|
| quote: | Originally posted by Trancewave
ABT-
The only reason I brought up your original quote was because it was those comments that evoked a response from me in the first place, and it was how this whole situation got started, you asked in your previous post why I had such a problem with it, I thought I had explained it. |
Right. I heard you the first 2 times.
| quote: | | I just felt that the McVeigh reference WAS very ignorant and is an injustice to all kids with same sex parents of the world. | i've already admitted to the inappropriateness of this comment... care to make ANOTHER reference to it in your next post? And i hope by making my original comment, that all the "kids of same sex parents of the world" did not get hurt or lose any sleep... because i would not want to cause an injustice to all of them! 
| quote: | By making comments like that on your original post you should know that some people will be enraged with those comments.
You made your points and I had mine. now if you feel that by me calling some of the statements that you made 'ignorant' and feel that it is a personal attack on you, then maybe it is YOU who may not ready for a serious debate. It is not an attack, but the statement displayed ignorance and I'm entitled to respond. | Ok, allow me to repeat myself for the third time! I was not offended... i get called "stupid" all the time here on TA. What i am saying is that everytime i ever make a good arguement on here, people come back with insulting my intelligence as a "comeback." I was just bringing this to your attention, doesn't bother me, so drop this. 
| quote: | | The fact that you can't see how this can offend me unless I fall under the same conditions really tells me a lot about you. (did I just insult you? hope not, sweetcheeks) |
Well, since you are such an 'expert' on me now, why don't you share with the rest of us what you've learned about me? (thanks for complimenting my facial features, i'm rather proud of them!)
| quote: | | You are willing to bet money that psychological studies would prove that kids would go through emotional and mental abuse and mental trauma than kids with hetero parent....so you're telling me that you don't have any studies at hand to really back that up, and it's only your pre-percieved notion that it is more likely to happen. And that is the point I was always trying to make. |
well, i didn't work at a children's camp with same-sex-parent-kids... but i did take psychology for 2 years in college... i am by no means an "expert" in psychology, but i am not making psychological profiling statements totally unfounded... If you'd like, i could find some books for you to read on studies of children with emotional trauma. I had to read 2 books on this in one semester... *Remember the emotional trauma is not always from the parents, but also from others.... Its proven in countless studies, I just didn't feel like researching on the internet to find some for you. Again, this is not my crusade, i'm not trying to "turn" anyone, and you and i both know that neither of us is going to change each other's opinion.... My point of McVeigh suffering from Trauma was only to show what correlation my FIRST post was made from... Kids that receive more emotional trauma and abuse are more likely to lead an abnormal adulthood... its proven fact. This was proven about McVeigh's childhood in court, and i was showing this as an example of HOW an abused child can turn out. Again, apologize for the comparison, not called for..
| quote: | | You have to take every case on an individual basis. |
true, i never said this was incorrect.
| quote: | | I've worked with kids with same sex parents before in camp and they are quite "normal" and happy. Now, I'm not blind to the fact that there will be kids who would carry more of an emotional burden. It's individual cases. | of course the kids will "appear normal".... Haven't you seen the billboards about untreated depression? 90% of teen suicides are from untreated depression... why is it always untreated? Because kids are excellent at disguising their sadness. I've done it before in life, and i'm SURE you have too. My point here is only to show that your statement means NOTHING in the child's contentment in life... If you are not "blind" to the fact that some kids will carry more of an emotional burden, then you are agreeing with the statement i made several posts ago... 
| quote: | | This also alludes to your justification that gay adoption should therefore not be alowed, and that to me is pretty lame. To justify that kids would be less happy and have more of a burden based on your pre-percieved notion of what you THINK will happen to me is unjust. | My notions are more founded than yours. Not on an equality level but on psychological studies level. You also have to look at reality, TW. Not everyone in the world is so "open & nice" as you. Don't forget (and don't give the general public more credit than it deserves), that these kids would get harassed till there is no tomorrow. You know it, and i know it. Again, the stress & trauma part has been proven. You say "its not right". But where's the proof? How do we know that equality is the "right" thing here? Sometimes there are other factors you have to consider... like what would the kid want? If you ask ANY child in an adoption center whether they'd prefer opposite-sex parents or same-sex parents, i'd bet you a hundred bucks you and i both know what the answer would be.
| quote: | | I'm not going to lose sleep over it. We simply can't just brush things under a rug and say it's only an 'opinion' so why do people have problems with it. These issues should be brought to the forefront. | ... contradicting yourself again... you're not going to lose sleep over it, but you won't stand for it either... hmmm.... 
| quote: | I know your opinion is not hateful and neither is mine. And you know how I hate to bring another reference to McVeigh on this (sorry, couldn't help it) , what does the fact that McVeigh was emotionally abused by his parents have to do with anything? ??? | If you know my opinion is not hateful, and you know i'm not trying to "spread homophobia", then why were you so "outraged" at my original post? You said yourself that you couldn't stand to see someone write that.... hey, your words.. See above for the explanation on the McVeigh post...
| quote: | | But you've already stated earlier that kids with same sex parents would be more likely to be emotionally abused, and that is where I have a big beef with. You have nothing to substantiate your point on this, just what you 'think' will happen. | Again, i go by what i learned in college and what you see in society. You go by what "feels right". Your cause is definitely more admirable, but mine is more truthful. What i've said has been proven. You have beef with psychological studies? hmmm....
| quote: | | By me telling you I think you are truthful means that I know that you truly believe in your heart what you are saying that's all (I said that earlier). I'm NOT agreeing with you at the slightest , believe me we are on a WHOLE different wavelength. |
ok.
Cheers! 
-ABT-
___________________
Peace.
Last edited by ABTsportsline on Nov-11-2001 at 21:45
|