|
...::: Disclaimer - If anything I say below doesnt make sense, don't blame me, blame THC :::...
| quote: | Originally posted by CONNERMAN2000
I see...so what you are saying is that suburbs should NOT become more than a bedroom community? |
not at all
| quote: |
Is it really that vital to not detract from a metropolitan area's urban core? To me, I think having suburbs become more than bedroom communities would only benefit the entire metropolis as a whole. Think of LA. Los Angeles itself is practically nothing when you look at the whole scheme of things when you see LA. Its all Hollywood (a suburb), Long Beach (a suburb), and along with all the other coastal communities (all suburbs). Los Angeles pretty much just has a downtown skyline, and I guess we'll thrown in Lakers stadium, and thats pretty much it. What im getting at is, wouldnt improving the suburbs improve the city core? Although many consider this to be trivial bullshit, im pretty fuckin interested to hear what you have to say.
|
is it vital to not detract? yes and no
I'm by no means saying that suburbs developing and becoming more than bedroom communities is a cardinal sin, but it can be dangerous if done incorrectly.
Most suburbs I know have their own downtowns. At one point they were cities too and as milwaukee grew, those towns would fill in. they're all their each little city. I think cool little downtowns with corner shops and a some retail is fine. They are their own self-economized (does that word work? cities. I have no problem with malls either. They shouldnt be located downtown in my opinion anyway. Many downtowns dont have enough street-level retail to compete with a mall. A malls duty, like a casino (also bad downtown) are to keep people indoors and spending money. this starves the other street retail that cant provide the sheltered, easy paced environment that a mall can. In the case of Chicago, which has multiple malls and indoor shopping centers, it has the mag mile and many other great retail options and has MUCH higher pedestrian activity than most cities. Due to the presence of so many people, malls are fine in downtowns.
In the case of LA, yes it does thrive from its suburbs. Christ, LA,s metro has almost 20 million people in it and it continues to spread. People move there for various reasons, but the suburbs such as hollywood creat more appeal.
I think improving suburbs do improve the cities. look at any major mid-size or large-sized cities in the US. Not ONE is self-sufficient. You will never find a city over 150,000 in the US without a suburb. Americans are obsessed with suburban living. Withouth the suburbs, the cities would not survive at their current magnitude. New York has close to 22,000,000 people in its metro area. These are huge cities and they got that way because of the suburbs.
| quote: | | O and do you think Schaumburg has really detracted from Chicago? Malls arent really a new thing, and thats pretty much all Schaumburg has (The Streets of Woodfield, im sure you know it). Where I live (Naperville), we have the Fox Valley Mall, which serves East Aurora, West Naperville, Winfield, Warrenville, and a few other suburbs. Does having it mean Naperville is detracting from Chicago? |
I dont think Schaumburg is detracting from Chicago in a way that should cause concern. As I said, Chicago is a HUGE city. there are over 3 million people in the city and nearly 12 in the MSA. Chicago is a world city, a world commerce center and has its name everywhere that matters.Schaumburg detracts but not at any noticable rate. go to downtown chicago any night and i gaurantee the traffic is heavy and there'll be people everywhere. Scaumburg is a terribly planned and terribly overdone suburb. Its nothing but big box retailers and shitty sprawl. To most people that doesnt matter shit but I guess to a few people it does.
Does Schaumburg even have sidewalks?
not that i've seen.
And no naperville isnt detracting noticably either. But my cousin and his wife and their son live there and they enjoy it. 
how close are you to o'hare btw? is the airnoise shitty or dont you notice it much? with over 75,000,000 passengers a year I'd think it would be unbearable.
|