|
| quote: | Originally posted by Nite-Mer
It's a close friend of mine, but maybe he came off wrong somehow or maybe Tijs was having a bad day, like I said. I doubt his girl was there, but you never know. And, you're right about the cd's vs. live sets. Tiesto - Live @ Energy 2000 used to be one of my favorites and I didn't hear the mistakes before I started mixing myself. It is fairly sloppy, so you're probably right. But I would think repetition for three/four more years would improve him more. Maybe it's an unfair expectation on my part. I know we're all human, but he seems more inconsistent than a lot of dj's with far less experience. I guess ear can't be taught though. It just has to be there. I just have a hypersensitive/critical ear myself, and if makes me hold dj's to a higher standard. That's why, for the most part, I prefer progressive dj's, that lock in their beats and are more consistent. As a trance and progressive dj, I don't think beat matching one is harder than the other. I think some of my comments get misinterpreted because I want it all. I'm not saying Tiesto is the worst dj out there, I just wish he were better. Maybe I just wish I never started spinning so I wouldn't hear all this stuff. Ignorance truly is bliss. I'm not saying you are ignorant either, I was before I started playing my own vinyl. |
But I do play my own vinyl, and I'm 100% aware of what you're criticizing.
However, Energy 2000 is an excellent example for proving my personal point. Everyone knows that this set is a masterpiece. But yes, the mixing is rather sloppy and subpar if we take the critical approach you're taking. However, MUSICALLY speaking, the whole set is genius, brilliant, out of this world. Not for the mixing, but for the raw energy and euphoria that Tiesto constructed throught the harmonic and rhythmic development of the set. The rollercoaster of intensity and emotion expressed by mixing contrasts and the general programming in the set are actually pretty complex and electrifying from a musical standpoint and I doubt that Armin, Oakey, let alone an amateur dj could do something like it. There's NO dj on this earth that could have accomplished what he did on that set.
I'll give credit where it's due. In beatmatching and general technique PvD is far superior to Armin anyway. Not to speak of track selection and track placement, where Armin fails greatly to impress me as a musician while PvD and Tiesto are the leading experts of their respective movements in Holland and Germany.
|