 |
|
|
|
 |
Perfect_Cheezit
Machine Beat

Registered: Jul 2003
Location: MNTA #08
|
|
|
| quote: | Originally posted by idoru
You mean that some of the cultures in the Middle East that oppress women also value personal freedom? |
You don't think that these insurgent groups view themselves as fighting for a right of self-determination? Western governments have talked about human freedom, liberty and equality for centuries - that is, freedom, liberty and equality provided you're a citizen of their country, or if you're white and male. If not, then we get to torture you.
| quote: |
True. That's because each governing country governs in methods geared more towards their own culture rather than methods of cultures on the other side of the world that differ vastly from themselves. |
Well, yes, but that's not what I was talking about as much. Obviously a government of one society will be responsive to the demands of its own people. The question is more whether these governments are acting on a political push for a certain ethnicity or if they are governing for what they perceive to be the "culture" of their country. Say, for example, if the culture of "India" is Hindu, what about the millions of Sikhs and Muslims that live there? What does being Indian mean then? Like I said before, cultures aren't insular. Agreeing upon individual rights and agreeing to treat individuals with dignity do not deprive societies of their right to exist and function autonomously.
| quote: |
I'm kind of split on where I stand on this particular piece. Part of me agrees, but the other part, I dunno. We can't just go over and force our own beliefs on other cultures, that's just not right. |
I'm not saying we should force beliefs on anyone, because armed intervention is what causes a lot of these problems and political conflicts to manifest themselves. But it's not like components of a particular culture are moral-neutral if it deprives someone of basic dignity, like slavery whose basis is race or religion. Dismissing it like it's a component of their culture just simply ignores the political dimensions that made violence or degradation tolerable.
___________________
If you choose to pull the trigger - should your drama prove sincere - do it somewhere far away from here.
|
|
May-08-2007 23:39
|
|
|
 |
 |
Lebezniatnikov
Stupidity Annoys Me

Registered: Feb 2004
Location: DC
|
|
|
| quote: | Originally posted by idoru
I love you, in the most heterosexual way possible. |
I take that as the kindest of compliments.
| quote: | Originally posted by Perfect_Cheezit
There is no culture in the entire planet that doesn't value human life innately and there is no culture that doesn't value personal freedom. |
People certainly place different values on individual life -- look at cultures, for instance, where honor killings and human sacrifices are socially acceptable. A lot of it ties to conceptions of what is more representative of the good life: communal good or individual self-interest.
| quote: | | The problem with human rights is that it is enforced by states, and states will not enforce them. Individuals and communities, not governments, need to be taking stances against shit like this and not writing off the event like it's some inherent characteristic of people living in the Middle East that can never be changed. |
I don't know if you know it, but I agree with you a lot more than you might think.
| quote: | Originally posted by emc^2
I want to ask you a question. Before the whole tree-hugging, peace loving, "why can't we be friends" emo generation took root - what was the concept of original warfare?
|
Well, the wars generally had a purpose, other than nuking villages as deterrant.
| quote: | Originally posted by emc^2
humans are self-destructive. all our thought process becomes null and void once you enter primitive mindset like some of the people over in Middle East and other places. You can't use western mentality and basic respect for human life with stone-age cavemen. |
You're joking, right? The cultural insensitivity on your part is so ironic, seeing as it's exactly what you're criticizing on their part. It's no surprise that there's a war when both sides view their counterparts as stupid, primitive, immoral degenerates. I said I wasn't going to point out hypocrisy before, but well, I've changed my mind.
| quote: | Originally posted by Perfect_Cheezit
I'm not saying we should force beliefs on anyone, because armed intervention is what causes a lot of these problems and political conflicts to manifest themselves. But it's not like components of a particular culture are moral-neutral if it deprives someone of basic dignity, like slavery whose basis is race or religion. Dismissing it like it's a component of their culture just simply ignores the political dimensions that made violence or degradation tolerable. |
Yes, you're absolutely on point here.
| quote: | Originally posted by Sukhoi29SU
Two- I didn't create this topic in order to support my position relating to the current situation in Iraq- but since someone brought it up- I will say that I am in complete support of the current US involvement in Iraq. I think it was completely justified and necessary. And I think pulling all troops out now would be a major crime. |
You're right, you didn't mention it in this thread - I was simply going off some of your posts in PDD.
I think that's enough for now.
___________________
|
|
May-09-2007 17:38
|
|
|
 |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 10:36.
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|
Contact Us - return to tranceaddict
Powered by: Trance Music & vBulletin Forums
Copyright ©2000-2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Privacy Statement / DMCA
|