Originally posted by starglider
Nobody's criticizing your taste, he was simply pointing out that Beachbreeze is clearly not one of the "best vocal tracks of all time". Whether you, I or he likes the track is of little import.
Really now??? Scroll up and read his previous post. Seems pretty clear to me.
quote:
What's the deal with everyone getting upset? We're not allowed to criticize the taste of others? Sheesh, I didn't realize people would get so offended by dissent.
___________________
Feb-15-2004 23:10
keithos27
Perfecto For Clubs
Registered: Nov 2003
Location: Atlanta
these are some of the songs i feel have some really great lyrics... some of the actual songs are better than others, but all have great lyrics imo....
cass & slide - perception (vocal mix)
amoebaassassin - piledriver (grayed out mix)
motorcycle - as the rush comes
solarstone - speak in sympathy
chicane - no ordinary morning
conjure one feat. sinead o'connor - tears from the moon (tiesto remix)
ascension - someone
ascension - for a lifetime
solid sessions - janeiro (avb remix)
oceanlab feat. justine suissa - satellite (original mix)
michael woods - if u want me (antillas remix)
armin van buuren feat. justine suissa - burned with desire
slam feat. tyrone - lifetimes
way out west feat. trisha lee kelshall - mindcircus (gabriel & dresden club mix)
-keith
Feb-15-2004 23:15
Perfect_Cheezit
Machine Beat
Registered: Jul 2003
Location: MNTA #08
quote:
Originally posted by Dan1584 DOES EVERY FUCKING THREAD HAVE TO TURN INTO AN ARGUEMENT!!!!???? SHIT, I STARTED THIS THREAD AND NOW I'M LEAVING IT...STOP ARGUING MUSIC IS SUPPOSED TO BRING PEOPLE TOGETHER, NOT TEAR THEM APART. PEOPLE HAVE DIFFERENT TASTES IN SONGS SO STOP CRITISIZING THEIR CHOICES TOO!!! FUCKING REDICULOUS!
sorry, you have to realize this is TA and people will ruin your threads whether they realize it or not
Feb-15-2004 23:18
Cobalt
Trance Isn't Trance
Registered: Apr 2002
Location: Vancouver, BC
quote:
Originally posted by vtec junkie
Really now??? Scroll up and read his previous post. Seems pretty clear to me.
If you want an accurate definition of what are the "best vocal tracks of all time," you're necessarily going to have to criticize others' selections. And "Best Vocal Tracks Of All Time" is the name of the thread. Not everyone is happy with a group concensus; it's inherently a compromise. If we just went around in a thread like this saying "yeah, I respect your selections, even though I don't agree," it would totally defeat the point of the thread. I've seen that happen a hundred times, and wanted to take a stand on it for once.
And besides, I wasn't being cocky or arrogant. Just because others won't push back without anything but swear words and insults doesn't make me arrogant. I'm expressing an opinion based on a long interest in electronic music, which you may or may not agree with. You have an equal right to do the same.
Feb-15-2004 23:20
vtec junkie
slave to the dark beat
Registered: Oct 2002
Location: In the zone, chief
quote:
Originally posted by Cobalt
If you want an accurate definition of what are the "best vocal tracks of all time," you're necessarily going to have to criticize others' selections. And "Best Vocal Tracks Of All Time" is the name of the thread. Not everyone is happy with a group concensus; it's inherently a compromise. If we just went around in a thread like this saying "yeah, I respect your selections, even though I don't agree," it would totally defeat the point of the thread. I've seen that happen a hundred times, and wanted to take a stand on it for once.
And besides, I wasn't being cocky or arrogant. Just because others won't push back without anything but swear words and insults doesn't make me arrogant. I'm expressing an opinion based on a long interest in electronic music, which you may or may not agree with. You have an equal right to do the same.
Whatever man, im not here to argue. Im sure you wernt trying to be cocky or arrogant but thats the way i took it. My bad.
___________________
Feb-15-2004 23:27
Cobalt
Trance Isn't Trance
Registered: Apr 2002
Location: Vancouver, BC
Also, I never said "oh my god, you suck! What a bunch of cheese!"
I criticized tracks and pointed out tracks I thought were not the "Best Vocal Tracks of All Time." Nowhere in this thread do I attack a person, only opinions. And attacking opinions is, indeed, the foundation of diverse and free thought.
Again, I don't get what all the upset is about. "Oh my lord, a person on an internet forum disagrees with me! The horror!"
Feb-15-2004 23:28
T_2199
life on mars ?
Registered: Dec 2001
Location: An der schönen Stadt am Main (Frankfurt)
quote:
Originally posted by Cobalt
No.
quote:
Originally posted by Cobalt
Yes.
Wow 1337 twat!?!? Who are you to tell people what is good and what is not good?! You are the forum god or what?? You define good and bad taste??
Music is a matter of taste.. There is no better or worse.. Just because you don´t like certain tracks doesn´t mean others don´t like too.. People like you make me sick!!
Post more vocal tracks or STFU lamer!!
I´ll post some more:
Chicane ft Bryan Adams - Dont Give Up (Agnelli and Nelson Mix)
Dumonde - Tomorrow [ Original Mix ]
T & Z -Sunglasses @ night
Madelyne - Beatiful Child <-- catchy
Kay Cee - Unsolved Mysteries [ Mr Sams Like Someone In Love Mix ]
sarah mclachlan - Sweet Surrender (DJ Tiesto Remix)
dj tiesto - close to you (magik muzik mix)
Wonderer - Vernon´s World (ATB mix)
dave matthews band - The Space Between Us (DJ Tiesto Mix)
Resistance D - You Were There (4 Strings remix)
DT8 Feat. Roxanne Wilde - Destination (Vocal Mix)
Oxygen Feat Andrea Britton - Am I On Your Mind (Lustral Mix)
Hiver & Hammer ft Javah - 5 Million Miles (A1 Mix)
Blackeight - The Silence (Original)
Frank T.R.A.X. - Nebuchan (Three Drives Remix)
___________________
Feb-15-2004 23:32
Cobalt
Trance Isn't Trance
Registered: Apr 2002
Location: Vancouver, BC
quote:
Originally posted by T_2199
Wow 1337 twat!?!? Who are you to tell people what is good and what is not good?! You are the forum god or what?? You define good and bad taste??
Music is a matter of taste.. There is no better or worse.. Just because you don´t like certain tracks doesn´t mean others don´t like too.. People like you make me sick!!
That's interesting how I never insulted anyone but you're insulting me. Kind of hypocritical if you ask me.
I can see you read none of my posts. I never laid claim to some sort of universal "bad" and "good."
Oh well. Another thread bites the dust and joins the ten thousand other "vocal track" threads.
Feb-15-2004 23:38
vtec junkie
slave to the dark beat
Registered: Oct 2002
Location: In the zone, chief
Armin Van Buuren - Burned With Desire
Barraka - Song To the Siren
BT - Somnambulist (best male vocals imo)
Dave Gahan - I need you
And that's only under the search "vocal* track" in the title.
Feb-15-2004 23:46
T_2199
life on mars ?
Registered: Dec 2001
Location: An der schönen Stadt am Main (Frankfurt)
quote:
Originally posted by Cobalt
That's interesting how I never insulted anyone but you're insulting me. Kind of hypocritical if you ask me.
I can see you read none of my posts. I never laid claim to some sort of universal "bad" and "good."
Oh well. Another thread bites the dust and joins the ten thousand other "vocal track" threads.
Why dont you just STFU or post some vocal tracks instead of destroying this thread with your argumentations.. You said to certain tracks NO which means for me they suck in your opinion.. Yes = they´re good that´s the way I interpret this..
Oh and I never said you insulted someone, did I ??
___________________
Feb-15-2004 23:46
Cobalt
Trance Isn't Trance
Registered: Apr 2002
Location: Vancouver, BC
quote:
Originally posted by T_2199
Why dont you just STFU or post some vocal tracks instead of destroying this thread with your argumentations..
Because there's lots of threads for that (here are some more), and it seemed the original poster didn't want another thread like that. Just look at the title.
quote:
Oh and I never said you insulted someone, did I ??
No, but you're more deserving of criticism than I am for attacking me personally. I never insulted a person.