Agree with the Fraser no trade.

I would offer: Reid + Rocca + Dick

Reid was pick 8 shows promise & is a key forward.

Rocca can just go, they need another forward.

Dick promising young aborigine from WA who will probably get home sick anyway & he shows some promise.

quote:

Originally posted by Teflon_Teapot if judd nominates collingwood i hope west coast play hard ball and f#ck collingwood over. and if they dont get a good enough deal they have the balls to do what port adelaide did with nick stevens and send judd to the pre-season draft.

If Judd nominates only the Pies, WCE would be stupid to send him into the PSD and get nothing. Nick Stevens, as much as Carlton Supporters think otherwise... was never highly rated. He's known as a soft receiver. Didak is a highly skilled match winner... and Port knew that.

quote:

this whole judd situation is a load of crap imo. the player is not bigger than the club and should not be interviewing clubs and telling them yes or no. it should be up to west coast to do a trade deal that compensates them properly, not the player telling the club where he wants to be traded to. fine judd wants to come back to victoria but he should not be able to pick the club he wants to go to and force his old club to do a deal with them.

While I believe hes a touch overrated, I really dont see anything wrong with the way he has gone about it. He knows what his value is, he knows other clubs are after him - that pretty much gives him the green light. As far as "compensating" WCE? Haha mangz - they should have traded him when he had a year left on his contract. Then they would be compensated. Ofcourse the player still has the right to agree / disagree to the trade.

quote:

if judd picks collingwood, i guarantee west coast will get screwed over. collingwood are f*3ks when it comes to trading away good players in return for gaining even better players just think about the nick stevens trade deal.

What has Nick Stevens done so far hes been at Carlton? Jack. Didak on the other hand is an All Australian. We would have been stupid to trade Didak for Stevens.

quote:

in all honesty this whole year has changed my opinion on chris judd. first the eye gouging incident (he was guilty) and secondly this trade situation. this whole process has made him sound like a spoilt little boy crying for his mother and nit-picking when it comes to which melbourne club he plays for.

Ive always been one to be pretty critical of Judd [ on field ], while others look at him like hes Michael Jordan. But as far as the whole trading thing - good on him for knowing he can do that. He should be selective.

HAVE A LOOK AT REALLY WHENT ON IN GEELONG!!!

over 9 minute video that my mate took and put together.... total gold!! TOTAL GOLD!!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rqwjgKRij_Q

enjoy and comment bout it lol! wish so many of yas were partying with us, extreeeemly unique!!! its never going to rock like that ever again!

i was in todays Geelong Advertiser newspaper too lol!! my mates and i ran into the reporter and were talkin to him for ages, so i was exstatic to find out he put us in!!!! BUT THE TOOL SPELT MY NAME WRONG!!! Bon Giovanni.... TOOL!!! 1 word damn it!!!

___________________
DJ Marak - "Hardcore for life, be different, be wild!"

http://www.geelongadvertiser.com.au.../7421_news.html

THERE IS THE WRITE UP!!! looks much better when its actually in the newspaper!! but check it out!!!!

___________________
DJ Marak - "Hardcore for life, be different, be wild!"

quote:

Originally posted by ONION What has Nick Stevens done so far hes been at Carlton? Jack. Didak on the other hand is an All Australian. We would have been stupid to trade Didak for Stevens. Ive always been one to be pretty critical of Judd [ on field ], while others look at him like hes Michael Jordan. But as far as the whole trading thing - good on him for knowing he can do that. He should be selective.

I'll cry if they ever trade Didak.





haha Marak you made the newspaper woooooooo

quote:

Originally posted by MiSSyM I'll cry if they ever trade Didak. haha Marak you made the newspaper woooooooo

if collingwood get him it will probably be didak and fraser in the trade I have heard!

___________________


Sign the petition!

quote:

Originally posted by springhit Reid was pick 8 shows promise & is a key forward. .

Lol ben reid showed absolutely fuck all this year, for a top 8 pick he showed absolutely nothing!!!

___________________
edit sig- image needs to be resized

The Last Sunday @ Ladida coming soon....

quote:

Originally posted by PauLie_C Lol ben reid showed absolutely fuck all this year, for a top 8 pick he showed absolutely nothing!!!

Sure your shit 'TIGERS' would luv him

Yeah, RICHMOND = 'LOOSERS'

Some of your Pathetic 'QUOTES'

quote:

Collingwood are useless and over rated!

quote:

Fuck off kirby! Richmond wont finish last

Rank16 Tigers Richmond 22 3 1 18 1958 2537 77 14

VIVA LA COLLINGWOOD.

NO way Didak better not be going anywhere

quote:

Originally posted by Dean Millson So the footy's about to start in a few weeks (yay) & i thought it could be interesting for everyone to put down some of their predictions pre-season for posterity. Premiers • Adelaide Top 8 at end of Home & Away Games • Adelaide • West Coast • Sydney • Western Bulldogs • Collingwood • Fremantle • St Kilda • Kangaroos Other... • I think half way through the season everyone will have forgotten about the 'contraversy' surrounding the stricter interpretation of the push in the back rule. • Kevin Sheedy's contract won't be renewed for 2008 • Bomber Thompson won't be coaching Geelong in 2008

Nice one on Sheedy. Pity you didnt even have Geelong in your top 8.

Judd chose Carlton.


Judd's new home

___________________
edit sig- image needs to be resized

The Last Sunday @ Ladida coming soon....