Ferrys remix isn't happy it's sad, sweet and turned a classic piece into trance, theres always going to have to be a beat & bassline that some determine as cheesey on it to do anything, and my main problem is that Tijs after bitching endlessly about not wanting to be another ferry corsten has remade a tune ferry made perfect in a trance sense
May-11-2003 22:43
tc-fan
dancing galaxy
Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Cubaleah , FL USA
the minimalistix mix is great also btw..
___________________
May-11-2003 22:43
Cobalt
Trance Isn't Trance
Registered: Apr 2002
Location: Vancouver, BC
Better than Ferry's, I think. It has more edge. But what is with the discordant bass-melody overlay right at the beginning? That needs to be snipped out.
I'm sure the flying Dutchman isn't too thrilled right now.
Also, both are products of their time. Ferry's remix represented the 99 trance sound, and Tiesto's mix is a natural progression of that to what trance sounds more like today.
May-11-2003 22:48
TimeportE
... Addicted Yet ?
Registered: Jul 2001
Location: The Netherlands in "Limburg City" Maastricht <Attention!!> 3000 posts REACHED
mmm i'll wait till i get a better rip of this one one thing is clear it totally rocked my boxers when i heared it live!! (but ferry remix is still one of my alltime fav so i dont think will outpass it )
btw... why keep babling about william orbit it's samuel barbers (from platoon)
Registered: Jun 2002
Location: NYC-New Haven- San Juan-Amsterdam / PRTA #1
quote:
Originally posted by Ian^
@ DJ Pio
Ferrys remix isn't happy it's sad, sweet and turned a classic piece into trance, theres always going to have to be a beat & bassline that some determine as cheesey on it to do anything, and my main problem is that Tijs after bitching endlessly about not wanting to be another ferry corsten has remade a tune ferry made perfect in a trance sense
I don't like and have never liked Ferry's remix, who cares? I don't like how he developed the harmony into a major key after the breakdown, it just doesn't sound right to me. I had played the original Barber a thousand times with my orchestra before the Ferry mix ever came out and when I heard that remix it sounded like an insult to Barber. Sorry if you don't like my opinion, but that's just the way it is.
And Tijs has proven to me enough times that he's above Ferry in every way (except beatmatching). However, it would be pointless to discuss that here because everyone knows that you're a Ferry Corsten whore and I'm a Tiesto whore.
edit: Cobalt's right. Both remixes are products of their time and I recognize that Ferry's mix is quality too production-wise (even if i don't like it).
May-11-2003 22:57
tc-fan
dancing galaxy
Registered: Oct 2000
Location: Cubaleah , FL USA
sorry to say but this mix is great..for a banging set...but ferry mix owns it...
___________________
May-11-2003 22:59
arturob
Supreme tranceaddict
Registered: Jan 2001
Location: Miami
heh.. thats why i love pvd.. owns tiesto and ferry in both, mixing and producing god i love this board
Registered: Jun 2002
Location: NYC-New Haven- San Juan-Amsterdam / PRTA #1
quote:
Originally posted by Starfox
heh.. thats why i love pvd.. owns tiesto and ferry in both, mixing and producing god i love this board
oh really, then I wanna hear a PvD 'rework' or re-edit of Barber's Adagio. It would be interesting to see how it would turn out with his amazingly original bassline
May-11-2003 23:14
Creamfields23
Bunga Bunga alliance
Registered: Sep 2001
Location: Tilburg City
After repeating this track a 100 times at work today, I was wondering this: If there is another world after this and I can take one tune over there-----------> It's this one
I would have paid that 45 euro with love just to here this track!!!
Can't wait for the DVD
May-11-2003 23:16
arecebo
see below
Registered: Dec 2001
Location: 388-400 Carroll St
This remix is fucking TUNE! Better than Ferry's in my opinion, but I'm not saying Ferry's isnt amazing... I just hope he will drop it on thursday for me
May-11-2003 23:20
Az
took me all the way back
Registered: Aug 2001
Location: Walking to John O'Groats for some spastics
quote:
Originally posted by Starfox
heh.. thats why i love pvd.. owns tiesto and ferry in both, mixing and producing
thats highly debateable
as he can't mix for shit
and his tunes sound the same
May-11-2003 23:22
Aya Brea
Design Evolved
Registered: Jun 2002
Location: Long Island, NY
the rip is too shitty to try and enjoy it...
maybe he'll play it friday