quote:

Originally posted by DarkAngel Requiem for a dream. Utter crap and did nothing to impress me. Nothing to get hyped up about whatsoever.

true dat! fuk that movie is more painful to watch then pulling out an ingrown hair!

as for me I would say Mission Impossible 1, 2 & 3!

and totally agree that brokeback vagina, I mean brokeback mountain was nothing spectacular at all! if anything it made me fall asleep! i guess that's what happens when a straight girl watches two men together

___________________
DALLAS STAR ™ °¤§£¤y°

Treat people as if they are what they ought to be and you may help them to become what they are capable of being.

I have to agree that with the exception of universally criticized films (can you say Uwe Bowl films), or the cult fan favourites, it really is personal preference.

For example, for those who say LOTR was overrated, I could not disagree more. Jackson did what people said could not be done (live action LOTR), and he didn't butcher the plot that badly in the process. There were some slow parts, but the sheer epic scale is unmatched and likely will be for a long time. The main battle scene in Return of the King was of such a scale and scope, that most other "medieval" movies with battle scenes pale in comparison. The extended versions of the movies are even better, adding even more background story to an already great set of films.

I would say the same for Castaway. I found that it really gave a great sense of the solitude that the character faced, and the insanity that would slowly grow on any person in that situation.

Gladiator
What women want
The Passion of the christ

War of the Worlds - was sooooo disappointed with this movie; stOOpid movie plot changes

Battlefield Earth - Happily have not seen it.

Starship Troopers 2: Hero of the Federation; LOVED the first one but when I rented this, I should have realized that this slag of a movie went straight to video for a reason...

Come on! Showgirls!! That's the movie hating spirit!!

How about Gigli; now THERE's scraping the bottom of the bottom...

___________________
"...End? No, the journey doesn't end here. Death is just another path...one that we all must take.
The grey rain-curtain of this world rolls back, and all change to silver glass...and then you see it...
...white shores...and beyond...the far green country under a swift sunrise."

quote:

Originally posted by Fir3start3r How about Gigli; now THERE's scraping the bottom of the bottom...

Oh yeah can't forget about that piece of Crap!

___________________
DALLAS STAR ™ °¤§£¤y°

Treat people as if they are what they ought to be and you may help them to become what they are capable of being.

quote:

Originally posted by Djsketchbag Napoleon Dynamite - too manny ppl say this movie is soooo funny when it's sooo not!

This is simply a movie that you either get or don't get. If you grew up in a certain time period you usually understand the stupidity of the film. Its a stupid funny but not something like a Hot Shots stupid funny... that leans more or less to something like the Scary Movies... I can't really explain more other than to say you must understand the underlying theme behind the film in order to laugh at the stupidity.

As far as something like the LoTR series.. like I said probably one of THE best book-to-movie adaptations.. but seriously those movies just seemed far too prolongued and very predictable... all 3 movies had the exact same buildup... likewise with the new Star Wars type movies.. where they try to have this extravagent storyline for 2hours to try and hype you up for a final battle which is what most are waiting for...

Requiem For A Dream needs to be a movie you see without anyone telling you even remotely what its about nor try to hype it up to be something special. If you happen to be "lucky" and just stumble across this film its a very powerful film that should make you feel... and if you don't feel for this film you must have completely missed the point... more or less refering to my initial statement... you either get it or you don't.

Definately need to add X3 to this list as being one of THE worst films in a very very long time... I can not believe how bad that finale was.. it completely murdered the trilogy in every respect.

Some others:

Spiderman 1&2 -- Spiderman was alright, but the second seemed like a complete rehash of the first with a diff villain.
All of Clint Eastwood' recent flicks... can't bash that Mystic River and Million Dollar Baby movie enough... BAH!
Matrix Revolutions -- The 2nd almost made the list but you must understand the Wachowski brothers didnt give a crap about the storyline after the first... the sequels were MEANT to be eye candy and eye candy only. I didn't add Reloaded simply because the action was enough to keep me entertained and not care about the storyline... but I knew the 3rd would be shear disappointment... and without a doubt it was
Harry Potter flicks -- ah same thing applies here as with the LoTR series...

quote:

Originally posted by Spike gladiator

quote:

Originally posted by |3 |_ @ Z 3 |) LoTR Trilogy

lol two of the greatest movies ever.

gladiator, 5 oscars...and at least 40 other awards world wide.
LOTR trilogy, 17 oscars...and at least 200 other awards world wide.

I don't see how these two films are overated, but that's your opinion...

gladiator was amazing
this thread is crap

quote:

Originally posted by evil_cookie gladiator, 5 oscars...and at least 40 other awards world wide.

haha overrated x 934373 orrr lack of decent movies?

quote:

Originally posted by evil_cookie lol two of the greatest movies ever. gladiator, 5 oscars...and at least 40 other awards world wide. LOTR trilogy, 17 oscars...and at least 200 other awards world wide. I don't see how these two films are overated, but that's your opinion...

LMAO your justification for a movie being good is because it won Oscars? LOL thats as bad as the DJ Mag top 100.

If you need award shows to tell you whats good and whats not then your clearly don't critique a film.. you simply follow the general public.

and this thread is great... we all need to be able to agree to disagree.. but most of you are not explaining why you think its sooo amazing or completely terrible.

quote:

Originally posted by |3 |_ @ Z 3 |) LMAO your justification for a movie being good is because it won Oscars? LOL thats as bad as the DJ Mag top 100. If you need award shows to tell you whats good and whats not then your clearly don't critique a film.. you simply follow the general public.

yeah I guess judging a movie based on the awards its won, the money its made...the fan base, the box office records it broke, the actors and directors who've done extremely well in the past...

is wrong.

your logic is...well, there is no logic to your post.

quote:

Originally posted by geroin gladiator was amazing this thread is crap

basically