam" share the exact same scripture (i.e. The Quran). There's only one version of the Quran which all Muslims are supposed to follow. The divide is more of a political nature. It basically started with the question as to who should be Prophet Muhammad's successor. Muhammad, who died of some illness in a 2 week span, on his death bed, chose Ali (who was his cousin and son-in-law, also one of the first people ot except Islam, also one of the Prophets closest companions) to be his successor.
Umar, who was a powerful and prominent tribe leader before he accepted Islam and not particularly popular amongst the people even after he did, said that the Prophet was sick, old, and not in a mental state to be taken seriously. So he basically paid no heed to the Prophets wishes and will. Once the Prophet passed away, Umar became histerical and in denial of the fact that he was dead. This mourning, wheather genuine or superficial, convineintly continued until Abu Bakar, arrived from some trip/mission or the other back in Madina. Abu Bakr, another prominet figure but with a little more popularity amongst the people, convinced the majority that he should be the first caliph and is the rightful successor to the Prophet. Now, Abu Bakar and Umar were buddies and Umar willingly accepted him as the new leader, after which he became the second caliph.
Ali, refused to acknowledge this at first. Abu Bakr who was pissed that Ali wasn't submitting to his leadership, asked Umar to coerce him into it. Umar arrived at Ali's house. He demanded that Ali open the door and come out. Ali, who was with his wife Fatima (who was also the Prophets daughter), said he couldn't at the moment. Fatima, who was pregnant with Ali child (making the kid the Prophets grandchild), said that she was in there with him and to give them their privacy. Umar simply broke in, mortally wounding Fatima in the process, who was near the door at the time. There was a miscarriage and she also died from this injury.
Now many Muslims know as "Shi'at Ali" or something which basically means "the party of Ali" or something to that effect, refused to give up their alligence to Ali and recongized only him as the true successor of Muhammad (who, as I said earlier, Muhammad has chosen himself).
These Muslims were also coered and persecuted, and infact, there was a even a civil war at one point. Ali eventually decided to compromise, in order to keep Muslims united and detering a further divide.
Fast forward a generation. Another major event that occured was when the Prophets grandson Hussain and many of his friends and family were persecuted and eventually slaughtered by the "caliph" Yazid. Sunni however still recognize Yazid as a legitimate Caliph and insist that his generals fucked up on the battle field, which is rubbish. The terms Shia and Sunni didn't come into use until after this event. Sunnis also consider Abu Bakar and Umar to be legitimate caliphs and successors of the Prothet, where as Shias do not.
Shia have basically been pursecuted through out history, and depending on messed up the power structure they lived in was, were even killed and massacred.
So, to sum up, Sunnis have mostly been the passive majority submitting to the power structure, and the Shia are the ones that get screwed all the time.
The Wahabis, another group that splintered off from Sunnis, are extremely fanatical and violent nuts. They control Saudi Arabia. The taliban were wahabis, and they went to Shia villages and literally massacred them using methods similar to the Nazis. Pretty sick stuff . The even desecrated the grave and burrial site of Imam Hussein (the Prophets grandson ). The extremely fanatical and militant distortion of Islam usually find its roots in/ties to the Wahabism. Which is another reason why I am somewhat pissed at the cozy relation between Saudi Arabia and the US. The Saudis are usually the ones funding all these different terrorist groups.
My dad is Shia and my mom Sunni. I myself do not identify with eigther group. I'm simply Muslim. And I'm pretty disgusted by and sick of this ridiculous internal conflict is still going on, and the spread of fanatical views in the "old world" (i.e. Middle East/South-east Asia). And it's only getting worse and more fanatical with aggressive US policy . The "Imams" & "Mullahs" over there now a days are mostly illiterate bufoons holding on to their power by dividing the people and causing internal conflict. It gotton so bad in the past few years that people opposing sets have actually gone into Shia/Sunni mosques and opened fire on people while they were praying! A pretty sad state of affairs.
Anyways, I hope that helped.
___________________
"The Greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge." -Stephen Hawking
"First they came for the communists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a communist;
Then they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a socialist;
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist;
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— because I was not a Jew;
Then they came for me— and there was no one left to speak out for me." -Martin Niemöller
Last edited by shaolin_Z on Mar-18-2006 at 23:09
|
|
Mar-18-2006 22:41
|
|
|
 |
 |
Fir3start3r
Armin Acolyte

Registered: Oct 2001
Location: Toronto, ON, Canada
|
|
|
| quote: | Originally posted by shaolin_Z
Well, all "sects of Islam" share the exact same scripture (i.e. The Quran). There's only one version of the Quran which all Muslims are supposed to follow. The divide is more of a political nature. It basically started with the question as to who should be Prophet Muhammad's successor. Muhammad, who died of some illness in a 2 week span, on his death bed, chose Ali (who was his cousin and son-in-law, also one of the first people ot except Islam, also one of the Prophets closest companions) to be his successor.
Umar, who was a powerful and prominent tribe leader before he accepted Islam and not particularly popular amongst the people even after he did, said that the Prophet was sick, old, and not in a mental state to be taken seriously. So he basically paid no heed to the Prophets wishes and will. Once the Prophet passed away, Umar became histerical and in denial of the fact that he was dead. This mourning, genuine or superficial, convineintly continued until Abu Bakar, arrived from some trip/mission or the other back to Madina. Abu Bakr, another prominet figure but with a little more popularity amongst the people, convinced the majority that he should be the first caliph and is the rightful successor to the Prophet. Now, Abu Bakar and Umar were buddies and Umar willingly accepted him as the new leader, after which he became the second caliph.
Ali, refused to acknowledge this at first. Abu Bakr who was pissed that Ali wasn't submitting to his leadership, asked Umar to coerce him into it. Umar arrived at Ali's house. He demanded that Ali open the door and come out. Ali, who was with his wife Fatima (who was also the Prophets daughter), said he couldn't at the moment. Fatima, who was pregnant with Ali child (making the kid the Prophets grandchild), said that she was in there with him and to give them their privacy. Umar simply broke in, mortally wounding Fatima in the process, who was near the door at the time. There was a miscarriage and she also died from this injury.
Now many Muslims know as "Shi'at Ali" or something which basically means "the party of Ali" or something to that effect, refused to give up their alligence to Ali and recongized only him as the true successor of Muhammad (who, as I said earlier, Muhammad has chosen himself).
These Muslims were also coered and persecuted, and infact, there was a even a civil war at one point. Ali eventually decided to compromise, in order to keep Muslims united and detering a further divide.
Fast forward a generation. Another major event that occured was when the Prophets grandson Hussain and many of his friends and family were persecuted and eventually slaughtered by the "caliph" Yazid. Sunni however still recognize Yazid as a legitimate Caliph and insist that his generals fucked up on the battle field, which is rubbish. The terms Shia and Sunni didn't come into use after this event. Sunnis also consider Abu Bakar and Umar to be legitimate caliphs and successors of the Prothet, where as Shias do not.
Shia have basically been pursecuted through out history, and depending on messed up the power structure they lived in was, were even killed and massacred.
So, to sum up, Sunnis have mostly been the passive majority submitting to the power structure, and the Shia are the ones that get screwed all the time.
The Wahabis, another group that splintered off from Sunnis, are extremely fanatical and violent nuts. They control Saudi Arabia. The taliban were wahabis, and they went to Shia villages and literally massacred them using methods similar to the Nazis. Pretty sick stuff . The even desecrated the grave and burrial site of Imam Hussein (the Prophets grandson ). The extremely fanatical and militant distortion of Islam usually find its roots in/ties to the Wahabism. Which is another reason why I am somewhat pissed at the cozy relation between Saudi Arabia and the US. The Saudis are usually the ones funding all these different terrorist groups.
My dad is Shia and my mom Sunni. I myself do not identify with eigther group. I'm simply Muslim. And I'm pretty disgusted by and sick of this ridiculous internal conflict is still going on, and the spread of fanatical views in the "old world" (i.e. Middle East/South-east Asia). And it's only getting worse and more fanatical with aggressive US policy . The "Imams" & "Mullahs" over there now a days are mostly illiterate bufoons holding on to their power by dividing the people and causing internal conflict. It gotton so bad in the past few years that people opposing sets have actually gone into Shia/Sunni mosques and opened fire on people while they were praying! A pretty sad state of affairs.
Anyways, I hope that helped. |
Thanks for the primer and your candor; interesting.
I hope, for the sake of the Muslim religion, that things do eventually work out...
___________________
"...End? No, the journey doesn't end here. Death is just another path...one that we all must take.
The grey rain-curtain of this world rolls back, and all change to silver glass...and then you see it...
...white shores...and beyond...the far green country under a swift sunrise."
|
|
Mar-18-2006 22:52
|
|
|
 |
 |
shaolin_Z
Hei Hu Quan

Registered: Nov 2004
Location: Austin, Texas, USA: TXTA #102
|
|
|
| quote: | Originally posted by Fir3start3r
Thanks for the primer and your candor; interesting. |
You're welcome .
| quote: | Originally posted by Fir3start3r
I hope, for the sake of the Muslim religion, that things do eventually work out... |
Yeah, I hope so too. 
___________________
"The Greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge." -Stephen Hawking
"First they came for the communists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a communist;
Then they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a socialist;
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist;
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— because I was not a Jew;
Then they came for me— and there was no one left to speak out for me." -Martin Niemöller
|
|
Mar-18-2006 23:18
|
|
|
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
digitul punk
Supreme tranceaddict

Registered: Aug 2004
Location: Da Krib Foool! KD 0079
|
|
|
| quote: | Originally posted by shaolin_Z
Well, all "sects of Islam" share the exact same scripture (i.e. The Quran). There's only one version of the Quran which all Muslims are supposed to follow. The divide is more of a political nature. It basically started with the question as to who should be Prophet Muhammad's successor. Muhammad, who died of some illness in a 2 week span, on his death bed, chose Ali (who was his cousin and son-in-law, also one of the first people ot except Islam, also one of the Prophets closest companions) to be his successor.
Umar, who was a powerful and prominent tribe leader before he accepted Islam and not particularly popular amongst the people even after he did, said that the Prophet was sick, old, and not in a mental state to be taken seriously. So he basically paid no heed to the Prophets wishes and will. Once the Prophet passed away, Umar became histerical and in denial of the fact that he was dead. This mourning, wheather genuine or superficial, convineintly continued until Abu Bakar, arrived from some trip/mission or the other back in Madina. Abu Bakr, another prominet figure but with a little more popularity amongst the people, convinced the majority that he should be the first caliph and is the rightful successor to the Prophet. Now, Abu Bakar and Umar were buddies and Umar willingly accepted him as the new leader, after which he became the second caliph.
Ali, refused to acknowledge this at first. Abu Bakr who was pissed that Ali wasn't submitting to his leadership, asked Umar to coerce him into it. Umar arrived at Ali's house. He demanded that Ali open the door and come out. Ali, who was with his wife Fatima (who was also the Prophets daughter), said he couldn't at the moment. Fatima, who was pregnant with Ali child (making the kid the Prophets grandchild), said that she was in there with him and to give them their privacy. Umar simply broke in, mortally wounding Fatima in the process, who was near the door at the time. There was a miscarriage and she also died from this injury.
Now many Muslims know as "Shi'at Ali" or something which basically means "the party of Ali" or something to that effect, refused to give up their alligence to Ali and recongized only him as the true successor of Muhammad (who, as I said earlier, Muhammad has chosen himself).
These Muslims were also coered and persecuted, and infact, there was a even a civil war at one point. Ali eventually decided to compromise, in order to keep Muslims united and detering a further divide.
Fast forward a generation. Another major event that occured was when the Prophets grandson Hussain and many of his friends and family were persecuted and eventually slaughtered by the "caliph" Yazid. Sunni however still recognize Yazid as a legitimate Caliph and insist that his generals fucked up on the battle field, which is rubbish. The terms Shia and Sunni didn't come into use until after this event. Sunnis also consider Abu Bakar and Umar to be legitimate caliphs and successors of the Prothet, where as Shias do not.
Shia have basically been pursecuted through out history, and depending on messed up the power structure they lived in was, were even killed and massacred.
So, to sum up, Sunnis have mostly been the passive majority submitting to the power structure, and the Shia are the ones that get screwed all the time.
The Wahabis, another group that splintered off from Sunnis, are extremely fanatical and violent nuts. They control Saudi Arabia. The taliban were wahabis, and they went to Shia villages and literally massacred them using methods similar to the Nazis. Pretty sick stuff . The even desecrated the grave and burrial site of Imam Hussein (the Prophets grandson ). The extremely fanatical and militant distortion of Islam usually find its roots in/ties to the Wahabism. Which is another reason why I am somewhat pissed at the cozy relation between Saudi Arabia and the US. The Saudis are usually the ones funding all these different terrorist groups.
My dad is Shia and my mom Sunni. I myself do not identify with eigther group. I'm simply Muslim. And I'm pretty disgusted by and sick of this ridiculous internal conflict is still going on, and the spread of fanatical views in the "old world" (i.e. Middle East/South-east Asia). And it's only getting worse and more fanatical with aggressive US policy . The "Imams" & "Mullahs" over there now a days are mostly illiterate bufoons holding on to their power by dividing the people and causing internal conflict. It gotton so bad in the past few years that people opposing sets have actually gone into Shia/Sunni mosques and opened fire on people while they were praying! A pretty sad state of affairs.
Anyways, I hope that helped. |
Best fuckin post ever.. Great. 
___________________
Music for your Mind
|
|
Mar-19-2006 08:05
|
|
|
 |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 11:11.
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|
Contact Us - return to tranceaddict
Powered by: Trance Music & vBulletin Forums
Copyright ©2000-2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Privacy Statement / DMCA
|