|
| quote: | Originally posted by Bierheld
After thinking about it a bit more, the reason why I dislike polls like DJmag's is because it's pure media logic in action.
What they're always trying to do is turn everything into a competition, even if it's clearly irrelevant. The way the actual dance music industry should work is to have scenes with like-minded people, bound either by location or musical preference. Who, unlike with politics for instance, should really have nothing to do with each other. There is no battle for absolute artistic supremacy, only journalists who are trying to justify their position as leaders of opinion, their relevance. We're all playing by their rules after all.
What you eventually get is that their lists become self fulfilling prophecies. The results of this poll and mainly it's top spots will be copied by other media without a slither of scepticism, leading to an increase in fame for those who managed to attain the top spots solidifying their positions even more. Which is why we see the top ten barely changing at all from year to year.
Now, if it turns out there was no legitimacy to their ranking in the first place, which is clearly the case since it can only ever be a representation of a small group of people's preferences (i.e. the people who know of the poll's existence and could be bothered to vote), you get a thoroughly fucked up situation.
So who actually is the top DJ or most popular DJ? It's all dry statistics. You would have to measure bookings and show attendees, album and single sales, prevalence in media from all over the world to get anything remotely accurate. Or you'd have to ask every single person in the world. It's not going to happen, just let it go. The scene would get much healthier if the whole globalist megalomania would end and DJ's would have to rely on word to word or local journalistic promotion. Actual talent would rise to the top rather then PR expertise. But that's just dreaming I guess. |
Well phucking said.
___________________
https://soundcloud.com/lentej
|